GW170817 Most Likely Made a Black Hole

Abstract

There are two outstanding issues regarding the neutron-star merger event GW170817: the nature of the compact remnant and the interstellar shock. The mass of the remnant of GW170817, $\sim$2.7 $M_{\odot }$, implies the remnant could be either a massive, rotating, neutron star, or a black hole. We report Chandra Director's Discretionary Time observations made in 2017 December and 2018 January, and we reanalyze earlier observations from 2017 August and 2017 September, in order to address these unresolved issues. We estimate the X-ray flux from a neutron star remnant and compare that to the measured X-ray flux. If we assume that the spin-down luminosity of any putative neutron star is converted to pulsar wind nebula X-ray emission in the 0.5-8 keV band with an efficiency of $10^{-3}$, for a dipole magnetic field with $3\times 10^{11}$ G < $B$ < $10^{14}$ G, a rising X-ray signal would result and would be brighter than that observed by day 107, we therefore conclude that the remnant of GW170817 is most likely a black hole. Independent of any assumptions of X-ray efficiency, however, if the remnant is a rapidly-rotating, magnetized, neutron star, the total energy in the external shock should rise by a factor $\sim$$10^2$ (to $\sim$$10^{52}$ erg) after a few years, therefore, Chandra observations over the next year or two that do not show substantial brightening will rule out such a remnant. The same observations can distinguish between two different models for the relativistic outflow, either an angular or radially varying structure.

10 pages, 4 figures, accepted to ApJL

References in corpus (16)

• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• Multi-messenger Observations of a Binary Neutron Star Merger
• Origin of the heavy elements in binary neutron-star mergers from a gravitational wave event
• Swope Supernova Survey 2017a (SSS17a), the Optical Counterpart to a Gravitational Wave Source
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. II. UV, Optical, and Near-IR Light Curves and Comparison to Kilonova Models
• The Physics of Gamma-Ray Bursts and Relativistic Jets
• The X-ray counterpart to the gravitational wave event GW 170817
• Illuminating Gravitational Waves: A Concordant Picture of Photons from a Neutron Star Merger
• Constraining the Maximum Mass of Neutron Stars From Multi-Messenger Observations of GW170817
• The Emergence of a Lanthanide-Rich Kilonova Following the Merger of Two Neutron Stars
• The Combined Ultraviolet, Optical, and Near-Infrared Light Curves of the Kilonova Associated with the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817: Unified Data Set, Analytic Models, and Physical Implications
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. V. Rising X-ray Emission from an Off-Axis Jet
• A mildly relativistic wide-angle outflow in the neutron star merger GW170817
• A Deep Chandra X-ray Study of Neutron Star Coalescence GW170817
• The Observable Signatures of GRB Cocoons
• Brightening X-ray Emission from GW170817/GRB170817A: Further Evidence for an Outflow

Cited by in corpus (45)

• Kilonovae
• Science with the Einstein Telescope: a comparison of different designs
• Gravitational waves from neutron star mergers and their relation to the nuclear equation of state
• A Decline in the X-ray through Radio Emission from GW170817 Continues to Support an Off-Axis Structured Jet
• Short GRB 160821B: a reverse shock, a refreshed shock, and a well-sampled kilonova
• The electromagnetic counterparts of compact binary mergers
• A long-lived neutron star merger remnant in GW170817: constraints and clues from X-ray observations
• Two years of non-thermal emission from the binary neutron star merger GW170817: rapid fading of the jet afterglow and first constraints on the kilonova fastest ejecta
• Search for gravitational waves from a long-lived remnant of the binary neutron star merger GW170817
• When Did the Remnant of GW170817 Collapse to a Black Hole?
• A magnetar-powered X-ray transient as the aftermath of a binary neutron-star merger
• A long-lived remnant neutron star after GW170817 inferred from its associated kilonova
• Afterglow Lightcurves from Misaligned Structured Jets
• The Optical Afterglow of GW170817: An Off-axis Structured Jet and Deep Constraints on a Globular Cluster Origin
• Unveiling the Engines of Fast Radio Bursts, Super-Luminous Supernovae, and Gamma-Ray Bursts
• A lesson from GW170817: most neutron star mergers result in tightly collimated successful GRB jets
• From $\gamma$ to Radio - The Electromagnetic Counterpart of GW 170817
• Evidence for X-ray Emission in Excess to the Jet Afterglow Decay 3.5 yrs After the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW 170817: A New Emission Component
• On the formation of GW190814
• Populations of stellar mass Black holes from binary systems
• Phase transitions in neutron stars and their links to gravitational waves
• GW170817 Afterglow Reveals that Short Gamma-Ray Bursts are Neutron Star Mergers
• Imprints of r-process heating on fall-back accretion: distinguishing black hole-neutron star from double neutron star mergers
• A Late-time Radio Survey of Short GRBs at $z<0.5$: New Constraints on the Remnants of Neutron Star Mergers
• A unified binary neutron star merger magnetar model for the Chandra X-ray transients CDF-S XT1 and XT2
• Constraining coherent low frequency radio flares from compact binary mergers
• X-ray guided gravitational-wave search for binary neutron star merger remnants
• High Tide: A Systematic Search for Ellipsoidal Variables in ASAS-SN
• GW170817: The energy extraction process of the off-axis relativistic outflow and the constraint on the equation of state of neutron stars
• Searching for fast extragalactic X-ray transients in Chandra surveys
• Discovery of one neutron star candidate from radial velocity monitoring
• Late-time radio observations of the short GRB200522A: constraints on the magnetar model
• Needle in a Bayes Stack: a Hierarchical Bayesian Method for Constraining the Neutron Star Equation of State with an Ensemble of Binary Neutron Star Post-merger Remnants
• Diagnosing the remnants of binary neutron star merger from GW170817/GRB170817A event
• Scattered Short Gamma-Ray Bursts as Electromagnetic Counterparts to Gravitational Waves and Implications of GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• Radio Forensics Could Unmask Nearby Off-axis Gamma-ray Bursts
• Central engine of GRB170817A: Neutron star versus Kerr black hole based on multimessenger calorimetry and event timing
• Late-Time Afterglow from Double-Sided Structured Jets: Application to GRB 170817A
• The Panchromatic Afterglow of GW170817: The full uniform dataset, modeling, comparison with previous results and implications
• Short duration gamma-ray bursts and their outflows in light of GW170817
• Observational prospects of double neutrons star mergers and their multi-messenger afterglows: LIGO discovery power, event rates and diversity
• The remnant of GW170817: a trapped neutron star with a hypermassive incompressible superfluid core
• Impact of Hot Inner Crust on Compact Stars at Finite Temperature
• Formation, Possible Detection and Consequences of Highly Magnetized Compact Stars
• Systematic study for gas-to-dust ratio of short gamma-ray burst afterglows