Fragile Topology and Wannier Obstructions

Abstract

Topological phases, such as Chern insulators, are defined in terms of additive indices that are stable against the addition of trivial degrees of freedom. Such topology presents an obstruction to any Wannier representation, namely, the representation of the electronic states in terms of symmetric, exponentially localized Wannier functions. Here, we address the converse question: Do obstructions to Wannier representation imply stable band topology? We answer this in the negative, pointing out that some bands can also display a distinct type of "fragile topology." Bands with fragile topology do not admit any Wannier representation by themselves, but such a representation becomes possible once certain additional trivial degrees of freedom are supplied. We construct a physical model of fragile topology on the honeycomb lattice that also helps resolve a recent puzzle in band theory. This model provides a counterexample to the assumption that splitting of an "elementary band representation" introduced in [Nature 547, 298--305 (2017)] leads to bands that are individually topological. Instead, half of the split bands of our model realizes a trivial band with exponentially localized symmetric Wannier functions, whereas the second half possess fragile topology. Our work highlights an important and previously overlooked connection between band structure and Wannier functions, and is expected to have far reaching consequences given the central role played by Wannier functions in the modeling of real materials.

(5.5+4) pages; 3 figures; 2 tables; v2: close to published version

References in corpus (17)

• Magic-angle graphene superlattices: a new platform for unconventional superconductivity
• Correlated Insulator Behaviour at Half-Filling in Magic Angle Graphene Superlattices
• Topological Insulators with Inversion Symmetry
• Classification of topological insulators and superconductors in three spatial dimensions
• Topological Crystalline Insulators
• Surface States of the Topological Insulator Bi_{1-x}Sb_x
• Bulk Topological Invariants in Noninteracting Point Group Symmetric Insulators
• Wannier representation of Z_2 topological insulators
• Exponential localization of Wannier functions in insulators
• Faithful Tight-binding Models and Fragile Topology of Magic-angle Bilayer Graphene
• Failure of Nielsen-Ninomiya theorem and fragile topology in two-dimensional systems with space-time inversion symmetry: application to twisted bilayer graphene at magic angle
• Band Structure of Twisted Bilayer Graphene: Emergent Symmetries, Commensurate Approximants and Wannier Obstructions
• Double crystallographic groups and their representations on the Bilbao Crystallographic Server
• Topological surface states in three-dimensional magnetic insulators
• Graph Theory Data for Topological Quantum Chemistry
• Compactly-supported Wannier functions and algebraic $K$-theory
• Distinct trivial phases protected by a point-group symmetry in quantum spin chains

Cited by in corpus (270)

• Non-Hermitian Physics
• The (High Quality) Topological Materials In The World
• Quantization of fractional corner charge in $C_n$-symmetric higher-order topological crystalline insulators
• Correlated states in twisted double bilayer graphene
• All "Magic Angles" Are "Stable" Topological
• Topological acoustics
• High-throughput calculations of magnetic topological materials
• Faithful Tight-binding Models and Fragile Topology of Magic-angle Bilayer Graphene
• Failure of Nielsen-Ninomiya theorem and fragile topology in two-dimensional systems with space-time inversion symmetry: application to twisted bilayer graphene at magic angle
• Higher-Order Topology, Monopole Nodal Lines, and the Origin of Large Fermi Arcs in Transition Metal Dichalcogenides XTe${}_2$ (X=Mo,W)
• Band Structure of Twisted Bilayer Graphene: Emergent Symmetries, Commensurate Approximants and Wannier Obstructions
• Superfluidity and Quantum Geometry in Twisted Multilayer Systems
• Experimental discovery of bulk-disclination correspondence
• Magnetic Topological Quantum Chemistry
• Topology-Bounded Superfluid Weight In Twisted Bilayer Graphene
• MATBG as Topological Heavy Fermion: I. Exact Mapping and Correlated Insulators
• Wilson loop approach to fragile topology of split elementary band representations and topological crystalline insulators with time reversal symmetry
• Band topology in classical waves: Wilson-loop approach to topological numbers and fragile topology
• Twisted Bilayer Graphene IV. Exact Insulator Ground States and Phase Diagram
• A fractional corner anomaly reveals higher-order topology
• Strong and Fragile Topological Dirac Semimetals with Higher-Order Fermi Arcs
• All Topological Bands of All Nonmagnetic Stoichiometric Materials
• Ferromagnetic Mott State in Twisted Graphene Bilayers at the Magic Angle
• Efficient Topological Materials Discovery Using Symmetry Indicators
• Topological Materials Discovery from Crystal Symmetry
• Twisted bilayer graphene III. Interacting Hamiltonian and exact symmetries
• Topological Euler class as a dynamical observable in optical lattices
• Topological Classification of Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians
• Fractional disclination charge in two-dimensional $C_n-$symmetric topological crystalline insulators
• Correlated insulating phases of twisted bilayer graphene at commensurate filling fractions: a Hartree-Fock study
• Real Space Invariants: Twisted Bulk-Boundary Correspondence of Fragile Topology
• Observation of non-Abelian topological semimetals and their phase transitions
• Unsupervised machine learning and band topology
• Twisted bilayer graphene. II. Stable symmetry anomaly
• Nematic topological semimetal and insulator in magic angle bilayer graphene at charge neutrality
• Geometric approach to fragile topology beyond symmetry indicators
• Boundary-obstructed topological phases
• Experimental characterization of fragile topology in an acoustic metamaterial
• Disconnected Elementary Band Representations, Fragile Topology, and Wilson Loops as Topological Indices: An Example on the Triangular Lattice
• Fragile topology and flat-band superconductivity in the strong-coupling regime
• Band Representations and Topological Quantum Chemistry
• Superfluid weight bounds from symmetry and quantum geometry in flat bands
• Topological and geometrical aspects of band theory
• Twisted bilayer graphene I. Matrix elements, approximations, perturbation theory and a $k\cdot p$ 2-Band model
• Tutorial: Computing topological invariants in two-dimensional photonic crystals
• Fractional corner charges in spin-orbit coupled crystals
• Hybrid skin-topological modes without asymmetric couplings
• Coulomb interaction, phonons, and superconductivity in twisted bilayer graphene
• Refined symmetry indicators for topological superconductors in all space groups
• Correlation-induced insulating topological phases at charge neutrality in twisted bilayer graphene
• The Landau Level of Fragile Topology
• Topological correspondence between magnetic space group representations
• Fragile Topology Protected by Inversion Symmetry: Diagnosis, Bulk-Boundary Correspondence, and Wilson Loop
• Phonons as a platform for non-Abelian braiding and its manifestation in layered silicates
• Spin-Orbit-Induced Topological Flat Bands in Line and Split Graphs of Bipartite Lattices
• Engineering Fragile Topology in Photonic Crystals: Topological Quantum Chemistry of Light
• Stiefel-Whitney classes and topological phases in band theory
• Symmetry representation approach to topological invariants in $C_{2z}T$-symmetric systems
• Multiple Flat Bands and Topological Hofstadter Butterfly in Twisted Bilayer Graphene Close to the Second Magic Angle
• Derivation of Wannier orbitals and minimal-basis tight-binding hamiltonians for twisted bilayer graphene: a first-principles approach
• Shift insulators: rotation-protected two-dimensional topological crystalline insulators
• Realization of Topological Mott Insulator in a Twisted Bilayer Graphene Lattice Model
• Spectral signatures of the surface anomalous Hall effect in magnetic axion insulators
• Exact Diagonalization for Magic-Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene
• Fragile Phases As Affine Monoids: Classification and Material Examples
• ${\mathbb{Z}}_Q$ Berry Phase for Higher-Order Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases
• Momentum space quantum Monte Carlo on twisted bilayer Graphene
• Symmetry indicators of band topology
• From spinon band topology to the symmetry quantum numbers of monopoles in Dirac spin liquids
• Valley Jahn-Teller effect in twisted bilayer graphene
• Magic-angle semimetals
• Classification of Crystalline Topological Insulators and Superconductors with Point Group Symmetries
• Crystallographic splitting theorem for band representations and fragile topological photonic crystals
• Chiral Magic-Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene in a Magnetic Field: Landau Level Correspondence, Exact Wavefunctions and Fractional Chern Insulators
• Topological Phases of Photonic Crystals under Crystalline Symmetries
• Detection of Topological Materials with Machine Learning
• Spin-Resolved Topology and Partial Axion Angles in Three-Dimensional Insulators
• Topological acoustic triple point
• Wannier representation of Floquet topological states
• Multicellularity of delicate topological insulators
• Bulk-corner correspondence of time-reversal symmetric insulators: deduplicating real-space invariants
• Fragile topological phases in interacting systems
• Weyl phonons in chiral crystals
• Dynamical correlations and order in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene
• Moiré magnons in twisted bilayer magnets with collinear order
• Topological exact flat bands in two dimensional materials under periodic strain
• Subdimensional topologies, indicators and higher order phases
• Topological Flat Bands and Correlated States in Twisted Monolayer-Bilayer Graphene
• Delicate topology protected by rotation symmetry: Crystalline Hopf insulators and beyond
• Geometric characterization of anomalous Landau levels of isolated flat bands
• Ferromagnetism and its stability from the one-magnon spectrum in twisted bilayer graphene
• Observation of topological Euler insulators with a trapped-ion quantum simulator
• Homotopy, Symmetry, and Non-Hermitian Band Topology
• Topological Zero-Dimensional Defect and Flux States in Three-Dimensional Insulators
• Exciton Proliferation and Fate of the Topological Mott Insulator in a Twisted Bilayer Graphene Lattice Model
• Quantum Geometric Contributions to the BKT Transition: Beyond Mean Field Theory
• Fragile topology in line-graph lattices with two, three, or four gapped flat bands
• Manipulation and braiding of Weyl nodes using symmetry-constrained phase transitions
• Berry bands and pseudo-spin of topological photonic phases
• General construction of flat bands with and without band crossings based on wave function singularity
• Teleportation of Berry curvature on the surface of a Hopf insulator
• Tenfold Topology of Crystals: Unified classification of crystalline topological insulators and superconductors
• Dynamical properties of collective excitations in twisted bilayer Graphene
• Fragile topologically flat band in the checkerboard antiferromagnetic monolayer FeSe
• Correlated Insulating Phases in the Twisted Bilayer Graphene
• Optical manifestations and bounds of topological Euler class
• TBG as Topological Heavy Fermion: II. Analytical approximations of the model parameters
• Local markers for crystalline topology
• Local Topological Markers in Odd Dimensions
• Tunable Fragile Topology in Floquet Systems
• Local Kekulé distortion turns twisted bilayer graphene into topological Mott insulators and superconductors
• Piezoelectricity and Topological Quantum Phase Transitions in Two-Dimensional Spin-Orbit Coupled Crystals with Time-Reversal Symmetry
• Classification of crystalline insulators without symmetry indicators: atomic and fragile topological phases in twofold rotation symmetric systems
• Application of the induction procedure and the Smith Decomposition in the calculation and topological classification of electronic band structures in the 230 space groups
• Classification of Dirac points with higher-order Fermi arcs
• $N$-band Hopf insulator
• Doubled Quantum Spin Hall Effect with High-Spin Chern Number in $\alpha$-Antimonene and $\alpha$-Bismuthene
• An accurate tight binding model for twisted bilayer graphene describes topological flat bands without geometric relaxation
• Location and topology of the fundamental gap in photonic crystals
• Topological continuum charges of acoustic phonons in 2D
• Topological Crystalline Phases in a Disordered Inversion-Symmetric Chain
• Symmetry Analysis of Anomalous Floquet Topological Phases
• Symmetry-based approach to nodal structures: Unification of compatibility relations and gapless point classifications
• Magic angles in twisted bilayer graphene near commensuration: Towards a hypermagic regime
• Quantum Monte Carlo sign bounds, topological Mott insulator and thermodynamic transitions in twisted bilayer graphene model
• Topology invisible to eigenvalues in obstructed atomic insulators
• No-go theorem for topological insulators and sure-fire recipe for Chern insulators
• Interacting topological quantum chemistry of Mott atomic limits
• Constrained Random Phase Approximation of the effective Coulomb interaction in lattice models of twisted bilayer graphene
• Flat bands with band crossings enforced by symmetry representation
• Origin of band flatness and constraints of higher Chern numbers
• Fragile phonon topology on the honeycomb lattice with time-reversal symmetry
• High-throughput screening for Weyl Semimetals with S${}_4$ Symmetry
• Magnon corner states in twisted bilayer honeycomb magnets
• Rapid Exploration of Topological Band Structures using Deep Learning
• Landau Levels of the Euler Class Topology
• Absence of topological protection of the interface states in ${\mathbb{Z}}_2$ photonic crystals
• Non-Compact Atomic Insulators
• Current Switching of Valley Polarization in Twisted Bilayer Graphene
• Interacting Topological Quantum Chemistry in 2D: Many-body Real Space Invariants
• High transmission in twisted bilayer graphene with angle disorder
• Identifying Higher Order Topology and Fractional Corner Charge Using Entanglement Spectra
• Fractional corner charges in a 2D super-lattice Bose-Hubbard model
• Topological Superconductivity from Unconventional Band Degeneracy with Conventional Pairing
• Gate-defined wires in twisted bilayer graphene: from electrical detection of inter-valley coherence to internally engineered Majorana modes
• Interacting second-order topological insulators in one-dimensional fermions with correlated hopping
• Multiplicative topological phases
• Multiferroicity and Topology in Twisted Transition Metal Dichalcogenides
• Three-dimensional $\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}$-symmetric topological phases with Pontryagin index
• Correlated Fragile Topology: a Parton Approach
• Interferometry of non-Abelian band singularities and Euler class topology
• Unsupervised learning of topological phase diagram using topological data analysis
• From Atomic Semimetal to Topological Nontrivial Insulator
• Spectroscopic signature of obstructed surface states in SrIn${}_2$P${}_2$
• Dynamics of self-dual kagome metamaterials and the emergence of fragile topology
• Superconductivity in unconventional metals
• Optical $N$-insulators: topological obstructions in the atomistic susceptibility tensor
• Embedded Topological Semimetals
• Real Hopf Insulator
• Transport and spectral properties of magic angle twisted bilayer graphene junctions based on local orbital models
• Topology in time-reversal symmetric crystals
• Stability of Topological character of Weyl Semi-metal, and Topological Dipole in Holography
• Non-Hermitian Origin of Detachable Boundary States in Topological Insulators
• Effective action approach to the filling anomaly in crystalline topological matter
• Orbital shift-induced boundary obstructed topological materials with a large energy gap
• Topological phonon analysis of the 2D buckled honeycomb lattice: an application to real materials
• Inducing a many-body topological state of matter through Coulomb-engineered local interactions
• Rational boundary charge in one-dimensional systems with interaction and disorder
• Glassy word problems: ultraslow relaxation, Hilbert space jamming, and computational complexity
• Projected spin texture as a bulk indicator of fragile topology
• Topologically distinct atomic insulators
• Generalized Fermion Doubling Theorems: Classification of 2D Nodal Systems in Terms of Wallpaper Groups
• Flat bands with fragile topology through superlattice engineering on single-layer graphene
• Inherited topological superconductivity in two-dimensional Dirac semimetals
• Electronic structure and spin-lattice relaxation in superconducting vortex states on the kagome lattice near van Hove filling
• Realizing and detecting Stiefel-Whitney insulators in an optical Raman lattice
• Homotopic classification of band structures: Stable, fragile, delicate, and stable representation-protected topology
• Dynamical Fragile Topology in Floquet Crystals
• Chern-insulator phases and spontaneous spin and valley order in a moiré lattice model for magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene
• On the nature of the correlated insulator states in twisted bilayer graphene
• Anderson Critical Metal Phase in Trivial States Protected by Average Magnetic Crystalline Symmetry
• Rotoinversion-symmetric bulk-hinge correspondence and its applications to higher-order Weyl semimetals
• Energy density as a probe of band representations in photonic crystals
• Protected Gapless Edge States In Trivial Topology
• Andreev reflection in Euler materials
• Topological obstructed atomic limit by annihilating Dirac fermions
• A diagnosis of explicit symmetry breaking in the tight-binding constructions for symmetry-protected topological systems
• Gapping fragile topological bands by interactions
• Theory of Dirac Spin-Orbital Liquids: monopoles, anomalies, and applications to $SU(4)$ honeycomb models
• Regularized lattice theory for spatially dispersive nonlinear optical conductivities
• Kagome and honeycomb flat bands in moiré graphene
• Textured Exciton Insulators
• Revisiting Bloch electrons in magnetic field: Hofstadter physics via hybrid Wannier states
• Optimally Localized Wannier Functions for 2D Chern Insulators
• Majorana corner modes in unconventional monolayers of the 1T-PtSe2 family
• Observation of floating surface state in obstructed atomic insulator candidate NiP${}_2$
• Simulating Higher-Order Topological Insulators in Density Wave Insulators
• Diagnosis of topological nodal lines with nontrivial monopole charge in the presence of rotation symmetries
• The topological invariants of rotationally symmetric crystals
• Theory of Anomalous Floquet Higher-Order Topology: Classification, Characterization, and Bulk-Boundary Correspondence
• Fractal Surface States in Three-Dimensional Topological Quasicrystals
• Fractional corner charges in threefold-symmetric two-dimensional materials with fragile topology
• Superconductivity in a Topological Lattice Model with Strong Repulsion
• Antichiral surface states and Su-Schrieffer-Heeger physics in rutile altermagnets
• Construction of low-energy symmetric Hamiltonians and Hubbard parameters for twisted multilayer systems using ab-initio input
• Two-dimensional orbital-obstructed insulators with higher-order band topology
• Probing fragile topology with a screw dislocation
• Second Euler number in four dimensional synthetic matter
• Fragile topological phase on the triangular kagome lattice and its bulk-boundary correspondence
• Kitaev Building-block Construction for Inversion-Protected Higher-order Topological Superconductors
• Spin Weyl Topological Insulators
• The Future of the Correlated Electron Problem
• Topologically nontrivial and trivial flat bands via weak and strong interlayer coupling in twisted bilayer honeycomb optical lattices for ultracold atoms
• Omnidirectional domain wall modes protected by fragile topological states
• General corner charge formulas in various tetrahedral and cubic space groups
• Bulk-entanglement spectrum correspondence in $PT$- and $PC$-symmetric topological insulators and superconductors
• $K$-theory classification of Wannier localizability and detachable topological boundary states
• Punctured-Chern topological invariants for semi-metallic bandstructures
• Topological insulators on fractal lattices: A general principle of construction
• Topological phases of amorphous matter
• Quantized thermal and spin transports of dirty planar topological superconductors
• From quantum geometry to non-linear optics and gerbes: Recent advances in topological band theory
• Many-body quantum catalysts for transforming between phases of matter
• Higher order topological state induced by $d$-wave competing orders in high-T${}_c$ superconductor based heterostructure
• Universality of Abelian and non-Abelian Wannier functions in one dimension
• Fragile topology in nodal-line semimetal superconductors
• IrRep: symmetry eigenvalues and irreducible representations of ab initio band structures
• Transversality-Enforced Tight-Binding Models for 3D Photonic Crystals aided by Topological Quantum Chemistry
• Simple realization of a fragile topological lattice with quasi flat-bands in a microcavity array
• Tunable symmetry-protected higher-order topological states with fermionic atoms in bilayer optical lattices
• Representation-protected topology of spin-singlet $s$-wave superconductors
• Homotopy invariant in time-reversal and twofold rotation symmetric systems
• Topological insulators and geometry of vector bundles
• Incommensurability-induced sub-ballistic narrow-band-states in twisted bilayer graphene
• Second-order topological insulator and fragile topology in topological circuitry simulation
• Van der Waals Heterostructure Pt${}_2$HgSe${}_3$/CrI${}_3$ for Topological Valleytronics
• Mott transition and magnetism in a fragile topological insulator
• Topological phase transition from periodic edge states in moiré superlattices
• High-chirality and multiquaternion Weyl nodes in hexagonal ReO${}_3$
• Topological Triviality of Flat Hamiltonians
• Hopf Semimetals
• PT-symmetric Non-Hermitian Hopf Metal
• Interacting Crystalline Topological Insulators in two-dimensions with Time-Reversal Symmetry
• Hilbert band complexes and their applications
• Generalized Peierls substitution for Wannier obstructions: response to disorder and interactions
• Superfluid stiffness of superconductors with delicate topology
• Dynamically Characterizing the Structures of Dirac Points via Wave Packets
• Various electronic crystal phases in rhombohedral graphene multilayers
• Frustration-free free fermions
• Frustration-free free fermions and beyond
• Identifying Anyonic Topological Order in Fractional Quantum Anomalous Hall Systems
• Quantum Magnetism in Wannier-Obstructed Mott Insulators
• Fragile topological insulators protected by rotation symmetry without spin-orbit coupling
• Entanglement-enabled symmetry-breaking orders
• Anomalous gapped boundaries between surface topological orders in higher-order topological insulators and superconductors with inversion symmetry
• Nodal higher-order topological superconductivity from C6-symmetric Dirac semimetals
• Dynamical Symmetry Indicators for Floquet Crystals
• Knot Morphing Algorithm for Quantum `Fragile Topology'
• Topological property of graphene with triangular array of nanoholes
• Analysis of the singular band structure occurring in one-dimensional topological normal and superfluid fermionic systems: A pedagogical description
• Particle-hole asymmetric phases in doped twisted bilayer graphene
• Topological Classification of Gapped/Gap-preserving Rational Space-Time Crystal Systems
• Reduced Wannier representation for topological bands
• Phase-Space Approach to Wannier Pairing and Bogoliubov Orbitals in Square-Octagon Lattices
• Exploiting $\vartheta -$functions for the identification of topological materials
• Topological Invariants of a Filling-Enforced Quantum Band Insulator
• Projected branes as platforms for crystalline, superconducting, and higher-order topological phases
• Crystallographic Interacting Topological Phases and Equivariant Cohomology: To assume or not to assume
• Design Principles for Topological Thermoelectrics
• When Wannier centers jump: Critical points between atomic insulating phases