Solving the conundrum of intervening strong MgII absorbers towards GRBs and quasars

Abstract

Previous studies have shown that the incidence rate of intervening strong MgII absorbers towards GRBs were a factor of 2 - 4 higher than towards quasars. Exploring the similar sized and uniformly selected legacy data sets XQ-100 and XSGRB, each consisting of 100 quasar and 81 GRB afterglow spectra obtained with a single instrument (VLT/X-shooter), we demonstrate that there is no disagreement in the number density of strong MgII absorbers with rest-frame equivalent widths $W_r^{2796}>$ 1 Å towards GRBs and quasars in the redshift range 0.1 < z < 5. With large and similar sample sizes, and path length coverages of $\Delta$z = 57.8 and 254.4 for GRBs and quasars, respectively, the incidences of intervening absorbers are consistent within 1 sigma uncertainty levels at all redshifts. For absorbers at z < 2.3 the incidence towards GRBs is a factor of 1.5$\pm$0.4 higher than the expected number of strong MgII absorbers in SDSS quasar spectra, while for quasar absorbers observed with X-shooter we find an excess factor of 1.4$\pm$0.2 relative to SDSS quasars. Conversely, the incidence rates agree at all redshifts with reported high spectral resolution quasar data, and no excess is found. The only remaining discrepancy in incidences is between SDSS MgII catalogues and high spectral resolution studies. The rest-frame equivalent width distribution also agrees to within 1 sigma uncertainty levels between the GRB and quasar samples. Intervening strong MgII absorbers towards GRBs are therefore neither unusually frequent, nor unusually strong.

arXiv comment10 pages, accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (47)

• Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
• A luminous quasar at a redshift of z = 7.085
• X-shooter, the new wide band intermediate resolution spectrograph at the ESO Very Large Telescope
• Automated data reduction workflows for astronomy
• A glimpse of the end of the dark ages: the gamma-ray burst of 23 April 2009 at redshift 8.3
• GRB 090423 at a redshift of z~8.1
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Quasar Catalog: twelfth data release
• Low-Resolution Spectroscopy of Gamma-ray Burst Optical Afterglows: Biases in the Swift Sample and Characterization of the Absorbers
• Mg II Absorption Systems in SDSS QSO Spectra
• The JHU-SDSS metal absorption line catalog: redshift evolution and properties of Mg II absorbers
• On the Incidence and Kinematics of Strong Mg II Absorbers
• The line-of-sight towards GRB 030429 at z = 2.66: Probing the matter at stellar, galactic and intergalactic scales
• XQ-100: A legacy survey of one hundred 3.5 < z < 4.5 quasars observed with VLT/XSHOOTER
• Probing star formation across cosmic time with absorption line systems
• Lensing, reddening and extinction effects of MgII absorbers from z=0.4 to z=2
• Molecular Hydrogen in the Damped Lyman-alpha System towards GRB 120815A at z=2.36
• On the Incidence of Strong MgII Absorbers Along GRB Sightlines
• A Survey of MgII Absorption at 2 < z < 6 with Magellan / FIRE: I: Sample and Evolution of the MgII Frequency
• The evolution of neutral gas in damped Lyman $\alpha$ systems from the XQ-100 survey
• The distribution of equivalent widths in long GRB afterglow spectra
• The CORALS Survey II: Clues to Galaxy Clustering Around QSOs from z_abs ~ z_em Damped Lyman Alpha Systems
• Statistics and characteristics of MgII absorbers along GRB lines of sight observed with VLT-UVES
• An efficient technique for pre-selecting low redshift damped Lyman alpha systems
• The Number Density of 0.6 < z < 1.7 MgII Systems from CORALS: Observational Biases at Intermediate Redshift
• Three intervening galaxy absorbers towards GRB060418: faint and dusty?
• Chemical abundances of damped Lyman alpha systems in the XQ-100 survey
• Intervening Metal Systems in GRB and QSO sight-lines: The Mgii and Civ Question
• Strong MgII systems in quasar and gamma-ray burst spectra
• Precious Metals in SDSS Quasar Spectra II: Tracking the Evolution of Strong, 0.4 < z < 2.3 MgII Absorbers with Thousands of Systems
• The High A(V) Quasar Survey: Reddened quasi-stellar objects selected from optical/near-infrared photometry - II
• The extended High A(V) Quasar Survey: Searching for dusty absorbers toward mid-infrared selected quasars
• Disparate MgII Absorption Statistics towards Quasars and Gamma-Ray Bursts : A Possible Explanation
• On the Incidence of C IV Absorbers Along the Sightlines to Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Casting light on the 'anomalous' statistics of Mg II absorbers toward Gamma-Ray Burst afterglows: the incidence of weak systems
• Dusty MgII absorbers: population statistics, extinction curves and gamma-ray burst sightlines
• Incidence of MgII absorbers towards Blazars and the GRB/QSO puzzle
• Testing the Possible Intrinsic Origin of the Excess of Very Strong MgII Absorbers Along GRB Lines-of-Sight
• Metallicities and dust content of proximate damped Lyman alpha systems in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The high A_V Quasar Survey: A z=2.027 metal-rich damped Lyman-alpha absorber towards a red quasar at z=3.21
• An Imaging and Spectroscopic Study of Four Strong MgII Absorbers Revealed By GRB060418
• On the selection of damped Lyman alpha systems using MgII absorption at 2<z<4
• An Independent Measurement of the Incidence of MgII Absorbers along Gamma-Ray Burst Sightlines: the End of the Mystery?
• Intervening Mg II absorption systems from the SDSS DR12 quasar spectra
• Direct Observational Test Rules Out Small MgII Absorbers
• The Redshift Distribution of Intervening Weak MgII Quasar Absorbers and a Curious Dependence on Quasar Luminosity
• Constraints on the relative sizes of intervening Mg II-absorbing clouds and quasar emitting regions
• On the significance of the excess number of strong MgII absorbers observed towards Gamma-ray bursts

Cited by in corpus (10)

• The peculiar short-duration GRB 200826A and its supernova
• The X-shooter GRB afterglow legacy sample (XS-GRB)
• MUSE-ALMA Halos V: Physical properties and environment of z < 1.4 HI quasar absorbers
• Metal enrichment and evolution in four z > 6.5 quasar sightlines observed with JWST/NIRSpec
• Evidence of First Stars-enriched Gas in High-redshift Absorbers
• A quasar hiding behind two dusty absorbers. Quantifying the selection bias of metal-rich, damped Lyman-alpha absorption systems
• Sub-damped Lyman alpha systems in the XQ-100 survey I -- Identification and contribution to the cosmological HI budget
• Sub-damped Lyman alpha systems in the XQ-100 survey II -- Chemical evolution at 2.4<z<4.3
• X-shooter and ALMA spectroscopy of GRB 161023A - A study of metals and molecules in the line of sight towards a luminous GRB
• Rapid Response Mode observations of GRB 160203A: Looking for fine-structure line variability at z=3.52