On the significance of the excess number of strong MgII absorbers observed towards Gamma-ray bursts
arXiv:1301.0646 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/766/1/23
Abstract
The number of strong (equivalent width > 1A) MgII absorbers observed towards Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) has been found to be statistically larger than the number of strong absorbers towards quasi-stellar objects (QSOs). We formalize this "MgII problem" and present a detailed explanation of the statistical tools required to assess the significance of the discrepancy. We find the problem exists at the 4σ level for GRBs with high-resolution spectra. It has been suggested that the discrepancy can be resolved by the combination of a dust obscuration bias towards QSOs, and a strong gravitational lensing bias towards GRBs. We investigate one of the two most probable lensed GRBs that we presented in our previous work (GRB020405; Rapoport et al.) and find it not to be strongly gravitationally lensed, constraining the percentage of lensed GRBs to be < 35% (2σ). Dust obscuration of QSOs has been estimated to be a significant effect with dusty MgII systems removing ~20% of absorbed objects from flux-limited QSO samples. We find that if ~30% of the strong MgII systems towards QSOs are missing from the observed samples, then GRBs and QSOs would have comparable numbers of absorbers per unit redshift. Thus, gravitational lensing bias is likely to make only a modest contribution to solving the MgII problem. However, if the dust obscuration bias has been slightly underestimated, the MgII problem would no longer persist.
arXiv comment7 pages, 5 figures. Submitted to ApJ. After referee report revision
References in corpus (27)
- The host of GRB 030323 at z=3.372: a very high column density DLA system with a low metallicity
- On the Incidence and Kinematics of Strong Mg II Absorbers
- The line-of-sight towards GRB 030429 at z = 2.66: Probing the matter at stellar, galactic and intergalactic scales
- Optical Spectropolarimetry of the GRB 020813 Afterglow
- Spectroscopy of GRB 050505 at z=4.275: A logN(HI)=22.1 DLA Host Galaxy and the Nature of the Progenitor
- High-Redshift Starbursting Dwarf Galaxies Revealed by GRB Afterglows
- Optical and near-infrared observations of the GRB020405 afterglow
- On the Incidence of Strong MgII Absorbers Along GRB Sightlines
- Probing a GRB progenitor at a redshift of z=2: a comprehensive observing campaign of the afterglow of GRB 030226
- GRB 071003: Broadband Follow-up Observations of a Very Bright Gamma-Ray Burst in a Galactic Halo
- Keck Spectroscopy and HST Imaging of GRB 000926: Probing a Host Galaxy at z = 2. 038
- The Pittsburgh Sloan Digital Sky Survey MgII Quasar Absorption-Line Survey Catalog
- Time-Dependent Optical Spectroscopy of GRB 010222: Clues to the GRB Environment
- Statistics and characteristics of MgII absorbers along GRB lines of sight observed with VLT-UVES
- Photometry and spectroscopy of GRB 060526: A detailed study of the afterglow and host galaxy of a z=3.2 gamma-ray burst
- Three intervening galaxy absorbers towards GRB060418: faint and dusty?
- Strong MgII systems in quasar and gamma-ray burst spectra
- Strongly Variable z=1.48 FeII and MgII Absorption in the Spectra of z=4.05 GRB 060206
- Physics of the GRB 030328 afterglow and its environment
- Dusty MgII absorbers: population statistics, extinction curves and gamma-ray burst sightlines
- Testing the Possible Intrinsic Origin of the Excess of Very Strong MgII Absorbers Along GRB Lines-of-Sight
- GRB 081029: A Gamma-Ray Burst with a Multi-Component Afterglow
- Dusty MgII Absorbers: Implications for the GRB/Quasar Incidence Discrepancy
- A gravitational lensing explanation for the excess of strong Mg-II absorbers in GRB afterglow spectra
- The Multi-Band Magnification Bias for Gravitational Lenses
- Testing the gravitational lensing explanation for the MgII problem in GRBs
- Constraints on the relative sizes of intervening Mg II-absorbing clouds and quasar emitting regions
Cited by in corpus (7)
- Composition of Early Planetary Atmospheres I: Connecting Disk Astrochemistry to the Formation of Planetary Atmospheres
- X-ray absorption evolution in Gamma-Ray Bursts: intergalactic medium or evolutionary signature of their host galaxies?
- Herschel survey and modelling of externally-illuminated photoevaporating protoplanetary disks
- An Independent Measurement of the Incidence of MgII Absorbers along Gamma-Ray Burst Sightlines: the End of the Mystery?
- Solving the conundrum of intervening strong MgII absorbers towards GRBs and quasars
- Euclid preparation. Optical emission-line predictions of intermediate-z galaxy populations in GAEA for the Euclid Deep and Wide Surveys
- GRBs as Probes of the IGM