Past of a quantum particle: Common sense prevails
arXiv:1704.03722 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.96.022126
Abstract
We analyze Vaidman's three-path interferometer with weak path marking [Phys. Rev. A 87, 052104 (2013)] and find that common sense yields correct statements about the particle's path through the interferometer. This disagrees with the original claim that the particles have discontinuous trajectories at odds with common sense. In our analysis, "the particle's path" has operational meaning as acquired by a path-discriminating measurement. For a quantum-mechanical experimental demonstration of the case, one should perform a single-photon version of the experiment by Danan et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 240402 (2013)] with unambiguous path discrimination. We present a detailed proposal for such an experiment.
arXiv commentv1: 20 pages, 15 figures; v2 and v3: 20 pages, 16 figures, text and figures edited, references updated
References in corpus (22)
- Ultra-bright source of polarization-entangled photons
- Optimum Unambiguous Discrimination Between Linearly Independent Symmetric States
- The past of a quantum particle
- Experimental Demonstration of Optimal Unambiguous State Discrimination
- Optimal distinction between non-orthogonal quantum states
- Particle Path Through a Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer
- Tracing the past of a quantum particle
- Interpreting a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer with classical optics
- Can a Dove prism change the past of a single photon?
- Knowing "where the photons have been"
- Comment on "Asking Photons Where Have They Been"
- Experimental observation of anomalous trajectories of single photons
- Comment on "Which-way information in a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer"
- Control of quantum interference in the quantum eraser
- Comment on "One-state vector formalism for the evolution of a quantum state through nested Mach-Zehnder interferometers"
- Paradox of Photons Disconnected Trajectories Being Located by Means of "Weak Measurements" in the Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer
- An Improved Experiment to Determine the `Past of a Particle' in the Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer
- How well can you know the edge of a quantum pyramid?
- A Comment on "Paradox of photons disconnected trajectories being located by means of 'weak measurements' in the nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer"
- Measuring evolution of a photon in an interferometer with spectrally-resolved modes
- Response to the Comment on "Paradox of Photons Disconnected Trajectories Being Located by Means of "Weak Measurements" in the Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer" (JETP Letters 105, 152 (2017))
- Controllable generation of mixed two-photon states
Cited by in corpus (28)
- Comment on "Past of a quantum particle revisited"
- Weak values and quantum properties
- Multifold paths of neutrons in the three-beam interferometer detected by tiny energy-kick
- Analysis of counterfactuality of counterfactual communication protocols
- How Quantum is Quantum Counterfactual Communication?
- When photons are lying about where they have been
- Weak values and the past of a quantum particle
- The Weak Reality that Makes Quantum Phenomena more Natural: Novel Insights and Experiments
- Reply to "Comment on `Past of a quantum particle revisited' "
- Past of a particle in an entangled state
- Reply to Comment on "Null weak values and the past of a quantum particle" by D. Sokolovski
- Unambiguous path discrimination in a two-path interferometer
- Do weak values capture the complete truth about the past of a quantum particle?
- From Counterportation to Local Wormholes
- Three approaches for analyzing the counterfactuality of counterfactual protocols
- A possible solution to the which-way problem of quantum interference
- Spectra in nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer experiments
- Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements
- Apparent quantum paradoxes as simple interference: Quantum violation of the pigeonhole principle and exchange of properties between quantum particles
- Comment on "Multifold paths of neutrons in the three-beam interferometer detected by a tiny energy kick"
- Weak values from path integrals
- Erasing the which-path information of photons
- Separating a particle's mass from its momentum
- Quantum weak values and the 'which way?' question
- Time-symmetry and topology of the Aharonov-Bohm effect
- Quantum coherence and negative quasi probabilities in a contextual three-path interferometer
- Do neutrons disagree with photons about where they have been inside an interferometer?
- Reply to Comment on "Multitime Quantum Communication: Interesting But Not Counterfactual" by L. Vaidman