Weak values and the past of a quantum particle

Abstract

We investigate four key issues with using a nonzero weak value of the spatial projection operator to infer the past path of an individual quantum particle. First, we note that weak measurements disturb a system, so any approach relying on such a perturbation to determine the location of a quantum particle describes the state of a disturbed system, not that of a hypothetical undisturbed system. Secondly, even assuming no disturbance, there is no reason to associate the non-zero weak value of an operator containing the spatial projection operator with the classical idea of `particle presence'. Thirdly, weak values are only measurable over ensembles, and so to infer properties of individual particles from values of them is problematic. Finally, weak value approaches to the path of a particle do not provide information beyond standard quantum mechanics (and the classical modes supporting the experiment). We know of no experiment with testable consequences that demonstrates a connection between particle presence and weak values.

arXiv comment10 pages, 2 figures. Matches published version

References in corpus (40)

• Ultrasensitive Beam Deflection Measurement via Interferometric Weak Value Amplification
• Colloquium: Understanding Quantum Weak Values: Basics and Applications
• Technical advantages for weak value amplification: When less is more
• Protocol for direct counterfactual quantum communication
• Quantum Cheshire Cats
• The past of a quantum particle
• Fast light, slow light, and phase singularities: a connection to generalized weak values
• Weak Value Amplification Can Outperform Conventional Measurement in the Presence of Detector Saturation
• Weak-Measurement Elements of Reality
• Particle Path Through a Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer
• "No Information Without Disturbance": Quantum Limitations of Measurement
• Tracing the past of a quantum particle
• Protocol for Counterfactually Transporting an Unknown Qubit
• Comment on "Protocol for Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communication" [arXiv:1206.2042]
• Past of a quantum particle: Common sense prevails
• Cherenkov radiation and superluminal particles
• Modification of "Counterfactual communication protocols" which eliminates weak particle traces
• The Case of the Disappearing (and Re-Appearing) Particle
• Comment on "Asking Photons Where Have They Been"
• Comment on "Past of a quantum particle revisited"
• Counterfactual Ghost Imaging
• A Completely Top-Down Hierarchical Structure in Quantum Mechanics
• Analysis of counterfactuality of counterfactual communication protocols
• Exchange-Free Computation on an Unknown Qubit at a Distance
• What is a quantum-mechanical 'weak value' the value of?
• Probing finite coarse-grained virtual Feynman histories with sequential weak values
• How Quantum is Quantum Counterfactual Communication?
• Demystifying weak measurements
• Anomalous weak values via a single photon detection
• Weak Measurement of the Arrival Times of Single Photons and Pairs of Entangled Photons
• The Weak Reality that Makes Quantum Phenomena more Natural: Novel Insights and Experiments
• An Improved Experiment to Determine the `Past of a Particle' in the Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer
• Comment on "Particle Path Through a Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer"
• The laws of physics do not prohibit counterfactual communication
• Past of a particle in an entangled state
• Reply to Comment on "Particle Path Through a Nested Mach-Zehnder Interferometer"
• From Counterportation to Local Wormholes
• Three approaches for analyzing the counterfactuality of counterfactual protocols
• Non-representative quantum mechanical weak values
• Anomalous weak values are caused by disturbance

Cited by in corpus (14)

• Contextuality, Coherences, and Quantum Cheshire Cats
• The laws of physics do not prohibit counterfactual communication
• A possible solution to the which-way problem of quantum interference
• Dependence of measurement outcomes on the dynamics of quantum coherent interactions between the system and the meter
• Sequential propagation of a single photon through five measurement contexts in a three-path interferometer
• Reply to "Comment on `Weak values and the past of a quantum particle' ''
• Tracing quantum correlations back to collective interferences
• Is the dynamical quantum Cheshire cat detectable?
• Separating a particle's mass from its momentum
• Quantum weak values and the 'which way?' question
• Reply to "Counterfactual communication not achieved yet -- A Comment on Salih et al. (2022)"
• Weak Particle Presence
• Quantum coherence and negative quasi probabilities in a contextual three-path interferometer
• Spatio-Temporal Weak Measurement of Chiral Ultra short Laser Pulse