Verification of high-speed solar wind stream forecasts using operational solar wind models

Abstract

High-speed solar wind streams emanating from coronal holes are frequently impinging on the Earth's magnetosphere causing recurrent, medium-level geomagnetic storm activity. Modeling high-speed solar wind streams is thus an essential element of successful space weather forecasting. Here we evaluate high-speed stream forecasts made by the empirical solar wind forecast (ESWF) and the semiempirical Wang-Sheeley-Arge (WSA) model based on the in situ plasma measurements from the ACE spacecraft for the years 2011 to 2014. While the ESWF makes use of an empirical relation between the coronal hole area observed in Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO)/Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) images and solar wind properties at the near-Earth environment, the WSA model establishes a link between properties of the open magnetic field lines extending from the photosphere to the corona and the background solar wind conditions. We found that both solar wind models are capable of predicting the large-scale features of the observed solar wind speed (root-mean-square error, RMSE $\approx$ 100 km/s) but tend to either overestimate (ESWF) or underestimate (WSA) the number of high-speed solar wind streams (threat score, TS $\approx$ 0.37). The predicted high-speed streams show typical uncertainties in the arrival time of about 1 day and uncertainties in the speed of about 100 km/s. General advantages and disadvantages of the investigated solar wind models are diagnosed and outlined.

References in corpus (6)

• Coronal Holes
• Automated Coronal Hole Detection using Local Intensity Thresholding Techniques
• Obtaining Potential Field Solution with Spherical Harmonics and Finite Differences
• Comparative Study of MHD Modeling of the Background Solar Wind
• Real-time solar wind prediction based on SDO/AIA coronal hole data
• Solar Wind Forecasting with Coronal Holes

Cited by in corpus (30)

• Extended MHD modeling of the steady solar corona and the solar wind
• Modeling observations of solar coronal mass ejections with heliospheric imagers verified with the Heliophysics System Observatory
• Statistical Analysis and Catalog of Non-polar Coronal Holes Covering the SDO-era using CATCH
• Solar wind prediction using deep learning
• Preconditioning of interplanetary space due to transient CME disturbances
• Characteristics of Low-Latitude Coronal Holes near the Maximum of Solar cycle 24
• Testing the background solar wind modelled by EUHFORIA
• The Dynamic Time Warping as a Means to Assess Solar Wind Time Series
• The Dependence of the Peak Velocity of High-Speed Solar Wind Streams as Measured in the Ecliptic by ACE and the STEREO satellites on the Area and Co-Latitude of their Solar Source Coronal Holes
• Forecasting the Ambient Solar Wind with Numerical Models: I. On the Implementation of an Operational Framework
• The Observational Uncertainty of Coronal Hole Boundaries in Automated Detection Schemes
• Forecasting the Ambient Solar Wind with Numerical Models. II. An Adaptive Prediction System for Specifying Solar Wind Speed Near the Sun
• Using gradient boosting regression to improve ambient solar wind model predictions
• SWASTi-SW: Space Weather Adaptive SimulaTion framework for Solar Wind and its relevance to ADITYA-L1 mission
• Machine learning for predicting the Bz magnetic field component from upstream in situ observations of solar coronal mass ejections
• A magnetic cloud prediction model for forecasting space weather relevant properties of Earth-directed coronal mass ejections
• Toward Quantitative Model for Simulation and Forecast of Solar Energetic Particles Production during Gradual Events - I: Magnetohydrodynamic Background Coupled to the SEP Model
• Prediction of Dst during solar minimum using in situ measurements at L5
• A comparison study of extrapolation models and empirical relations in forecasting solar wind
• Influence of coronal hole morphology on the solar wind speed at Earth
• Geomagnetic storm forecasting from solar coronal holes
• The Merging of a Coronal Dimming and the Southern Polar Coronal Hole
• Space weather: the solar perspective -- an update to Schwenn (2006)
• Quantifying Uncertainties in Solar Wind Forecasting Due to Incomplete Solar Magnetic Field Information
• Comparative Study of Microwave Polar Brightening, Coronal Holes, and Solar Wind Over the Solar Poles
• Ensemble Modeling of the Solar Wind Flow with Boundary Conditions Governed by Synchronic Photospheric Magnetograms. I. Multi-point Validation in the Inner Heliosphere
• Forecasting High-Speed Solar Wind Streams from Solar Images
• Coronal electron density: Insights from radio and in situ observations, and EUHFORIA modeling
• Using sunRunner3D to interpret the global structure of the heliosphere from in situ measurements
• Preconditioning of the interplanetary medium due to isolated ICMEs