Radii and binding energies in oxygen isotopes: a puzzle for nuclear forces

Abstract

We present a systematic study of both nuclear radii and binding energies in (even) oxygen isotopes from the valley of stability to the neutron drip line. Both charge and matter radii are compared to state-of-the-art {\it ab initio} calculations along with binding energy systematics. Experimental matter radii are obtained through a complete evaluation of the available elastic proton scattering data of oxygen isotopes. We show that, in spite of a good reproduction of binding energies, {\it ab initio} calculations with conventional nuclear interactions derived within chiral effective field theory fail to provide a realistic description of charge and matter radii. A novel version of two- and three-nucleon forces leads to considerable improvement of the simultaneous description of the three observables for stable isotopes, but shows deficiencies for the most neutron-rich systems. Thus, crucial challenges related to the development of nuclear interactions remain.

6 pages, 5 figures, Submitted to Nature Physics, April 12th 2016; first version (v1 Arxiv) Internal Report Preprint Irfu-18 December 2015. 6 p., 5 fig., Submitted to Physical Review Letters, April 29, May 3rd 2016; 2nd version. Int. Rep. Irfu-24 May 2016. Published in PRL, 27 July 2016 with the modified title (Radii and binding energies in oxygen isotopes: a challenge for nuclear forces)

References in corpus (12)

• Chiral effective field theory and nuclear forces
• Improved nuclear matter calculations from chiral low-momentum interactions
• Accurate nuclear radii and binding energies from a chiral interaction
• Similarity Renormalization Group for Nucleon-Nucleon Interactions
• Local three-nucleon interaction from chiral effective field theory
• In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group for Nuclei
• Ab Initio Multi-Reference In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group Calculations of Even Calcium and Nickel Isotopes
• Three-nucleon forces and spectroscopy of neutron-rich calcium isotopes
• Ab initio Bogoliubov coupled cluster theory for open-shell nuclei
• Three-body forces and proton-rich nuclei
• Symmetry broken and restored coupled-cluster theory I. Rotational symmetry and angular momentum
• 2014 Update of the Discoveries of Nuclides

Cited by in corpus (79)

• Status and Future of Nuclear Matrix Elements for Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay: A Review
• High-quality two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order of the chiral expansion
• Discrepancy between experimental and theoretical $\beta$-decay rates resolved from first principles
• A Guided Tour of Ab Initio Nuclear Many-Body Theory
• Non-Empirical Interactions for the Nuclear Shell Model: An Update
• Saturation with chiral interactions and consequences for finite nuclei
• Novel chiral Hamiltonian and observables in light and medium-mass nuclei
• Limiting masses and radii of neutron stars and their implications
• Quantifying uncertainties and correlations in the nuclear-matter equation of state
• Towards an ab initio covariant density functional for nuclear structure
• Three-Nucleon Forces: Implementation and Applications to Atomic Nuclei and Dense Matter
• Global sensitivity analysis of bulk properties of an atomic nucleus
• Family of Chiral Two- plus Three-Nucleon Interactions for Accurate Nuclear Structure Studies
• Recent developments for the optical model of nuclei
• Ab initio electromagnetic observables with the in-medium similarity renormalization group
• Ab initio optical potentials and nucleon scattering on medium mass nuclei
• Self-consistent Green's function theory for atomic nuclei
• In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group for Closed and Open-Shell Nuclei
• Ab initio calculation of the potential bubble nucleus ${}^{34}$Si
• Leading order relativistic chiral nucleon-nucleon interaction
• Neutrino-nucleus cross section within the extended factorization scheme
• Ab initio computation of charge densities for Sn and Xe isotopes
• Fully self-consistent relativistic Brueckner-Hartree-Fock theory for finite nuclei
• Novel applications of the dispersive optical model
• Microscopic optical potentials for calcium isotopes
• Continuum effects in neutron-drip-line oxygen isotopes
• Trends of Neutron Skins and Radii of Mirror Nuclei from First Principles
• Determining the nuclear neutron distribution from Coherent Elastic neutrino-Nucleus Scattering: current results and future prospects
• Nuclear Forces for Precision Nuclear Physics -- a collection of perspectives
• Convergence of Eigenvector Continuation
• Historical perspective and future prospects for nuclear interactions
• Proton distribution radii of ${}^{16-24}$O: signatures of new shell closures and neutron skin
• Lepton scattering from ${}^{40}$Ar and ${}^{48}$Ti in the quasielastic peak region
• Benchmark calculations of infinite neutron matter with realistic two- and three-nucleon potentials
• Power counting in chiral effective field theory and nuclear binding
• Nuclear electromagnetic dipole response with the Self-Consistent Green's Function formalism
• High-resolution laser spectroscopy of ${}^{27-32}$Al
• Effective density functionals beyond mean field
• Algebraic diagrammatic construction formalism with three-body interactions
• Moving away from singly-magic nuclei with Gorkov Green's function theory
• Bogoliubov many-body perturbation theory under constraint
• Inclusive electron-nucleus cross section within the Self Consistent Green's Function approach
• Emergence of simple patterns in many-body systems: from macroscopic objects to the atomic nucleus
• In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group Approach to the Nuclear Many-Body Problem
• Structure of 55Sc and development of the N=34 subshell closure
• Testing isospin symmetry breaking in ab initio nuclear theory
• Normal-ordered $k$-body approximation in particle-number-breaking theories
• Bayesian optimization in ab initio nuclear physics
• Pre-processing the nuclear many-body problem: Importance truncation versus tensor factorization techniques
• Testing ab initio nuclear structure in neutron-rich nuclei: lifetime measurements of second 2+ states in 16C and 20O
• Doubly magic nuclei from Lattice QCD forces at $M_{PS}=$469 MeV/c${}^2$
• Deformed in-medium similarity renormalization group
• Do we know how to count powers in pionless and pionful effective field theory?
• Relativistic chiral description of the ${}^1{S}_0$ nucleon-nucleon scattering
• Nuclear charge radii of Na isotopes: A tale of two theories
• Nuclear Structure from the In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group
• Setting nonperturbative uncertainties on finite-temperature properties of neutron matter
• Examining the $N$ = 28 shell closure through high-precision mass measurements of ${}^{46-48}$Ar
• Gorkov algebraic diagrammatic construction formalism at third order
• Combining symmetry breaking and restoration with configuration interaction: a highly accurate many-body scheme applied to the pairing Hamiltonian
• Density matrix renormalization group description of the island of inversion isotopes ${}^{28-33}$F
• Non-trivial effect for the large radius at the dripline of Oxygen isotopes
• Isotope dependence of muon-to-electron conversion
• Sensitivity of quasi-free reactions on details of the bound-state overlap functions
• Core-polarization effects and effective charges in O and Ni isotopes from chiral interactions
• Merging ab initio theory and few-body approach for $(d,p)$ reactions
• Ab initio no-core shell model study of ${}^{18-23}$O and ${}^{18-24}$F isotopes
• Ground-state properties of doubly magic nuclei from the unitary-model-operator approach with the chiral two- and three-nucleon forces
• Importance truncation in non-perturbative many-body techniques
• Study of structure and radii for ${}^{20-31}$Na isotopes using microscopic interactions
• Complete set of bound negative-parity states in the neutron-rich 18N nucleus
• Investigation of constraints on few-neutron forces in neutron matter by empirical information on the neutron skin of 48Ca and 208Pb
• Symmetry-projected variational calculations with the numerical suite TAURUS II. Configuration mixing of symmetry-projected reference states
• Global Framework for Emulation of Nuclear Calculations
• Ab initio study of the radii of oxygen isotopes
• Ab initio models of atomic nuclei: challenges and new ideas
• Ab initio calculations of nuclear charge radii across and beyond ${}^{132}$Sn: Putting chiral EFT nuclear interactions to the test
• An overview of symmetric nuclear matter properties from chiral interactions up to fourth order of the chiral expansion
• Uncertainties in tellurium-based dark matter searches stemming from nuclear structure uncertainties