No evidence for younger stellar generations within the intermediate age massive clusters NGC 1783, NGC 1696 and NGC 411

Abstract

Recently, Li et al. (2016) claimed to have found evidence for multiple generations of stars in the intermediate age clusters NGC 1783, NGC 1696 and NGC 411 in the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds (LMC/SMC). Here we show that these young stellar populations are present in the field regions around these clusters and are not likely associated with the clusters themselves. Using the same datasets, we find that the background subtraction method adopted by the authors does not adequately remove contaminating stars in the small number Poisson limit. Hence, we conclude that their results do not provide evidence of young generations of stars within these clusters.

arXiv comment7 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (20)

• Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars II. Optical to far-infrared isochrones with improved TP-AGB models
• Eight New Milky Way Companions Discovered in First-Year Dark Energy Survey Data
• A comprehensive Maximum Likelihood analysis of the structural properties of faint Milky Way satellites
• Stellar populations in the nuclei of late-type spiral galaxies
• Multiple stellar populations in three rich Large Magellanic Cloud star clusters
• On the Formation of Multiple Stellar Populations in Globular Clusters
• Studying the YMC population of M83: how long clusters remain embedded, their interaction with the ISM and implications for GC formation theories
• Constraining Globular Cluster Formation Through Studies of Young Massive Clusters: I. A lack of ongoing star formation within young clusters
• No Evidence for Significant Age Spreads in Young Massive LMC Clusters
• Constraining globular cluster formation through studies of young massive clusters - II. A Single Stellar Population Young Massive Cluster in NGC 34
• The exclusion of a significant range of ages in a massive star cluster
• Constraining globular cluster formation through studies of young massive clusters - V. ALMA observations of clusters in the Antennae
• Constraining Globular Cluster Formation Through Studies of Young Massive Clusters - IV. Testing the Fast Rotating Massive Star Scenario
• Constraining globular cluster formation through studies of young massive clusters - III. A lack of gas and dust in massive stellar clusters in the LMC and SMC
• Analysis of colour-magnitude diagrams of rich LMC clusters: NGC 1831
• Ejection of globular cluster interstellar media through ionization by white dwarfs
• Is the Escape Velocity in Star Clusters Linked to Extended Star Formation Histories? Using NGC 7252: W3 as a Test Case
• Formation of new stellar populations from gas accreted by massive young star clusters
• Signal discovery, limits, and uncertainties with sparse On/Off measurements: an objective Bayesian analysis
• Probing the LMC age gap at intermediate cluster masses

Cited by in corpus (18)

• Hubble Space Telescope survey of Magellanic Cloud star clusters. Photometry and astrometry of 113 clusters and early results
• Globular Cluster Formation at High Density: A model for Elemental Enrichment with Fast Recycling of Massive-Star Debris
• Searching for GC-like abundance patterns in young massive clusters
• The dynamical origin of multiple populations in intermediate-age clusters in the Magellanic Clouds
• The double Blue Straggler sequence in NGC2173: a field contamination artefact
• Formation of globular clusters with multiple stellar populations from massive gas clumps in high-z gas-rich dwarf galaxies
• Chromosome maps of young LMC clusters: An additional case of coeval multiple populations
• The tight subgiant branch of the intermediate-age star cluster NGC 411 implies a single-aged stellar population
• First Observational Signature of Rotational Deceleration in a Massive, Intermediate-age Star Cluster in the Magellanic Clouds
• Blue Stragglers as tracers of the dynamical state of two clusters in the Small Magellanic Cloud: NGC 339 and NGC 419
• Stellar populations in star clusters
• A discovery of young stellar objects in older clusters of the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The Origin of Young Stellar Populations in NGC 1783: Accretion of External Stars
• The VISCACHA Survey: XIII. The extended main-sequence turn-off in intermediate-age low-mass clusters
• Unveiling Bifurcated Blue Straggler Sequences in NGC 2173: Insights from Binary Evolution
• Parameter Estimation for Scarce Stellar Populations
• Searching for chemical abundance variations in young star clusters in the Magellanic Clouds: NGC 411, NGC 1718 and NGC 2213
• Not-so-simple stellar populations in nearby, resolved massive star clusters