Implications of solar wind measurements for solar models and composition

Abstract

We critically examine recent claims of a high solar metallicity by von Steiger \& Zurbuchen (2016) based on \textit{in situ} measurements of the solar wind, rather than the standard spectroscopically-inferred abundances (Asplund et al. 2009). We test the claim by Vagnozzi et al. (2016) that a composition based on the solar wind enables one to construct a standard solar model in agreement with helioseismological observations and thus solve the decades-old solar modelling problem. We show that, although some helioseismological observables are improved compared to models computed with spectroscopic abundances, most are in fact worse. The high abundance of refractory elements leads to an overproduction of neutrinos, with a predicted ${}^8$B flux that is nearly twice its observed value, and ${}^7$Be and CNO fluxes that are experimentally ruled out at high confidence. A combined likelihood analysis shows that models using the vSZ16 abundances fare worse than AGSS09 despite a higher metallicity. We also present astrophysical and spectroscopic arguments showing the vSZ16 composition to be an implausible representation of the solar interior, identifying the first ionisation potential effect in the outer solar atmosphere and wind as the likely culprit.

Accepted version (MNRAS). 9 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables

References in corpus (12)

• Present-day cosmic abundances. A comprehensive study of nearby early B-type stars and implications for stellar and Galactic evolution and interstellar dust models
• Helioseismology and Solar Abundances
• The elemental composition of the Sun II. The iron group elements Sc to Ni
• The elemental composition of the Sun I. The intermediate mass elements Na to Ca
• The elemental composition of the Sun III. The heavy elements Cu to Th
• Fresh insights on the structure of the solar core
• Updated determination of the solar neutrino fluxes from solar neutrino data
• Solar abundances and helioseismology: fine structure spacings and separation ratios of low-degree p modes
• Solar heavy element abundance: constraints from frequency separation ratios of low-degree p modes
• Alive and well: a short review about standard solar models
• Constraints on the opacity profile of the sun from helioseismic observables and solar neutrino flux measurements
• Line broadening and the solar opacity problem

Cited by in corpus (18)

• The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision
• Solar structure and evolution
• Physics from solar neutrinos in dark matter direct detection experiments
• Direct detection of dark energy: the XENON1T excess and future prospects
• 3D non-LTE line formation of neutral carbon in the Sun
• Evaporation and scattering of momentum- and velocity-dependent dark matter in the Sun
• Solar models with convective overshoot, the solar-wind mass loss, and a PMS disk accretion: helioseismic quantities, Li depletion and neutrino fluxes
• New solar metallicity measurements
• Solar models in light of new high metallicity measurements from solar wind data
• Effect of electromagnetic dipole dark matter on energy transport in the solar interior
• Rotating Solar Models with Low Metal Abundances as Good as Those with High Metal Abundances
• $12660$ spotted stars toward the OGLE Galactic bulge fields
• Determining the Elemental and Isotopic Composition of the preSolar Nebula from Genesis Data Analysis: The Case of Oxygen
• The solar photospheric silicon abundance according to CO5BOLD: Investigating line broadening, magnetic fields, and model effects
• Projections for measuring the size of the solar core with neutrino-electron scattering
• Computation of atomic astrophysical opacities
• Generic energy transport solutions to the solar abundance problem -- a hint of new physics
• Upcoming searches for decaying dark matter with ULTRASAT ultraviolet maps