Is this scaling nonlinear?

Abstract

One of the most celebrated findings in complex systems in the last decade is that different indexes y (e.g., patents) scale nonlinearly with the population~x of the cities in which they appear, i.e., $y\sim x^{\beta },\beta \ne 1$. More recently, the generality of this finding has been questioned in studies using new databases and different definitions of city boundaries. In this paper we investigate the existence of nonlinear scaling using a probabilistic framework in which fluctuations are accounted explicitly. In particular, we show that this allows not only to (a) estimate $\beta$ and confidence intervals, but also to (b) quantify the evidence in favor of $\beta \ne 1$ and (c) test the hypothesis that the observations are compatible with the nonlinear scaling. We employ this framework to compare $5$ different models to $15$ different datasets and we find that the answers to points (a)-(c) crucially depend on the fluctuations contained in the data, on how they are modeled, and on the fact that the city sizes are heavy-tailed distributed.

arXiv comment11 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (8)

• Constructing cities, deconstructing scaling laws
• Fluctuation scaling in complex systems: Taylor's law and beyond
• Urban characteristics attributable to density-driven tie formation
• Large cities are less green
• Distance to the scaling law: a useful approach for unveiling relationships between crime and urban metrics
• Scaling: Lost in the smog
• Rural to urban population density scaling of crime and property transactions in English and Welsh Parliamentary Constituencies
• Superlinear and sublinear urban scaling in geographical network model of the city

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Crime prediction through urban metrics and statistical learning
• The statistical physics of Cities
• City size and the spreading of COVID-19 in Brazil
• From global scaling to the dynamics of individual cities
• Computational Socioeconomics
• Defining urban agglomerations to detect agglomeration economies
• Small cities face greater impact from automation
• Evolution of urban scaling: evidence from Brazil
• Human Mobility in Large Cities as a Proxy for Crime
• Critical factors for mitigating car traffic in cities
• Testing statistical laws in complex systems
• A common trajectory recapitulated by urban economies
• Length scales in Brownian yet non-Gaussian dynamics
• More crime in cities? On the scaling laws of crime and the inadequacy of per capita rankings -- a cross-country study
• Modeling the origin of urban output scaling laws
• Spatial interactions in urban scaling laws
• On the relation between Transversal and Longitudinal Scaling in Cities
• Assessing the attraction of cities on venture capital from a scaling law perspective
• Unveiling Relationships Between Crime and Property in England and Wales Via Density Scale-Adjusted Metrics and Network Tools
• City limits in the age of smartphones and urban scaling
• Truncated lognormal distributions and scaling in the size of naturally defined population clusters
• Some recent advances in urban system science: models and data
• Modeling cities
• Modelling virus spreading in ride-pooling networks
• Lognormals, Power Laws and Double Power Laws in the Distribution of Frequencies of Harmonic Codewords from Classical Music
• Impact of inter-city interactions on disease scaling
• Artificial Increasing Returns to Scale and the Problem of Sampling from Lognormals
• A Heteroscedastic Bayesian Generalized Logistic Regression Model with Application to Scaling Problems
• Super-linear Scaling Behavior for Electric Vehicle Chargers and Road Map to Addressing the Infrastructure Gap