Practical, Reliable Error Bars in Quantum Tomography
arXiv:1509.06763 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.117.010404
Abstract
Precise characterization of quantum devices is usually achieved with quantum tomography. However, most methods which are currently widely used in experiments, such as maximum likelihood estimation, lack a well-justified error analysis. Promising recent methods based on confidence regions are difficult to apply in practice or yield error bars which are unnecessarily large. Here, we propose a practical yet robust method for obtaining error bars. We do so by introducing a novel representation of the output of the tomography procedure, the "quantum error bars". This representation is (i) concise, being given in terms of few parameters, (ii) intuitive, providing a fair idea of the "spread" of the error, and (iii) useful, containing the necessary information for constructing confidence regions. The statements resulting from our method are formulated in terms of a figure of merit, such as the fidelity to a reference state. We present an algorithm for computing this representation and provide ready-to-use software. Our procedure is applied to actual experimental data obtained from two superconducting qubits in an entangled state, demonstrating the applicability of our method.
arXiv commentJournal version; 4+13 pages, 3+6 figures, 1 table. The new version introduces the "quantum error bars". Software available at https://github.com/Tomographer/tomographer/
References in corpus (71)
- On the Measurement of Qubits
- 14-qubit entanglement: creation and coherence
- Quantum state tomography via compressed sensing
- Atom chip based generation of entanglement for quantum metrology
- Experimental Quantum State Tomography of Optical Fields and Ultrafast Statistical Sampling
- Prescription for experimental determination of the dynamics of a quantum black box
- Unknown Quantum States and Operations, a Bayesian View
- The ALPS project release 1.3: open source software for strongly correlated systems
- Efficient quantum state tomography
- High-fidelity preparation, gates, memory and readout of a trapped-ion quantum bit
- Tight Finite-Key Analysis for Quantum Cryptography
- Quantum state estimation
- Quantum process tomography of a controlled-NOT gate
- Direct Fidelity Estimation from Few Pauli Measurements
- Quantum information transfer using photons
- The Bloch Vector for N-Level Systems
- Induced measures in the space of mixed quantum states
- Optimal, reliable estimation of quantum states
- Implementation of a Toffoli Gate with Superconducting Circuits
- Bloch vectors for qudits
- Quantum Tomography via Compressed Sensing: Error Bounds, Sample Complexity, and Efficient Estimators
- Qudit Quantum State Tomography
- Practical characterization of quantum devices without tomography
- Iterative maximum-likelihood reconstruction in quantum homodyne tomography
- Realization of Deterministic Quantum Teleportation with Solid State Qubits
- Quantum teleportation from a telecom-wavelength photon to a solid-state quantum memory
- Complete methods set for scalable ion trap quantum information processing
- Maximum Likelihood, Minimum Effort
- Characterization of the Positivity of the Density Matrix in Terms of the Coherence Vector Representation
- Permutationally invariant quantum tomography
- Duality Between Smooth Min- and Max-Entropies
- Quantum Tomography
- Reliable Quantum State Tomography
- Diluted maximum-likelihood algorithm for quantum tomography
- Heralded quantum entanglement between two crystals
- Adaptive quantum state tomography improves accuracy quadratically
- Iterative algorithm for reconstruction of entangled states
- Diagnosis, prescription and prognosis of a Bell-state filter by quantum process tomography
- Permutationally invariant state reconstruction
- Imperfect measurements settings: implications on quantum state tomography and entanglement witnesses
- Systematic errors in current quantum state tomography tools
- Experimental determination of a nonclassical Glauber-Sudarshan P function
- Practical Bayesian Tomography
- Hedged maximum likelihood estimation
- Benchmarking a Teleportation Protocol realized in Superconducting Circuits
- The effect of noise correlations on randomized benchmarking
- Dynamics of dispersive single qubit read-out in circuit quantum electrodynamics
- Experimental Comparison of Efficient Tomography Schemes for a Six-Qubit State
- Nonclassicality filters and quasiprobabilities
- Estimating errors reliably in Monte Carlo simulations of the Ehrenfest model
- Optimal error regions for quantum state estimation
- Self-consistent tomography of the state-measurement Gram matrix
- Parametrizations of density matrices
- Tomographic reconstruction of the Wigner function on the Bloch sphere
- Entanglement verification with finite data
- Monte Carlo sampling from the quantum state space. II
- Increasing the statistical significance of entanglement detection in experiments
- Adaptive experimental design for one-qubit state estimation with finite data based on a statistical update criterion
- Monte Carlo sampling from the quantum state space. I
- Group Theoretical Quantum Tomography
- Adaptive schemes for incomplete quantum process tomography
- Experimental Extraction of Secure Correlations from a Noisy Private State
- Reliable Entanglement Verification
- Near-optimal quantum tomography: estimators and bounds
- Estimating the bias of a noisy coin
- Error probability analysis in quantum tomography: a tool for evaluating experiments
- The Role of Topology in Quantum Tomography
- Precision-Guaranteed Quantum Metrology
- Continuous matrix product state tomography of quantum transport experiments
- Efficient quantum tomography
- Lower Bounds for Quantum Parameter Estimation
Cited by in corpus (50)
- High-rate, high-fidelity entanglement of qubits across an elementary quantum network
- Gate Set Tomography
- Multi-parameter estimation beyond Quantum Fisher Information
- Learning Quantum Systems
- Practical Bayesian Tomography
- Demonstration of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Steering Using Hybrid Continuous- and Discrete-Variable Entanglement of Light
- Experimental quantum homodyne tomography via machine learning
- Device-independent point estimation from finite data and its application to device-independent property estimation
- Certification of non-Gaussian states with operational measurements
- Experimentally exploring compressed sensing quantum tomography
- Continuous phase-space representations for finite-dimensional quantum states and their tomography
- Practical adaptive quantum tomography
- Projected Least-Squares Quantum Process Tomography
- Wigner tomography of multispin quantum states
- A comparative study of estimation methods in quantum tomography
- Gradient-descent quantum process tomography by learning Kraus operators
- Confidence Polytopes in Quantum State Tomography
- Capacity estimation and verification of quantum channels with arbitrarily correlated errors
- Error Mitigation for Deep Quantum Optimization Circuits by Leveraging Problem Symmetries
- Homodyne tomography with homodyne-like detection
- Numerical study of Wigner negativity in one-dimensional steady-state resonance fluorescence
- Optimal error intervals for properties of the quantum state
- Investigating Bias in Maximum Likelihood Quantum State Tomography
- Unbounded randomness from uncharacterized sources
- Error regions in quantum state tomography: computational complexity caused by geometry of quantum states
- Quantum State Tomography for Matrix Product Density Operators
- Practical and reliable error bars for quantum process tomography
- Quantum metrology in the finite-sample regime
- Simulating noisy quantum channels via quantum state preparation algorithms
- Efficient Bayesian credible-region certification for quantum-state tomography
- Experimental demonstration of a versatile and scalable scheme for iterative generation of non-Gaussian states of light
- Witnessing Entanglement in Experiments with Correlated Noise
- Bayesian error regions in quantum estimation I: analytical reasonings
- Theory of versatile fidelity estimation with confidence
- Estimating the precision for quantum process tomography
- Probing Bayesian credible regions intrinsically: a feasible error certification for physical systems
- Maximum a posteriori estimation of quantum states
- Comparison of confidence regions for quantum state tomography
- User-friendly confidence regions for quantum state tomography
- Learning optimal quantum models is NP-hard
- Local asymptotic equivalence of pure quantum states ensembles and quantum Gaussian white noise
- tqix: A toolbox for Quantum in X: Quantum measurement, quantum tomography, quantum metrology, and others
- Towards heralded distribution of polarization entanglement
- Benchmarking maximum-likelihood state estimation with an entangled two-cavity state
- Confidence polytopes for quantum process tomography
- Systematic errors in direct state measurements with quantum controlled measurements
- Reliable confidence regions for quantum tomography using distribution moments
- Uncorrelated problem-specific samples of quantum states from zero-mean Wishart distributions
- Quantum Tomography and Schwinger's Picture of Quantum Mechanics
- Ability of entanglement and purity to help to detect systematic experimental errors