Comparisons between different techniques for measuring mass segregation

Abstract

We examine the performance of four different methods which are used to measure mass segregation in star-forming regions: the radial variation of the mass function ${\mathcal{M}}_{\mathrm{MF}}$; the minimum spanning tree-based ${\Lambda }_{\mathrm{MSR}}$ method; the local surface density ${\Sigma }_{\mathrm{LDR}}$ method; and the ${\Omega }_{\mathrm{GSR}}$ technique, which isolates groups of stars and determines whether the most massive star in each group is more centrally concentrated than the average star. All four methods have been proposed in the literature as techniques for quantifying mass segregation, yet they routinely produce contradictory results as they do not all measure the same thing. We apply each method to synthetic star-forming regions to determine when and why they have shortcomings. When a star-forming region is smooth and centrally concentrated, all four methods correctly identify mass segregation when it is present. However, if the region is spatially substructured, the ${\Omega }_{\mathrm{GSR}}$ method fails because it arbitrarily defines groups in the hierarchical distribution, and usually discards positional information for many of the most massive stars in the region. We also show that the ${\Lambda }_{\mathrm{MSR}}$ and ${\Sigma }_{\mathrm{LDR}}$ methods can sometimes produce apparently contradictory results, because they use different definitions of mass segregation. We conclude that only ${\Lambda }_{\mathrm{MSR}}$ measures mass segregation in the classical sense (without the need for defining the centre of the region), although ${\Sigma }_{\mathrm{LDR}}$ does place limits on the amount of previous dynamical evolution in a star-forming region.

13 pages, 9 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (51)

• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• Embedded Clusters in Molecular Clouds
• A Universal Stellar Initial Mass Function? A Critical Look at Variations
• A Spitzer Survey of Young Stellar Clusters within One Kiloparsec of the Sun: Cluster Core Extraction and Basic Structural Analysis
• On the fraction of star formation occurring in bound stellar clusters
• The Spatial Distribution of Star Formation in the Solar Neighbourhood: Do all stars form in clusters?
• The statistical Analysis of Star Clusters
• The initial mass function : from Salpeter 1955 to 2005
• Massive stars in massive clusters II: Disruption of bound clusters by photoionization
• Using the minimum spanning tree to trace mass segregation
• The dynamical evolution of fractal star clusters: the survival of substructure
• Mass segregation and fractal substructure in young massive clusters: (I) the McLuster code and method calibration
• A Catalog of Young Stellar Groups and Clusters Within 1kpc of the Sun
• The early dynamical evolution of cool, clumpy star clusters
• Gravitational fragmentation and the formation of brown dwarfs in stellar clusters
• Dynamical evolution of star forming regions
• The distinction between star clusters and associations
• Ionizing feedback from massive stars in massive clusters III: Disruption of partially unbound clouds
• Do O-stars form in isolation?
• On the function describing the stellar initial mass function
• Constraints on Massive Star Formation: Cygnus OB2 was always an Association
• Star Cluster Formation in Turbulent, Magnetized Dense Clumps with Radiative and Outflow Feedback
• The secrets of the nearest starburst cluster: II. The present-day mass function in NGC 3603
• The Arches Cluster - Evidence for a Truncated Mass Function?
• Fractal Structure in Galactic Star Fields
• Young Stellar Groups and Their Most Massive Stars
• Mass Segregation in Young Magellanic Clouds Star Clusters: Four Clusters observed with HST
• The spatial distribution of stars in open clusters
• The structures of embedded clusters in the Perseus, Serpens and Ophiuchus molecular clouds
• Importance of the Initial Conditions for Star Formation - III: Statistical Properties of Embedded Protostellar Clusters
• On the Origin of Mass Segregation in NGC 3603
• Mass segregation in young compact star clusters in the Large Magellanic Cloud: I. Data and Luminosity Functions
• The Stellar Mass Distribution in the Giant Star Forming Region NGC 346
• The Complex Distribution of Recently Formed Stars. Bimodal Stellar Clustering in the Star-Forming Region NGC 346
• A MAD view of Trumpler 14
• No evidence for mass segregation in massive young clusters
• Global mass segregation in hydrodynamical simulations of star formation
• Identifying star clusters in a field: A comparison of different algorithms
• Dynamics versus structure: breaking the density degeneracy in star formation
• A highly efficient measure of mass segregation in star clusters
• On the mass segregation of stars and brown dwarfs in Taurus
• The Clustering Behavior of Pre-Main Sequence Stars in NGC 346 in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Limits on initial mass segregation in young clusters
• The Formation and Evolution of Small Star Clusters
• Primordial mass segregation in simulations of star formation?
• The role of low-mass star clusters in forming the massive stars in DR 21
• Berkeley 94 and Berkeley 96: Two Young Clusters with Different Dynamical Evolution
• Four Highly Luminous Massive Star Forming Regions in the Norma Spiral Arm II. Deep NIR imaging
• The central Blue Straggler population in four outer-halo globular clusters
• A New Diagnostic Method for Assessment of Stellar Stratification in Star Clusters
• Mass Segregation of Embedded Clusters in the Milky Way

Cited by in corpus (39)

• The ALMA Survey of 70 $\mu$m dark High-mass clumps in Early Stages (ASHES). I. Pilot Survey: Clump Fragmentation
• Properties of the dense core population in Orion B as seen by the Herschel Gould Belt survey
• A Census of Young Stars and Brown Dwarfs in IC 348 and NGC 1333
• The ALMA Survey of 70 $\mu$m Dark High-mass Clumps in Early Stages (ASHES). IX. Physical Properties and Spatial Distribution of Cores in IRDCs
• Revisiting the mass of open clusters with \emph{Gaia} data
• Multiplicity and clustering in Taurus star forming region. II. From ultra-wide pairs to dense NESTs
• ALMA-IMF VI -- Investigating the origin of stellar masses: Core mass function evolution in the W43-MM2&MM3 mini-starburst
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Dense Core Clusters in Orion A
• Mass segregation and sequential star formation in NGC 2264 revealed by Herschel
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: Structural and dynamical properties of the young cluster Chamaeleon I
• On the spatial distributions of dense cores in Orion B
• Radiation pressure in super star cluster formation
• Do open star clusters evolve toward energy equipartition?
• The Spatial Evolution of Young Massive Clusters I. A New Tool to Quantitatively Trace Stellar Clustering
• The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: Dense Core Clusters in Orion B
• A High-Resolution Multiband Survey of Westerlund 2 With the Hubble Space Telescope. III. The present-day stellar mass function
• How fast is mass-segregation happening in hierarchical formed embedded star clusters?
• Stellar population of the Rosette Nebula and NGC 2244: application of the probabilistic random forest
• ${\mathcal{Q}}^{+}$: Characterising the structure of young star clusters
• A tale of two clusters: dynamical history determines disc survival in Tr14 and Tr16 in the Carina Nebula
• Hierarchical formation of Westerlund 1: a collapsing cluster with no primordial mass segregation?
• Constraints on star formation in NGC2264
• The early dynamical evolution of star clusters near the Galactic Centre
• Early dynamics and violent relaxation of multi-mass rotating star clusters
• S2D2: Small-scale Significant substructure DBSCAN Detection I. NESTs detection in 2D star-forming regions
• Investigating the structure of star-forming regions using INDICATE
• Young Massive Clusters: Their Population Properties, Formation and Evolution, and Their Relation to the Ancient Globular Clusters
• No preferential spatial distribution for massive stars expected from their formation
• On the origin of planetary-mass objects in NGC1333
• The evolution of phase space densities in star-forming regions
• Evolution of spatio-kinematic structures in star-forming regions: are Friends of Friends worth knowing?
• Simulations of Fractal Star Cluster Formation: I. New Insights for Measuring Mass Segregation of Star Clusters with SubStructure
• ALMAGAL VI. The spatial distribution of dense cores during the evolution of cluster-forming massive clump
• The Spatial Evolution of Young Massive Clusters III. Effect of the Gaia Filter on 2D Spatial Distribution Studies
• Are hierarchically formed embedded star clusters surviving gas expulsion depending on their initial conditions?
• Massive star cluster formation III. Early mass segregation during cluster assembly
• Star Cluster Detection and Characterization using Generalized Parzen Density Estimation
• Structure and Dynamics of the Young Massive Star Cluster Westerlund 1
• Mass Segregation in the CMZoom Survey