Niels Bohr as Philosopher of Experiment: Does Decoherence Theory Challenge Bohr's Doctrine of Classical Concepts?

Abstract

Niels Bohr's doctrine of the primacy of "classical concepts" is arguably his most criticized and misunderstood view. We present a new, careful historical analysis that makes clear that Bohr's doctrine was primarily an epistemological thesis, derived from his understanding of the functional role of experiment. A hitherto largely overlooked disagreement between Bohr and Heisenberg about the movability of the "cut" between measuring apparatus and observed quantum system supports the view that, for Bohr, such a cut did not originate in dynamical (ontological) considerations, but rather in functional (epistemological) considerations. As such, both the motivation and the target of Bohr's doctrine of classical concepts are of a fundamentally different nature than what is understood as the dynamical problem of the quantum-to-classical transition. Our analysis suggests that, contrary to claims often found in the literature, Bohr's doctrine is not, and cannot be, at odds with proposed solutions to the dynamical problem of the quantum-classical transition that were pursued by several of Bohr's followers and culminated in the development of decoherence theory.

arXiv comment15 pages, identical to published version

References in corpus (4)

• Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical
• Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics
• Bananaworld: Quantum Mechanics for Primates
• The Kantian Framework of Complementarity

Cited by in corpus (18)

• Quantum Decoherence
• Niels Bohr on the wave function and the classical/quantum divide
• Experimental assessment of physical realism in a quantum-controlled device
• The Meaning of the Wave Function: In Search of the Ontology of Quantum Mechanics
• Von Neumann Was Not a Quantum Bayesian
• QBism: Quantum Theory as a Hero's Handbook
• Multiscale Structure in Eco-Evolutionary Dynamics
• Copenhagen Quantum Mechanics
• Critique of Quantum Optical Experimental Refutations of Bohr's Principle of Complementarity, of the Wootters-Zurek Principle of Complementarity, and of the Particle-Wave Duality Relation
• Emergence of the Classical from within the Quantum Universe
• Bohrification: From classical concepts to commutative algebras
• Making Sense of the Many Worlds Interpretation
• Decoherence: From Interpretation to Experiment
• On the Philosophical Foundations of Physics: An Experimentalist's Perspective
• On Relationalist Reconstructions of Quantum Theory
• Why Are We Obsessed with "Understanding" Quantum Mechanics?
• Does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle apply along the time dimension?
• Bohr, QBism, and Beyond