A Comparative Analysis of the Supernova Legacy Survey Sample with ΛCDM and the $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$ Universe

Abstract

The use of Type~Ia SNe has thus far produced the most reliable measurement of the expansion history of the Universe, suggesting that $\Lambda$CDM offers the best explanation for the redshift--luminosity distribution observed in these events. But the analysis of other kinds of source, such as cosmic chronometers, gamma ray bursts, and high-$z$ quasars, conflicts with this conclusion, indicating instead that the constant expansion rate implied by the $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$ Universe is a better fit to the data. The central difficulty with the use of Type~Ia SNe as standard candles is that one must optimize three or four nuisance parameters characterizing supernova luminosities simultaneously with the parameters of an expansion model. Hence in comparing competing models, one must reduce the data independently for each. We carry~out such a comparison of $\Lambda$CDM and the $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$ Universe, using the Supernova Legacy Survey (SNLS) sample of 252 SN~events, and show that each model fits its individually reduced data very well. But since $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$ has only one free parameter (the Hubble constant), it follows from a standard model selection technique that it is to be preferred over $\Lambda$CDM, the minimalist version of which has three (the Hubble constant, the scaled matter density and either the spatial curvature constant or the dark-energy equation-of-state parameter). We estimate by the Bayes Information Criterion that in a pairwise comparison, the likelihood of $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$ is $\sim 90\%$, compared with only $\sim 10\%$ for a minimalist form of $\Lambda$CDM, in which dark energy is simply a cosmological constant. Compared to $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$, versions of the standard model with more elaborate parametrizations of dark energy are judged to be even less likely.

31 Pages, 5 Figures, 1 Table. Accepted for publication in AJ

References in corpus (7)

• Improved Cosmological Constraints from New, Old and Combined Supernova Datasets
• Spectra and Light Curves of Six Type Ia Supernovae at 0.511 < z < 1.12 and the Union2 Compilation
• Gaussian Process Cosmography
• Gemini Near-infrared Spectroscopy of Luminous z~6 Quasars: Chemical Abundances, Black Hole Masses, and MgII Absorption
• Black hole masses and enrichment of z ~ 6 SDSS quasars
• A Cosmology-Independent Calibration of Gamma-Ray Burst Luminosity Relations and the Hubble Diagram
• A New Determination of the High Redshift Type Ia Supernova Rates with the Hubble Space Telescope Advanced Camera for Surveys

Cited by in corpus (39)

• Marginal evidence for cosmic acceleration from Type Ia supernovae
• Robust model comparison disfavors power law cosmology
• A comparison of the R_h=ct and LCDM cosmologies using the Cosmic Distance Duality Relation
• The Linear Growth of Structure in the R_h=ct Universe
• Physical Basis for the Symmetries in the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker Metric
• The HII Galaxy Hubble Diagram Strongly Favors $R_{\mathrm{h}}=ct$ over $\Lambda$CDM
• Cosmological test using the Hubble diagram of high-z quasars
• Model-independent Test of the Cosmic Distance Duality Relation
• A Test of Cosmological Models using high-z Measurements of H(z)
• Power law cosmology model comparison with CMB scale information
• Model-independent Distance Calibration and Curvature Measurement using Quasars and Cosmic Chronometers
• Reconstruction of the HII Galaxy Hubble Diagram using Gaussian Processes
• The Epoch of Reionization in the R_h=ct Universe
• Testing the Distance-Duality Relation in the $R_h=ct$ Universe
• Impact of a locally measured H_0 on the interpretation of cosmic chronometer data
• A Further Test of Lorentz Violation from the Rest-Frame Spectral Lags of Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Definitive Test of the R_h=ct Universe Using Redshift Drift
• Model Selection with Strong-lensing Systems
• Testing Cosmological Models with Type Ic Super Luminous Supernovae
• Constraining Dark-Matter Ensembles with Supernova Data
• The Age-Redshift Relationship of Old Passive Galaxies
• Cosmological Tests with the FSRQ Gamma-ray Luminosity Function
• Cosmological Tests With Strong Gravitational Lenses using Gaussian Processes
• A Two-point Diagnostic for the HII Galaxy Hubble Diagram
• Cosmological Tests with the Joint Lightcurve Analysis
• A comparison of the R_h=ct and LCDM cosmologies based on the observed halo mass function
• Effect of low anisotropy on cosmological models by using supernova data
• Reassessing Dust's Role in Forming the CMB
• Unseen Progenitors of Luminous High-z Quasars in the R_h=ct Universe
• Puzzling initial conditions in the R_h=ct model
• What if the universe expands linearly? A local general relativity to solve the "zero active mass" problem
• Model Selection based on the Angular-Diameter Distance to the Compact Structure in Radio Quasars
• Cosmological Perturbations without Inflation
• A cosmology-independent calibration of type Ia supernovae data
• Tantalizing New Physics from the Cosmic Purview
• A New Class of Cosmologically `Viable' $f(R)$ Models
• A comparison of cosmological models with high-redshift quasars
• Bayesian Model Comparison of $R_h=ct$ versus $\Lambda$CDM using HII galaxy Hubble diagram
• Supernovae as cosmological probes