On the proper use of the Schwarzschild and Ledoux criteria in stellar evolution computations

Abstract

The era of detailed asteroseismic analyses opened by space missions such as CoRoT and $\text{Kepler}$ has highlighted the need for stellar models devoid of numerical inaccuracies, in order to be able to diagnose which physical aspects are being ignored or poorly treated in standard stellar modeling. We tackle here the important problem of fixing convective zones boundaries in the frame of the local mixing length theory. First we show that the only correct way to locate a convective zone boundary is to find, at each iteration step, through interpolations or extrapolations from points $\text{within the convective zone}$, the mass where the radiative luminosity is equal to the total one. We then discuss two misuses of the boundary condition and the way they affect stellar modeling and stellar evolution. The first one consists in applying the neutrality condition for convective instability on the $\text{radiative}$ side of the convective boundary. The second way of misusing the boundary condition comes from the process of fixing the convective boundary through the search for a change of sign of a possibly \textit{discontinuous} function. We show that these misuses can lead to completely wrong estimates of convective core sizes with important consequences for the following evolutionary phases. We point out the advantages of using a double mesh point at each convective zone boundaries. The specific problem of a convective shell is discussed and some remarks concerning overshooting are given.

14 pages, 10 figures, to appear in A&A

References in corpus (7)

• ASTEC -- the Aarhus STellar Evolution Code
• CLES, Code Liegeois d'Evolution Stellaire
• CESAM: a free code for stellar evolution calculations
• Numerical Simulations of Penetration and Overshoot in the Sun
• CoRoT/ESTA-TASK 1 and TASK 3 comparison of the internal structure and seismic properties of representative stellar models: Comparisons between the ASTEC, CESAM, CLES, GARSTEC and STAROX codes
• Comparisons for Esta-Task3: Cles and Cesam
• Numerical simulations of downward convective overshooting in giants

Cited by in corpus (61)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• The spin of the second-born black hole in coalescing binary black holes
• Mixed modes in red giants: a window on stellar evolution
• Tight asteroseismic constraints on core overshooting and diffusive mixing in the slowly rotating pulsating B8.3V star KIC 10526294
• Giant star seismology
• Beyond Mixing-length Theory: a step toward 321D
• AIMS - A new tool for stellar parameter determinations using asteroseismic constraints
• The brightness of the Red Giant Branch tip: Theoretical framework, a set of reference models, and predicted observables
• Uncertainties on near-core mixing in red-clump stars: effects on the period spacing and on the luminosity of the AGB bump
• KIC 10526294: a slowly rotating B star with rotationally split, quasi-equally spaced gravity modes
• An Exploration of Double Diffusive Convection in Jupiter as a Result of Hydrogen-Helium Phase Separation
• Rotation of the convective core in $\gamma$ Dor stars measured by dips in period spacings of g modes coupled with inertial modes
• The BAyesian STellar Algorithm (BASTA): a fitting tool for stellar studies, asteroseismology, exoplanets, and Galactic archaeology
• The Aarhus Red Giants Challenge I: Stellar structures in the red giant branch phase
• Kepler red-clump stars in the field and in open clusters: constraints on core mixing
• On the uncertain nature of the core of $\mathbf{\alpha }$ Cen A
• How accurate are stellar ages based on stellar models ? I. The impact of stellar models uncertainties
• Convective core sizes in rotating massive stars: I. Constraints from solar metallicity OB field stars
• Evolutionary models of red supergiants: Evidence for a metallicity-dependent mixing length and implications for Type IIP supernova progenitors
• SpaceInn hare-and-hounds exercise: Estimation of stellar properties using space-based asteroseismic data
• The treatment of mixing in core helium burning models -- III. Suppressing core breathing pulses with a new constraint on overshoot
• On the red giant branch mass loss in 47 Tucanae: Constraints from the horizontal branch morphology
• Confronting uncertainties in stellar physics II. exploring differences in main-sequence stellar evolution tracks
• Convective boundary mixing in main-sequence stars: theory and empirical constraints
• Evolutionary modelling of subdwarf B stars using MESA with the predictive mixing and convective premixing schemes
• On the missing second generation AGB stars in NGC6752
• Convective boundary mixing in low- and intermediate-mass stars I. Core properties from pressure-mode asteroseismology
• Main Sequence Evolution with Layered Semiconvection
• Probing core overshooting using subgiant asteroseismology: the case of KIC10273246
• Schwarzschild and Ledoux are equivalent on evolutionary timescales
• On the recent parametric determination of an asteroseismological model for the DBV star KIC 08626021
• A new ${}^{12}$C + ${}^{12}$C nuclear reaction rate: impact on stellar evolution
• Asteroseismic analysis of variable hot subdwarf stars observed with TESS I. The mean g-mode period spacings in hot subdwarf B stars
• The effects of near-core convective shells on the gravity modes of the subdwarf B pulsator KIC 10553698A
• 3D Simulations and MLT: I. Renzini's Critique
• Tidal Interactions in Post Common-Envelope sdB Binaries
• Convective Mixing in Gas Giant Planets with Primordial Composition Gradients
• The growth of helium burning cores
• Impact of Convective Boundary Mixing on the TP-AGB
• Testing abundance-age relations beyond solar analogues with Kepler LEGACY stars
• The Properties of G-modes in Layered Semi-Convection
• Constraining convective regions with asteroseismic linear structural inversions
• Inclusion of Horizontal Branch stars in the derivation of star formation histories of dwarf galaxies: the Carina dSph
• Asteroseismology of the dip structure in period-spacings of rapidly rotating gamma Doradus stars caused by the coupling between core and envelope oscillations
• Characterization of magneto-convection in sunspots -- The Gough & Tayler stability criterion in MURaM sunspot simulations
• The imprint of convection on Type I X-ray bursts: Pauses in photospheric radius expansion lightcurves
• A non-local mixing-length theory able to compute core overshooting
• Towards 21st Century Stellar Models: Star Clusters, Supercomputing, and Asteroseismology
• Massive stars, successes and challenges
• Convective Mixing: The Formation Channel of Li-rich Giants
• Stellar evolution and modelling stars
• Toward a Comprehensive Grid of Cepheid Models with MESA II. Impact of Physical and Numerical Assumptions on Elemental Abundances
• Magnetized oscillatory double-diffusive convection
• Massive stars: stellar models and stellar yields, impact on Galactic Archaeology
• Advancing Globular Cluster Constraints on the Axion-Photon Coupling
• Asteroseismology of red giants & galactic archaeology
• The AGB bump: a calibrator for the core mixing
• Mechanisms for magnetic braking boost and disruption: the role of irradiation-driven winds and convective turnover time spike in cataclysmic variables
• Detailed theoretical analysis of core Helium-burning stars: Mixed mode patterns I. Impact of the He-flash discontinuity and of induced semi-convection
• Ensemble seismic study of the properties of the core of Red Clump stars