3D Simulations and MLT: I. Renzini's Critique

Abstract

Renzini (1987) wrote an influential critique of mixing-length theory (MLT) as used in stellar evolution codes, and concluded that three-dimensional (3D) fluid dynamical simulations were needed to clarify several important issues. We have critically explored the limitations of the numerical methods and conclude that they are approaching the required accuracy. Implicit large eddy simulations (ILES) automatically connect large scale turbulence to a Kolmogorov cascade below the grid scale, allowing turbulent boundary layers to remove singularities that appear in the theory. Interactions between coherent structures give multi-modal behavior, driving intermittency and fluctuations. Reynolds averaging (RA) allows us to abstract the essential features of this dynamical behavior of boundaries which are appropriate to stellar evolution, and consider how they relate static boundary conditions (Richardson, Schwarzschild or Ledoux). We clarify several questions concerning when and why MLT works, and does not work, using both analytical theory and 3D high resolution numerical simulations. The composition gradients and boundary layer structure which are produced by our simulations suggest a self-consistent approach to boundary layers, removing the need for ad hoc procedures for 'convective overshooting' and `semi-convection'. In a companion paper we quantify the adequacy of our numerical resolution, determine of the length scale of dissipation (the `mixing length') without astronomical calibration, quantify agreement with the four-fifths law of Kolmogorov for weak stratification, and extend MLT to deal with strong stratification.

References in corpus (25)

• Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. I. Hydrodynamic Simulation
• Stellar Turbulent Convection: A Selfconsistent Model
• Laboratory evidence of dynamo amplification of magnetic fields in a turbulent plasma
• Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. II. The Velocity Field
• Testing convective-core overshooting using period spacings of dipole modes in red giants
• Beyond Mixing-length Theory: a step toward 321D
• Turbulent convection in stellar interiors. III. Mean-field analysis and stratification effects
• Inertial range scaling in numerical turbulence with hyperviscosity
• Idealised hydrodynamic simulations of turbulent oxygen-burning shell convection in 4π geometry
• Turbulent Cells in Stars: I. Fluctuations in Kinetic Energy and Luminosity
• On the proper use of the Schwarzschild and Ledoux criteria in stellar evolution computations
• 3D Hydrodynamic Simulations of Carbon Burning in Massive Stars
• Energy Conservation and Gravity Waves in Sound-proof Treatments of Stellar Interiors: Part I Anelastic Approximations
• The Emergence of Solar Supergranulation as a Natural Consequence of Rotationally-Constrained Interior Convection
• Anelastic and Compressible Simulations of Stellar Oxygen Burning
• On the Amplitude of Convective Velocities in the Deep Solar Interior
• Towards a new generation of multi-dimensional stellar evolution models: development of an implicit hydrodynamic code
• Turbulent transport by diffusive stratified shear flows: from local to global models. Part I: Numerical simulations of a stratified plane Couette flow
• Anelastic Versus Fully Compressible Turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard Convection
• Hydrodynamic and hydromagnetic energy spectra from large eddy simulations
• Turbulent Mixing and Nuclear Burning in Stellar Interiors
• Identification of gravity waves in hydrodynamical simulations
• Synergies between Asteroseismology and Three-dimensional Simulations of Stellar Turbulence
• Key Issues Review: Numerical studies of turbulence in stars
• A new stellar mixing process operating below shell convection zones following off-center ignition

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Probing the interior physics of stars through asteroseismology
• Large-Scale Mixing in a Violent Oxygen-Neon Shell Merger Prior to a Core-Collapse Supernova
• The evolution of CNO elements in galaxies
• Convection with Misaligned Gravity and Rotation: Simulations and Rotating Mixing Length Theory
• Monotonicity of the cores of massive stars
• A systematic study of super-Eddington layers in the envelopes of massive stars
• Multidimensional low-Mach number time-implicit hydrodynamic simulations of convective helium shell burning in a massive star
• Convective shells in the interior of Cepheid variable stars: overshooting models based on hydrodynamic simulations
• The impact of wind mass loss on nucleosynthesis and yields of very massive stars at low metallicity
• KIC 3868420: A high-amplitude $\delta$ Scuti-$\gamma$ Dor hybrid star crossing the Hertzsprung gap
• One size does not fit all: Evidence for a range of mixing efficiencies in stellar evolution calculations