PopCORN: Hunting down the differences between binary population synthesis codes

Abstract

Binary population synthesis (BPS) modelling is a very effective tool to study the evolution and properties of close binary systems. The uncertainty in the parameters of the model and their effect on a population can be tested in a statistical way, which then leads to a deeper understanding of the underlying physical processes involved. To understand the predictive power of BPS codes, we study the similarities and differences in the predicted populations of four different BPS codes for low- and intermediate-mass binaries. We investigate whether the differences are caused by different assumptions made in the BPS codes or by numerical effects. To simplify the complex problem of comparing BPS codes, we equalise the inherent assumptions as much as possible. We find that the simulated populations are similar between the codes. Regarding the population of binaries with one WD, there is very good agreement between the physical characteristics, the evolutionary channels that lead to the birth of these systems, and their birthrates. Regarding the double WD population, there is a good agreement on which evolutionary channels exist to create double WDs and a rough agreement on the characteristics of the double WD population. Regarding which progenitor systems lead to a single and double WD system and which systems do not, the four codes agree well. Most importantly, we find that for these two populations, the differences in the predictions from the four codes are not due to numerical differences, but because of different inherent assumptions. We identify critical assumptions for BPS studies that need to be studied in more detail.

13 pages, +21 pages appendix, 35 figures, accepted for publishing in A&A, Minor change to match published version, most important the added link to the website http://www.astro.ru.nl/~silviato/popcorn for more detailed figures and information

References in corpus (7)

• Post-common-envelope binaries from SDSS. IX: Constraining the common-envelope efficiency
• A multiphysics and multiscale software environment for modeling astrophysical systems
• Efficiency of mass transfer in massive close binaries, Tests from double-lined eclipsing binaries in the SMC
• Young and Massive Binary Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae and Their Circumstellar Matter
• Black Hole Spin Evolution: Implications for Short-hard Gamma Ray Bursts and Gravitational Wave Detection
• Population synthesis of ultracompact X-ray binaries in the Galactic Bulge
• Blue supergiant progenitor models of Type II supernovae

Cited by in corpus (75)

• Observational clues to the progenitors of Type-Ia supernovae
• COSMIC Variance in Binary Population Synthesis
• Theoretical uncertainties of the type Ia supernova rate
• The binarity of the local white dwarf population
• Star formation, supernovae, iron, and alpha: consistent cosmic and Galactic histories
• Predicting the LISA white dwarf binary population in the Milky Way with cosmological simulations
• Type Ia Supernova Explosions in Binary Systems: A Review
• The evolution of stellar triples: The most common evolutionary pathways
• Prototype Global Analysis of LISA Data with Multiple Source Types
• A cooling anomaly of high-mass white dwarfs
• BSE versus StarTrack: implementations of new wind, remnant-formation, and natal-kick schemes in NBODY7 and their astrophysical consequences
• Ages of Type Ia Supernovae Over Cosmic Time
• The ejected mass distribution of type Ia supernovae: A significant rate of non-Chandrasekhar-mass progenitors
• The effect of a wider initial separation on common envelope binary interaction simulations
• Finding binaries from phase modulation of pulsating stars with Kepler: V. Orbital parameters, with eccentricity and mass-ratio distributions of 341 new binaries
• Observationally driven Galactic double white dwarf population for LISA
• Looks can be deceiving: underestimating the age of single white dwarfs due to binary mergers
• Disentangling Coalescing Neutron Star-White Dwarf Binaries for LISA
• The effect of helium accretion efficiency on rates of Type Ia supernovae: double-detonations in accreting binaries
• On the formation of neutron stars via accretion-induced collapse in binaries
• Formation and evolution of hybrid He-CO white dwarfs and their properties
• The demographics of neutron star - white dwarf mergers: rates, delay-time distributions and progenitors
• He-accreting carbon-oxygen white dwarfs and type Ia supernovae
• Double white dwarf merger products among high-mass white dwarfs
• Thermonuclear explosion of a massive hybrid HeCO white-dwarf triggered by a He-detonation on a companion
• Multiple Stellar Evolution: a population synthesis algorithm to model the stellar, binary, and dynamical evolution of multiple-star systems
• Triage of the Gaia DR3 astrometric orbits. I. A sample of binaries with probable compact companions
• FBOTs and AT2018cow following electron-capture collapse of merged white dwarfs
• Where are the double-degenerate progenitors of type Ia supernovae?
• Gravitational wave sources in our Galactic backyard: Predictions for BHBH, BHNS and NSNS binaries detectable with LISA
• i-Process Contribution of Rapidly Accreting White Dwarfs to the Solar Composition of First-Peak Neutron-Capture Elements
• Single-Degenerate Type Ia Supernovae Are Preferentially Overluminous
• Gravitational-Wave Signatures from Compact Object Binaries in the Galactic Center
• BEER analysis of Kepler and CoRoT light curves: IV. Discovery of four new low-mass white dwarf companions in the Kepler data
• Constraints on single-degenerate Chandrasekhar mass progenitors of Type Iax supernovae
• Next generation population synthesis of accreting white dwarfs: I. Hybrid calculations using BSE + MESA
• Pre-explosion companion stars in Type Iax supernovae
• Early ultraviolet signatures from the interaction of Type Ia supernova ejecta with a stellar companion
• Super-Eddington wind scenario for the progenitors of type Ia supernovae: Accreting He-rich matter onto white dwarfs
• The Delay Times of Type Ia Supernova
• SCATTER: A New Common Envelope Formalism
• Discovery of a Detached, Eclipsing 40 min Period Double White Dwarf Binary and a Friend: Implications for He+CO White Dwarf Mergers
• A double white dwarf with a paradoxical origin?
• R Coronae Borealis Stars are Viable Factories of Pre-solar Grains
• dart_board: Binary Population Synthesis with Markov Chain Monte Carlo
• A gap in the double white dwarf separation distribution caused by the common-envelope evolution: astrometric evidence from Gaia
• Discovery of the first resolved triple white dwarf
• Interrupted Binary Mass Transfer in Star Clusters
• Mergers of Equal-Mass Binaries with Compact Object Companions from Mass Transfer in Triple Star Systems
• Golden galactic binaries for LISA: mass-transferring white dwarf black hole binaries
• The Galactic Nova Rate: Estimates from the ASAS-SN and Gaia Surveys
• Mass-ratio distribution of extremely low-mass white dwarf binaries
• A Triple Star Origin For T Pyx and Other Short-Period Recurrent Novae
• Formation of long-period post-common-envelope binaries II. Explaining the self-lensing binary KOI 3278
• Rates and delay times of Type Ia supernovae in the helium-enriched main-sequence donor scenario
• Binary white dwarfs in the halo of the Milky Way
• Is the X-ray pulsating companion of HD 49798 a possible type Ia supernova progenitor?
• Eclipses of continuous gravitational waves as a probe of stellar structure
• A population synthesis study of the Gaia 100 pc unresolved white dwarf-main sequence binary population
• Fast radio burst repeaters produced via Kozai-Lidov feeding of neutron stars in binary systems
• A closer look at non-interacting He stars as a channel for producing the old population of Type Ia supernovae
• Orbital radius during the grazing envelope evolution
• Statistics of Magrathea exoplanets beyond the Main Sequence. Simulating the long-term evolution of circumbinary giant planets with TRES
• Using chemical evolution models of the Milky Way disk to constrain Type Ia supernova progenitors
• Astrophysics with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
• Synthetic Population of Binary Cepheids. II. The effect of companion light on the extragalactic distance scale
• A strange dwarf scenario for the formation of the peculiar double white dwarf binary SDSS J125733.63+542850.5
• The role of triple evolution in the formation of LISA double white dwarfs
• A Search for Pulsar Companions Around Low-Mass White Dwarfs
• Producing type Ia supernovae from hybrid CONe white dwarfs with main-sequence binary companions at low metallicity of Z = 0.0001
• Lucky planets: how circum-binary planets survive the supernova in one of the inner-binary components
• Impact of convective overshooting on the single-degenerate model of Type Ia supernovae
• The effects of unresolved double-degenerates in the white dwarf luminosity function
• Observational signatures of the surviving donor star in the double detonation model of Type Ia supernovae
• The X-ray binaries in M83: will any of them form gravitational wave sources for LIGO/VIRGO/KAGRA?