How conventional measures overestimate electroweak fine-tuning in supersymmetric theory
arXiv:1309.2984 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.095013
Abstract
The lack of evidence for superparticles at the CERN LHC, along with the rather high value of the Higgs mass, has sharpened the perception that supersymmetric model parameter space is highly electroweak fine-tuned (EWFT). We compare three measures of fine-tuning in SUSY models. 1. \Del_HS measures a terms containing large log contributions to m_Z that are inevitable in models defined at scales much higher than the electroweak scale. 2. \Del_BG measures variation in m_Z against variation of model parameters and allows for correlations among high scale parameters which are not included in \Del_HS. 3. The model-independent \Del_EW measures how naturally a model can generate the measured value of m_Z=91.2 GeV in terms of weak scale parameters alone. We hypothesize an overarching Ultimate Theory (UTH) wherein the high scale soft terms are all correlated. The UTH might be contained within the more general effective SUSY theories popular in the literature. For \Del_HS, EWFT can be overestimated by neglecting additional non-independent terms which lead to large cancellations. For \Del_BG, EWFT can be overestimated by applying the measure to the effective theories instead of to the UTH. The measure \Del_EW allows for the possibility of parameter correlations which should be present in the UTH and, since it is model-independent, provides the same value of EWFT for the effective theories as should occur for the UTH. We find that the well-known mSUGRA/CMSSM model is fine-tuned under all three measures so that it is unlikely to contain the UTH. The non-universal Higgs model NUHM2 appears fine-tuned with \Del_HS,BG > 10^3. But since \Del_EW can be as small as 7 (corresponding to 14% fine-tuning), it may contain the UTH for parameter ranges which allow for low true EWFT.
arXiv comment28 pages with 17 .png figures; version 2 has expanded references and several typos fixed; version 3 includes added discussion to coincide with published version in PRD
References in corpus (73)
- Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC
- Observation of a new boson at a mass of 125 GeV with the CMS experiment at the LHC
- Study of Constrained Minimal Supersymmetry
- Naturalness Constraints in Supersymmetric Theories with Non-Universal Soft Terms
- Natural SUSY Endures
- A Natural SUSY Higgs Near 125 GeV
- The More Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model
- Focus Points and Naturalness in Supersymmetry
- Higgs Boson Theory and Phenomenology
- Naturalness, Weak Scale Supersymmetry and the Prospect for the Observation of Supersymmetry at the Tevatron and at the LHC
- The Supersymmetric Particle Spectrum
- Radiative natural SUSY with a 125 GeV Higgs boson
- Direct, Indirect and Collider Detection of Neutralino Dark Matter In SUSY Models with Non-universal Higgs Masses
- The MSSM Parameter Space with Non-Universal Higgs Masses
- SUSY, the Third Generation and the LHC
- Supersymmetry, Naturalness, and Signatures at the LHC
- NMSSM Higgs Benchmarks Near 125 GeV
- Implications of a 125 GeV Higgs scalar for LHC SUSY and neutralino dark matter searches
- Exploration of the MSSM with Non-Universal Higgs Masses
- A Solution to the Supersymmetric Fine-Tuning Problem within the MSSM
- Search for squarks and gluinos with the ATLAS detector in final states with jets and missing transverse momentum using 4.7 fb^-1 of sqrt(s) = 7 TeV proton-proton collision data
- Naturalness and the Status of Supersymmetry
- Radiative natural supersymmetry: Reconciling electroweak fine-tuning and the Higgs boson mass
- Measures of fine tuning
- Naturalness Implications of LEP Results
- Focus Point Supersymmetry Redux
- Can The Supersymmetric Flavor Problem Decouple?
- Natural Supersymmetry: LHC, dark matter and ILC searches
- Search for supersymmetry in hadronic final states using MT2 in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 7 TeV
- Hidden SUSY at the LHC: the light higgsino-world scenario and the role of a lepton collider
- The fine-tuning of the generalised NMSSM
- The MSSM fine tuning problem: a way out
- The fine-tuning price of LEP
- Compressed supersymmetry and natural neutralino dark matter from top squark-mediated annihilation to top quarks
- Post-LHC7 fine-tuning in the mSUGRA/CMSSM model with a 125 GeV Higgs boson
- The Last Vestiges of Naturalness
- Naturalness and superpartner masses or when to give up on weak scale supersymmetry
- Haggling over the fine-tuning price
- The generalised NMSSM at one loop: fine tuning and phenomenology
- Naturalness, Supersymmetry and Implications for LHC and Dark Matter
- Relaxed fine-tuning in models with non-universal gaugino masses
- Fine tuning as an indication of physics beyond the MSSM
- Fine-Tuning Constraints on Supergravity Models
- Direct and indirect detection of higgsino-like WIMPs: concluding the story of electroweak naturalness
- On the treatment of threshold effects in SUSY spectrum computations
- Probing Dark Matter at the LHC using Vector Boson Fusion Processes
- A Natural 125 GeV Higgs Boson in the MSSM from Focus Point Supersymmetry with A-Terms
- XENON100 Implications for Naturalness in the MSSM, NMSSM and lambda-SUSY
- Non-Universal Gaugino Masses and Natural Supersymmetry
- Same sign diboson signature from supersymmetry models with light higgsinos at the LHC
- Naturalness of the Non-Universal MSSM in the light of the recent Higgs results
- A Collider Signature of the Supersymmetric Golden Region
- Multi-Channel Search for Minimal Supergravity at and Colliders
- Non-universal soft scalar masses in supersymmetric theories
- Non-universal gaugino masses and fine tuning implications for SUSY searches in the MSSM and the GNMSSM
- Higgs Boson Mass, Proton Decay, Naturalness and Constraints of LHC and Planck Data
- Focus Point Supersymmetry: Proton Decay, Flavor and CP Violation, and the Higgs Boson Mass
- Testing SUSY at the LHC: Electroweak and Dark matter fine tuning at two-loop order
- Quantified naturalness from Bayesian statistics
- Fine-tuning implications for complementary dark matter and LHC SUSY searches
- The fine-tuning cost of the likelihood in SUSY models
- The Higgs: so simple yet so unnatural
- Natural MSSM after the LHC 8 TeV run
- Fine-Tuning Implications of Direct Dark Matter Searches in the MSSM
- Optimising Stop Naturalness
- Fine Tuning in the Constrained Exceptional Supersymmetric Standard Model
- 125 GeV Higgs as a pseudo-Goldstone boson in supersymmetry with vector-like matters
- Naturalness and GUT Scale Yukawa Coupling Ratios in the CMSSM
- Peccei-Quinn NMSSM in the light of 125 GeV Higgs
- Electroweak versus high scale finetuning in the 19-parameter SUGRA model
- Naturalness, Supersymmetry and Light Higgsinos: A Snowmass Whitepaper
- Natural SUSY from SU(5) Orbifold GUT
- Leaving no stone unturned in the hunt for SUSY naturalness: A Snowmass whitepaper
Cited by in corpus (95)
- Dark matter production in the early Universe: beyond the thermal WIMP paradigm
- Cosmological Moduli and the Post-Inflationary Universe: A Critical Review
- Physics at the e+ e- Linear Collider
- SUSY models under siege: LHC constraints and electroweak fine-tuning
- Monojet plus soft dilepton signal from light higgsino pair production at LHC14
- Global fits of GUT-scale SUSY models with GAMBIT
- Combined collider constraints on neutralinos and charginos
- Supersymmetry, Naturalness, and Light Higgsinos
- Monojets and mono-photons from light higgsino pair production at LHC14
- SUSY under siege from direct and indirect WIMP detection experiments
- Upper bounds on sparticle masses from naturalness or how to disprove weak scale supersymmetry
- Midi-review: Status of weak scale supersymmetry after LHC Run 2 and ton-scale noble liquid WIMP searches
- Revisiting the SUSY mu problem and its solutions in the LHC era
- Mainly axion cold dark matter from natural supersymmetry
- Anomalous muon magnetic moment, supersymmetry, naturalness, LHC search limits and the landscape
- Mixed axion/neutralino dark matter in the SUSY DFSZ axion model
- Revisiting fine-tuning in the MSSM
- Radiatively-driven natural supersymmetry at the LHC
- Coupled Boltzmann computation of mixed axion neutralino dark matter in the SUSY DFSZ axion model
- Natural NMSSM after LHC Run I and the Higgsino dominated dark matter scenario
- Natural SUSY with a bino- or wino-like LSP
- Multi-channel assault on natural supersymmetry at the high luminosity LHC
- Natural generalized mirage mediation
- Naturalness and Dark Matter in the BLSSM
- Non-universal gaugino masses and semi-natural supersymmetry in view of the Higgs boson discovery
- Higgs Couplings and Naturalness in -SUSY
- Closing up a light stop window in natural SUSY at LHC
- A natural Little Hierarchy for SUSY from radiative breaking of PQ symmetry
- The Reach of the High-Energy LHC for Gluinos and Top Squarks in SUSY Models with Light Higgsinos
- LHC luminosity and energy upgrades confront natural supersymmetry models
- Current Status of Natural NMSSM in Light of LHC 13TeV Data and XENON-1T Results
- Higgs and superparticle mass predictions from the string theory landscape
- Gluino-SUGRA scenarios in light of FNAL muon g-2 anomaly
- The Higgs mass and natural supersymmetric spectrum from the landscape
- Strong constraints of LUX-2016 results on the natural NMSSM
- Improved Measurements and Wino/Higgsino Dark Matter
- Bayesian naturalness of the CMSSM and CNMSSM
- On the MSSM Higgsino mass and fine tuning
- Supersymmetry with Dark Matter is still natural
- Top-squark in natural SUSY under current LHC run-2 data
- Gluino reach and mass extraction at the LHC in radiatively-driven natural SUSY
- Gravity safe, electroweak natural axionic solution to strong CP and SUSY mu problems
- A top-squark hunter's guide
- Supergravity gauge theories strike back: There is no crisis for SUSY but a new collider may be required for discovery
- Catching sparks from well-forged neutralinos
- Naturalness implies intra-generational degeneracy for decoupled squarks and sleptons
- and SUSY Dark Matter: Direct Detection and Collider Search Complementarity
- Particle Spectroscopy of Supersymmetric SU(5) in Light of 125 GeV Higgs and Muon g-2 Data
- Prospects for Higgs coupling measurements in SUSY with radiatively-driven naturalness
- The LHC higgsino discovery plane for present and future SUSY searches
- The current status of fine-tuning in supersymmetry
- Anomaly mediated SUSY breaking model retrofitted for naturalness
- Naturalness versus stringy naturalness (with implications for collider and dark matter searches)
- En-gauging Naturalness
- Constraining SUSY with Heavy Scalars -- using the CMB
- What hadron collider is required to discover or falsify natural supersymmetry?
- The ILC as a natural SUSY discovery machine and precision microscope: from light higgsinos to tests of unification
- Naturalness, b to s gamma, and SUSY Heavy Higgses
- Aspects of the same-sign diboson signature from wino pair production with light higgsinos at the high luminosity LHC
- New angular (and other) cuts to improve the higgsino signal at the LHC
- Higgs Boson Spectra in Supersymmetric Left-Right Models
- Superparticle phenomenology from the natural mini-landscape
- Where to look for natural supersymmetry
- The cosmological moduli problem and naturalness
- Comparison of SUSY spectra generators for natural SUSY and string landscape predictions
- Exploring Non-Holomorphic Soft Terms in the Framework of Gauge Mediated Supersymmetry Breaking
- Implications of naturalness for the heavy Higgs bosons of supersymmetry
- Natural Supersymmetry: Status and Prospects
- Naughty or Nice? The Role of the `N' in the Natural NMSSM for the LHC
- Radiative natural SUSY spectrum from deflected AMSB scenario with messenger-matter interactions
- Explaining The Muon Anomaly and New CDF II W-Boson Mass in the Framework of (Extra)Ordinary Gauge Mediation
- Radiative natural supersymmetry emergent from the string landscape
- Leptogenesis scenarios for natural SUSY with mixed axion-higgsino dark matter
- Distinguishing LSP archetypes via gluino pair production at LHC13
- Improving naturalness in Gauge Mediation with non-unified messenger sectors
- Supersymmetry: Aspirations and Prospects
- Generalized focus point and mass spectra comparison of highly natural SUGRA GUT models
- Is the magnitude of the Peccei-Quinn scale set by the landscape?
- Investigating New Physics Models with Signature of Same-Sign Diboson +
- Dominant production of heavier Higgs bosons through vector boson fusion in NMSSM
- Testing Higgs boson scenarios in the phenomenological NMSSM
- Supersoft Stops
- Electroweak Naturalness and Deflected Mirage Mediation
- Non-minimal Coupling Inflation and Dark Matter under the Symmetry
- Precision gaugino mass measurements as a probe of large trilinear soft terms at ILC
- NMSSM with generalized deflected mirage mediation
- Detecting Heavy Higgs Bosons from Natural SUSY at a 100 TeV Hadron Collider
- Type-II neutrino seesaw mechanism extension of NMSSM from SUSY breaking mechanisms
- Analysis of fine-tuning measures in models with extended Higgs sectors
- Light Higgsinos for electroweak naturalness in mirage-mediated high-scale supersymmetry
- Same-sign Higgsino Production at the CERN LHC: How Not to Hunt for Natural Supersymmetry
- Impact of the LZ Experiment on the DM Phenomenology and Naturalness in the MSSM
- Implications of Mixed Axion-Neutralino Dark Matter
- Mass Hierarchies with GeV from Natural SUSY
- Natural SUSY: LHC and Dark Matter direct detection experiments interplay