Naturalness and the Status of Supersymmetry

Abstract

For decades, the unnaturalness of the weak scale has been the dominant problem motivating new particle physics, and weak-scale supersymmetry has been the dominant proposed solution. This paradigm is now being challenged by a wealth of experimental data. In this review, we begin by recalling the theoretical motivations for weak-scale supersymmetry, including the gauge hierarchy problem, grand unification, and WIMP dark matter, and their implications for superpartner masses. These are set against the leading constraints on supersymmetry from collider searches, the Higgs boson mass, and low-energy constraints on flavor and CP violation. We then critically examine attempts to quantify naturalness in supersymmetry, stressing the many subjective choices that impact the results both quantitatively and qualitatively. Finally, we survey various proposals for natural supersymmetric models, including effective supersymmetry, focus point supersymmetry, compressed supersymmetry, and R-parity-violating supersymmetry, and summarize their key features, current status, and implications for future experiments.

38 pages, to appear in Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science; v2: fixed typos, updated Higgs results, added references and a parable, published version

References in corpus (25)

• Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC
• Observation of a new boson at a mass of 125 GeV with the CMS experiment at the LHC
• Dark Matter Candidates from Particle Physics and Methods of Detection
• Echoes of a Hidden Valley at Hadron Colliders
• Cosmology and Astrophysics of Minimal Dark Matter
• Non-perturbative Effect on Thermal Relic Abundance of Dark Matter
• The Tevatron at the Frontier of Dark Matter Direct Detection
• Maverick dark matter at colliders
• Supersymmetry, Naturalness, and Signatures at the LHC
• Flavor in Supersymmetry with an Extended R-symmetry
• Higgs boson mass in supersymmetry to three loops
• Higgs Sector in Extensions of the MSSM
• Compressed supersymmetry and natural neutralino dark matter from top squark-mediated annihilation to top quarks
• Relaxed fine-tuning in models with non-universal gaugino masses
• Possible Effects of a Hidden Valley on Supersymmetric Phenomenology
• Direct Search of Dark Matter in High-Scale Supersymmetry
• Naturalness of the Non-Universal MSSM in the light of the recent Higgs results
• Natural SUSY's Last Hope: R-parity Violation via UDD Operators
• Inverted sfermion mass hierarchy and the Higgs boson mass in the MSSM
• New Patterns of Natural R-Parity Violation with Supersymmetric Gauged Flavor
• Exploring compressed supersymmetry with same-sign top quarks at the Large Hadron Collider
• Focus Point in Gaugino Mediation ~ Reconsideration of the Fine-tuning Problem ~
• The top squark-mediated annihilation scenario and direct detection of dark matter in compressed supersymmetry
• A Complete Model for R-parity Violation
• Bino-Higgsino Mixed Dark Matter in a Focus Point Gaugino Mediation

Cited by in corpus (147)

• Search for New Physics with Atoms and Molecules
• A facility to Search for Hidden Particles at the CERN SPS: the SHiP physics case
• Experimental Searches for the Axion and Axion-like Particles
• Cosmological constant and vacuum energy: old and new ideas
• Physics at the e+ e- Linear Collider
• Standard Model anatomy of WIMP dark matter direct detection II: QCD analysis and hadronic matrix elements
• SUSY models under siege: LHC constraints and electroweak fine-tuning
• Consistency of the Standard Model Effective Field Theory
• How conventional measures overestimate electroweak fine-tuning in supersymmetric theory
• WIMP-nucleon scattering with heavy WIMP effective theory
• The Electroweak Phase Transition: A Collider Target
• A light Higgs scalar in the NMSSM confronted with the latest LHC Higgs data
• The MSSM Higgs sector at a high $M_{SUSY}$: reopening the low tan$\beta$ regime and heavy Higgs searches
• Toward Full LHC Coverage of Natural Supersymmetry
• A Global Analysis of Dark Matter Signals from 27 Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies using 11 Years of Fermi-LAT Observations
• Light Neutralino Dark Matter: Direct/Indirect Detection and Collider Searches
• Standard Model anatomy of WIMP dark matter direct detection I: weak-scale matching
• Direct and indirect detection of higgsino-like WIMPs: concluding the story of electroweak naturalness
• Upper bounds on sparticle masses from naturalness or how to disprove weak scale supersymmetry
• Brout-Englert-Higgs physics: From foundations to phenomenology
• Uncovering Natural Supersymmetry via the interplay between the LHC and Direct Dark Matter Detection
• The State of Supersymmetry after Run I of the LHC
• Dark matter and Higgs bosons in the MSSM
• Search for direct production of supersymmetric partners of the top quark in the all-jets final state in proton-proton collisions at sqrt(s) = 13 TeV
• Midi-review: Status of weak scale supersymmetry after LHC Run 2 and ton-scale noble liquid WIMP searches
• Flavor Constraints from Unitarity and Analyticity
• Maximally Natural Supersymmetry
• NMSSM with a singlino LSP: possible challenges for searches for supersymmetry at the LHC
• Criteria for Natural Hierarchies
• Search for top squark production in fully-hadronic final states in proton-proton collisions at $\sqrt{s}=$ 13 TeV
• The Electroweak Sector of the pMSSM in the Light of LHC - 8 TeV and Other Data
• Conformal Extensions of the Standard Model with Veltman Conditions
• Reduced LHC constraints for higgsino-like heavier electroweakinos
• Zeeman interaction in ThO $H^3{\Delta }_1$ for the electron EDM search
• Dark Matter Detection in Focus Point Supersymmetry
• Cornering Natural SUSY at LHC Run II and Beyond
• New Supersoft Supersymmetry Breaking Operators and a Solution to the $\mu$ Problem
• Natural Supersymmetry, Muon $g-2$, and the Last Crevices for the Top Squark
• Non-universal gaugino masses and semi-natural supersymmetry in view of the Higgs boson discovery
• Exploring MSSM for Charge and Color Breaking and Other Constraints in the Context of Higgs@125 GeV
• What is a Natural SUSY scenario?
• Search for supersymmetry in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 13 TeV in the single-lepton final state using the sum of masses of large-radius jets
• Gravity, Scale Invariance and the Hierarchy Problem
• Electron electric dipole moment searches using clock transitions in ultracold molecules
• CP violation in the B system
• Two Notions of Naturalness
• CMSSM, naturalness and the "fine-tuning price" of the Very Large Hadron Collider
• A top-squark hunter's guide
• Supergravity gauge theories strike back: There is no crisis for SUSY but a new collider may be required for discovery
• Rare b hadron decays at the LHC
• Prospects for Higgs coupling measurements in SUSY with radiatively-driven naturalness
• Visible sector inflation and the right thermal history in light of Planck data
• Natural NMSSM confronting with the LHC7-8
• Search for supersymmetry in pp collisions at $\sqrt{s}=$ 13 TeV with 137 fb${}^{-1}$ in final states with a single lepton using the sum of masses of large-radius jets
• Naturalness after LHC8
• Minimal Froggatt-Nielsen Textures
• The Search for Electroweakinos
• Post LHC8 SUSY benchmark points for ILC physics
• Focus Point Supersymmetry in Extended Gauge Mediation
• Search for supersymmetry in the all-hadronic final state using top quark tagging in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 13 TeV
• Search for direct pair production of supersymmetric top quarks decaying to all-hadronic final states in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 8 TeV
• One residue to rule them all: Electroweak symmetry breaking, inflation and field-space geometry
• Asymptotic Scale Invariance and its Consequences
• Search for higgsino pair production in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 13 TeV in final states with large missing transverse momentum and two Higgs bosons decaying via H to bb-bar
• Pair production of 125 GeV Higgs boson in the SM extension with color-octet scalars at the LHC
• Naturalness, b to s gamma, and SUSY Heavy Higgses
• Heavy Bino Dark Matter and Collider Signals in the MSSM with Vector-like 4th-Generation Particles
• Six Top Messages of New Physics at the LHC
• The WIMP Paradigm: Theme and Variations
• Digging Deeper for New Physics in the LHC Data
• Toward the ultimate reach of current imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes and their sensitivity to TeV dark matter
• Dilaton-assisted generation of the Fermi scale from the Planck scale
• Electroweak versus high scale finetuning in the 19-parameter SUGRA model
• Effects of Curvature-Higgs Coupling on Electroweak Fine-Tuning
• Search for $R$-parity violating supersymmetry in pp collisions at $\sqrt{s}=$ 13 TeV using b jets in a final state with a single lepton, many jets, and high sum of large-radius jet masses
• Search for supersymmetry in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 13 TeV in the single-lepton final state using the sum of masses of large-radius jets
• A concise review on some Higgs-related new physics models in light of current experiments
• Advantages of Unity With SU(4)-Color: Reflections Through Neutrino Oscillations, Baryogenesis and Proton Decay
• Naturalness of scale-invariant NMSSMs with and without extra matter
• Natural Scherk-Schwarz Theories of the Weak Scale
• Yukawa Unification in an SO(10) SUSY GUT: SUSY on the Edge
• A decade of dark matter searches with ground-based Cherenkov telescopes
• Natural Supersymmetry in Warped Space
• Naturalness, Supersymmetry and Light Higgsinos: A Snowmass Whitepaper
• A Swarm of Bs
• AC Stark effect in ThO $H^3{\Delta }_1$ for the electron EDM search
• The past, present and future of the heavier electroweakinos in the light of LHC and other data
• MSSM4G: Reviving Bino Dark Matter with Vector-like 4th Generation Particles
• Tagging Boosted Ws with Wavelets
• Excessive Higgs pair production with little MET from squarks and gluinos in the NMSSM
• The Practice of Naturalness: A Historical-Philosophical Perspective
• An analysis of a minimal vectorlike extension of the Standard Model
• Measuring the polarization of boosted, hadronic $W$ bosons with jet substructure observables
• PeV Scale Right Handed Neutrino Dark Matter in $S_4$ Flavor Symmetric extra U(1) model
• Natural SUSY at LHC with Right-Sneutrino LSP
• Stop-mass prediction in naturalness scenarios within MSSM-25
• Auto-Concealment of Supersymmetry in Extra Dimensions
• Multilepton signals of heavier electroweakinos at the LHC
• Generalized focus point and mass spectra comparison of highly natural SUGRA GUT models
• Radiative Corrections to Aid the Direct Detection of the Higgsino-like Neutralino Dark Matter: Spin-Independent Interactions
• QFT without infinities and hierarchy problem
• $W$ boson mass tension caused by its right-handed gauge coupling at high energies?
• A counterexample to the Nelson-Seiberg theorem
• Supergravity Model of Inflation and Explaining IceCube HESE Data via PeV Dark Matter Decay
• Rare Flavor Processes in Maximally Natural Supersymmetry
• Supersymmetry and the collider Dark Matter picture
• Supersymmetric hybrid inflation with non-minimal coupling to gravity
• Sensitivity of the future ${\mathbf{e}}^{-}\mathbf{p}$ collider to the coupling of axion-like particles with vector bosons
• Discovering and profiling Z' bosons using asymmetry observables in top quark pair production with the lepton-plus-jets final state at the LHC
• The ABC of RPV II: Classification of R-parity Violating Signatures from UDD Couplings and their Coverage at the LHC
• Reducing the fine-tuning of gauge-mediated SUSY breaking
• Dreaming Awake: Disentangling the Underlying Physics in Case of a SUSY-like Discovery at the LHC
• Sbottom discovery via mixed decays at the LHC
• Gluino Meets Flavored Naturalness
• SUSY Signals from QCD Production at the Upgraded LHC
• Naturalness and a light $Z^{\prime }$
• Status and Implications of BSM Searches at the LHC
• The hierarchy problem and fine-tuning in a decoupling approach to multi-scale effective potentials
• Realization of Sneutrino Self-interacting Dark Matter in the Focus Point Supersymmetry
• PQ-symmetry for a small Dirac neutrino mass, dark radiation and cosmic neutrinos
• Precise interpretations of traditional fine-tuning measures
• Long-term LHC Discovery Reach for Compressed Higgsino-like Models using VBF Processes
• Hiding the little hierarchy problem in the NMSSM
• Dark Matter and Fundamental Physics Searches with IACTs
• Supersymmetry with a Heavy Lightest Supersymmetric Particle
• Constraints on Natural Supersymmetry from Electroweak Precision Tests
• Unified Maximally Natural Supersymmetry
• Non-renormalizable theories and finite formulation of QFT
• Lightest Higgs boson decays $h\to MZ$ in the $\mu$ from $\nu$ supersymmetric standard model
• The Early Universe with High-Scale Supersymmetry
• A Realization of Effective SUSY with Strong Unification
• Probing Compressed Mass Spectrum Supersymmetry at the LHC with the Vector Boson Fusion Topology
• Pair production of the lightest chargino at $\gamma \gamma$-collider
• Naturalness as a reasonable scientific principle in fundamental physics
• Searches for Dark Matter Particles at the LHC
• Phenomenological aspects of supergravity theories in de Sitter vacua
• Preferred hierarchy scales from the product landscape
• Wish-list for Run II top quark measurements (for BSM)
• The Hierarchy Solution to the LHC Inverse Problem
• Little hierarchy in the minimally specified MSSM
• Non-thermal production of Higgsino dark matter by late-decaying scalar fields
• Revisiting the gluino mass limits in the pMSSM in the light of the latest LHC data and Dark Matter constraints
• Hybrid Anomaly and Gravity Mediation for Electroweak Supersymmetry
• Fine-tuned Spin-3/2 and the Hierarchy Problem
• Off-Shell Supersymmetry
• Correlated Electric and Magnetic Dipole Moment in Natural Supersymmetry
• SUSY scenarios according to EWSB