Real or Interloper? The Redshift Likelihoods of z>8 Galaxies in the HUDF12
arXiv:1304.4594 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/775/1/11
Abstract
In the absence of spectra, fitting template model spectra to observed photometric fluxes, known as Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting, has become the workhorse for identifying high-z galaxies. In this paper, we present an analysis of the most recent and possibly most distant galaxies discovered in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field using a more robust method of redshift estimation based on Markov Chain Monte Carlo fitting (MCMC), rather than relying on the redshift of "best fit" models obtained using common chi^2 minimization techniques. The advantage of MCMC fitting is the ability to accurately estimate the probability density function of the redshift, as well as any other input model parameters, allowing us to derive accurate credible intervals by properly marginalizing over all other input model parameters. We apply our method to 13 recently identified sources and show that, despite claims based on chi^2 minimization, none of these sources can be securely ruled out as low redshift interlopers given the low signal-to-noise of currently available observations. We estimate that there is an average probability of 21% that these sources are low redshift interlopers.
arXiv comment18 Pages, 2 Figures, 1 Table. Accepted to ApJ
References in corpus (38)
- Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Evolutionary population synthesis: models, analysis of the ingredients and application to high-z galaxies
- Constraining the Evolution of the Ionizing Background and the Epoch of Reionization with z ~ 6 Quasars II: A Sample of 19 Quasars
- The Stellar Populations and Evolution of Lyman Break Galaxies
- The Abundance of Star-Forming Galaxies in the Redshift Range 8.5 to 12: New Results from the 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field Campaign
- CLASH: Three Strongly Lensed Images of a Candidate z ~ 11 Galaxy
- A candidate redshift z ~ 10 galaxy and rapid changes in that population at an age of 500 Myr
- Ultradeep Near-Infrared ISAAC Observations of the HDF-S: Observations, Reduction, Multicolor Catalog, and Photometric Redshifts
- Galaxies at z = 6 - 9 from the WFC3/IR imaging of the HUDF
- Color-selected galaxies at z~6 in the Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey
- Very Strong Emission-Line Galaxies in the WISP Survey and Implications for High-Redshift Galaxies
- The Luminosity Function of Lyman Alpha Emitters at Redshift z~5.7
- A robust sample of galaxies at redshifts 6.0<z<8.7: stellar populations, star-formation rates and stellar masses
- Star formation rates and stellar masses of z=7-8 galaxies from IRAC observations of the WFC3/IR ERS and the HUDF field
- The Rising Star-Formation Histories of Distant Galaxies and Implications for Gas Accretion with Time
- The luminosity function, halo masses and stellar masses of luminous Lyman-break galaxies at redshifts 5<z<6
- Evidence for a Massive Post-Starburst Galaxy at z ~ 6.5
- Optical to mid-IR observations of Lyman-alpha galaxies at redshift 5 in the HUDF: a young and low mass population
- An overdensity of galaxies at z=5.9 +/-0.2 in the Ultra Deep Field confirmed using the ACS grism
- Spectroscopic confirmation of a galaxy at redshift z=8.6
- GRAPES, Grism Spectroscopy of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: Description and Data Reduction
- Approaching Reionization: The Evolution of the Lyman Alpha Forest from Redshifts Four to Six
- Discovery of a possibly old galaxy at , multiply imaged by the massive cluster Abell 383
- ISAAC/VLT observations of a lensed galaxy at z=10.0
- A Tentative Detection of an Emission Line at 1.6 μm for the z~12 Candidate UDFj-39546284
- Spectroscopy of luminous z>7 galaxy candidates and sources of contamination in z>7 galaxy searches
- Stellar populations and Lya emission in two lensed z>~6 galaxies
- Spectroscopic Confirmation of Faint Lyman Break Galaxies at Redshifts Four and Five in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field
- On Contamination and Completeness in z>5 Lyman Break Galaxy Surveys
- HUDF-JD2: Mid-infrared Evidence for a z~2 Luminous Infrared Galaxy
- VLT/XSHOOTER & Subaru/MOIRCS Spectroscopy of HUDF-YD3: No Evidence for Lyman-alpha Emission at z=8.55
- Expanding the search for galaxies at z ~7-10 with new NICMOS Parallel Fields
- A Lyman Break Galaxy Candidate at z~9
- Gemini H-band imaging of the field of a z=10 candidate
- A Link to the Past: Using Markov Chain Monte Carlo Fitting to Constrain Fundamental Parameters of High-Redshift Galaxies
- Reanalysis of the spectrum of the z=10 galaxy
- Deep VLT V-band Imaging of the Field of a z=10 Candidate Galaxy: Below the Lyman Limit?
Cited by in corpus (15)
- The Occurrence and Architecture of Exoplanetary Systems
- The Frontier Fields: Survey Design
- What asteroseismology can do for exoplanets: Kepler-410A b is a Small Neptune around a bright star, in an eccentric orbit consistent with low obliquity
- The bright-end galaxy candidates at z ~ 9 from 79 independent HST fields
- The Sizes of Candidate Galaxies: confirmation of the bright CANDELS sample and relation with luminosity and mass
- An ALMA survey of the S2CLS UDS field: Optically invisible submillimetre galaxies
- Bright galaxies at Hubble's redshift detection frontier: Preliminary results and design from the redshift z~9-10 BoRG pure-parallel HST survey
- FIGS -- Faint Infrared Grism Survey: Description and Data Reduction
- ALMA will determine the spectroscopic redshift z>8 with FIR [O III] emission lines
- A High Space Density of Luminous Lyman Alpha Emitters at z~6.5
- Characterization and modeling of contamination for Lyman break galaxy samples at high redshift
- Simultaneous Estimation of Photometric Redshifts and SED Parameters: Improved Techniques and a Realistic Error Budget
- CLASH: Extreme Emission Line Galaxies and Their Implication on Selection of High-Redshift Galaxies
- Not In Our Backyard: Spectroscopic Support for the CLASH z=11 Candidate MACS0647-JD
- Performance of Photometric Template Fitting for Ultra-High Redshift Galaxies