Biased Assimilation, Homophily and the Dynamics of Polarization
arXiv:1209.5998 · doi:10.1073/pnas.1217220110
Abstract
Are we as a society getting more polarized, and if so, why? We try to answer this question through a model of opinion formation. Empirical studies have shown that homophily results in polarization. However, we show that DeGroot's well-known model of opinion formation based on repeated averaging can never be polarizing, even if individuals are arbitrarily homophilous. We generalize DeGroot's model to account for a phenomenon well-known in social psychology as biased assimilation: when presented with mixed or inconclusive evidence on a complex issue, individuals draw undue support for their initial position thereby arriving at a more extreme opinion. We show that in a simple model of homophilous networks, our biased opinion formation process results in either polarization, persistent disagreement or consensus depending on how biased individuals are. In other words, homophily alone, without biased assimilation, is not sufficient to polarize society. Quite interestingly, biased assimilation also provides insight into the following related question: do internet based recommender algorithms that show us personalized content contribute to polarization? We make a connection between biased assimilation and the polarizing effects of some random-walk based recommender algorithms that are similar in spirit to some commonly used recommender algorithms.
Cited by in corpus (61)
- Novel Multidimensional Models of Opinion Dynamics in Social Networks
- Opinion Dynamics in Social Networks with Hostile Camps: Consensus vs. Polarization
- How Algorithmic Confounding in Recommendation Systems Increases Homogeneity and Decreases Utility
- A Tutorial on Modeling and Analysis of Dynamic Social Networks. Part II
- Measuring Political Polarization: Twitter shows the two sides of Venezuela
- Opinion dynamics: models, extensions and external effects
- Recent advances in opinion propagation dynamics: A 2020 Survey
- An Influence Network Model to Study Discrepancies in Expressed and Private Opinions
- Understanding Echo Chambers in E-commerce Recommender Systems
- Nonlinear Opinion Dynamics with Tunable Sensitivity
- Opinion Polarization by Learning from Social Feedback
- Correcting for Selection Bias in Learning-to-rank Systems
- Fighting Fire with Fire: Using Antidote Data to Improve Polarization and Fairness of Recommender Systems
- Studying Fake News Spreading, Polarisation Dynamics, and Manipulation by Bots: a Tale of Networks and Language
- Emergence of polarized ideological opinions in multidimensional topic spaces
- From classical to modern opinion dynamics
- A Model for the Influence of Media on the Ideology of Content in Online Social Networks
- Opinion Dynamics of Online Social Network Users: A Micro-Level Analysis
- User-controllable Recommendation Against Filter Bubbles
- Flocking in complex environments -- attention trade-offs in collective information processing
- Cognitive cascades: How to model (and potentially counter) the spread of fake news
- Coevolutionary Dynamics of Actions and Opinions in Social Networks
- Extracting significant signal of news consumption from social networks: the case of Twitter in Italian political elections
- Intelligent social bots uncover the link between user preference and diversity of news consumption
- Social Conformity Despite Individual Preferences for Distinctiveness
- The few-get-richer: a surprising consequence of popularity-based rankings
- Modeling Explosive Opinion Depolarization in Interdependent Topics
- An Argument Communication Model of Polarization and Ideological Alignment
- Dynamics of opinion polarization
- Analysis and control of agreement and disagreement opinion cascades
- The Great Divide: Drivers of Polarization in the US Public
- A Laplacian Approach to Stubborn Agents and their Role in Opinion Formation on Influence Networks
- Bounded Confidence under Preferential Flip: A Coupled Dynamics of Structural Balance and Opinions
- Multidimensional political polarization in online social networks
- Link recommendations: Their impact on network structure and minorities
- Differential Inequalities in Multi-Agent Coordination and Opinion Dynamics Modeling
- Fast Evaluation for Relevant Quantities of Opinion Dynamics
- Local Edge Dynamics and Opinion Polarization
- About renegades and outgroup-haters: Modelling the link between social influence and intergroup attitudes
- Tell me something my friends do not know: Diversity maximization in social networks
- Towards Psychologically-Grounded Dynamic Preference Models
- Polarized Ukraine 2014: Opinion and Territorial Split Demonstrated with the Bounded Confidence XY Model, Parameterized by Twitter Data
- Spatial Opinion Dynamics and the Effects of Two Types of Mixing
- Discrete-Time Polar Opinion Dynamics with Susceptibility
- A model for the competition between political mono-polarization and bi-polarization
- Opinion disparity in hypergraphs with community structure
- Probabilistic Social Learning Improves the Public's Detection of Misinformation
- Opinion polarization in human communities can emerge as a natural consequence of beliefs being interrelated
- Information Evolution in Complex Networks
- Exploring the foundation of social diversity and coherence with a novel attraction-repulsion model framework
- Social Network Heterogeneity Promotes Depolarization of Multidimensional Correlated Opinions
- Discord in the voter model for complex networks
- Importance of initial conditions in the polarization of complex networks
- Collective patterns and stable misunderstandings in networks striving for consensus without a common value system
- Classification-Based Opinion Formation Model Embedding Agents' Psychological Traits
- PIE: Personalized Interest Exploration for Large-Scale Recommender Systems
- Computational Methods in Professional Communication
- Efficient Algorithms for Relevant Quantities of Friedkin-Johnsen Opinion Dynamics Model
- Mesoscopic analytical approach in a three state opinion model with continuous internal variable
- Monte Carlo Study of Agent-Based Blume-Capel Model for Political Depolarization
- Modified Axelrod Model Showing Opinion Convergence And Polarization In Realistic Scale-Free Networks