The Effect of Nonstationarity on Models Inferred from Neural Data

Abstract

Neurons subject to a common non-stationary input may exhibit a correlated firing behavior. Correlations in the statistics of neural spike trains also arise as the effect of interaction between neurons. Here we show that these two situations can be distinguished, with machine learning techniques, provided the data are rich enough. In order to do this, we study the problem of inferring a kinetic Ising model, stationary or nonstationary, from the available data. We apply the inference procedure to two data sets: one from salamander retinal ganglion cells and the other from a realistic computational cortical network model. We show that many aspects of the concerted activity of the salamander retinal neurons can be traced simply to the external input. A model of non-interacting neurons subject to a non-stationary external field outperforms a model with stationary input with couplings between neurons, even accounting for the differences in the number of model parameters. When couplings are added to the non-stationary model, for the retinal data, little is gained: the inferred couplings are generally not significant. Likewise, the distribution of the sizes of sets of neurons that spike simultaneously and the frequency of spike patterns as function of their rank (Zipf plots) are well-explained by an independent-neuron model with time-dependent external input, and adding connections to such a model does not offer significant improvement. For the cortical model data, robust couplings, well correlated with the real connections, can be inferred using the non-stationary model. Adding connections to this model slightly improves the agreement with the data for the probability of synchronous spikes but hardly affects the Zipf plot.

version in press in J Stat Mech

References in corpus (7)

• Identification of direct residue contacts in protein-protein interaction by message passing
• Are biological systems poised at criticality?
• The Ising Model for Neural Data: Model Quality and Approximate Methods for Extracting Functional Connectivity
• Mean Field Theory For Non-Equilibrium Network Reconstruction
• Dynamical TAP equations for non-equilibrium Ising spin glasses
• Network inference using asynchronously updated kinetic Ising Model
• Effect of coupling asymmetry on mean-field solutions of direct and inverse Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Colloquium: Criticality and dynamical scaling in living systems
• Inverse statistical problems: from the inverse Ising problem to data science
• Zipf's law and criticality in multivariate data without fine-tuning
• Scalability of asynchronous networks is limited by one-to-one mapping between effective connectivity and correlations
• Signatures of criticality arise in simple neural population models with correlations
• Maximum likelihood reconstruction for Ising models with asynchronous updates
• A unifying framework for mean-field theories of asymmetric kinetic Ising systems
• Approximate Inference for Time-varying Interactions and Macroscopic Dynamics of Neural Populations
• Inverse Ising problem in continuous time: A latent variable approach
• Lattice physics approaches for neural networks
• Simulations Approaching Data: Cortical Slow Waves in Inferred Models of the Whole Hemisphere of Mouse
• Dynamics and spike trains statistics in conductance-based Integrate-and-Fire neural networks with chemical and electric synapses
• Ensemble Inhibition and Excitation in the Human Cortex: an Ising Model Analysis with Uncertainties
• Dynamics of asymmetric kinetic Ising systems revisited
• Regularization and decimation pseudolikelihood approaches to statistical inference in $XY$-spin models
• Financial interaction networks inferred from traded volumes
• Improved Pseudolikelihood Regularization and Decimation methods on Non-linearly Interacting Systems with Continuous Variables
• Inference of stochastic time series with missing data
• Optimal encoding in stochastic latent-variable Models
• A Density Consistency approach to the inverse Ising problem
• Inference in neural networks using conditional mean-field methods
• Exponential Reduction in Sample Complexity with Learning of Ising Model Dynamics
• Objective and efficient inference for couplings in neuronal networks
• Statistical Patterns in the Equations of Physics and the Emergence of a Meta-Law of Nature
• Universal emergence of local Zipf-Mandelbrot law
• Biologically Plausible Sequence Learning with Spiking Neural Networks