The Curious Conundrum Regarding Sulfur Abundances In Planetary Nebulae
arXiv:1202.1563 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/749/1/61
Abstract
Sulfur abundances derived from optical emission line measurements and ionization correction factors in planetary nebulae are systematically lower than expected for the objects' metallicities. We have carefully considered a large range of explanations for this "sulfur anomaly", including: (1) correlations between the size of the sulfur deficit and numerous nebular and central star properties; (2) ionization correction factors which under-correct for unobserved ions; (3) effects of dielectronic recombination on the sulfur ionization balance; (4) sequestering of S into dust and/or molecules; and (5) excessive destruction of S or production of O by AGB stars. It appears that all but the second scenario can be ruled out. However, we find evidence that the sulfur deficit is generally reduced but not eliminated when S^+3 abundances determined directly from IR measurements are used in place of the customary sulfur ionization correction factor. We tentatively conclude that the sulfur anomaly is caused by the inability of commonly used ICFs to properly correct for populations of ionization stages higher than S^+2.
arXiv comment40 pages, 14 figures, 3 tables. Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal
References in corpus (30)
- The chemical composition of the Sun
- Updated stellar yields from Asymptotic Giant Branch models
- Heavy element abundances in blue compact galaxies
- Evolution, nucleosynthesis and yields of low mass AGB stars
- Nucleosynthesis and mixing on the Asymptotic Giant Branch. III. Predicted and observed s-process abundances
- The Composition Gradient in M101 Revisited. II. Electron Temperatures and Implications for the Nebular Abundance Scale
- The Element Abundances in Bare Planetary Nebula Central Stars and the Shell Burning in AGB Stars
- A reappraisal of the chemical composition of the Orion nebula based on VLT echelle spectrophotometry
- s-Process Nucleosynthesis in AGB Stars: A Test for Stellar Evolution
- Parameterising the third dredge-up in asymptotic giant branch stars
- Nucleosynthesis of light elements inside thermally pulsing AGB stars I: the case of intermediate-mass stars
- Sulfur, Chlorine, and Argon Abundances in Planetary Nebulae. IV: Synthesis and the Sulfur Anomaly
- Evolution on the AGB and beyond: On the formation of H-deficient post-AGB stars
- The carrier of the "30" micron emission feature in evolved stars. A simple model using magnesium sulfide
- Abundances of Galactic Anticenter Planetary Nebulae and the Oxygen Abundance Gradient in the Galactic Disk
- Nucleosynthesis Predictions for Intermediate-Mass AGB Stars: Comparison to Observations of Type I Planetary Nebulae
- Low mass AGB stellar models for 0.003 < Z < 0.02: basic formulae for nucleosynthesis calculations
- Sulfur, Chlorine, & Argon Abundances in Planetary Nebulae. I: Observations and Abundances in a Northern Sample
- Is Extra Mixing Really Needed in Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars?
- Planetary nebulae abundances and stellar evolution
- Knots in the Helix Nebula found in H2
- Alpha Element Abundances in a Large Sample of Galactic Planetary Nebulae
- Planetary nebulae abundances and stellar evolution II
- Neon and Sulfur Abundances of Planetary Nebulae in the Magellanic Clouds
- Spectra of globular clusters in the Sombrero galaxy: evidence for spectroscopic metallicity bimodality
- A Detailed Look at Chemical Abundances in Magellanic Cloud Planetary Nebulae. I. The Small Magellanic Cloud
- A temporal study of oxygen-rich pulsating variable AGB star, T Cep: Investigation on dust formation and dust properties
- A Multiwavelength Analysis of the Halo Planetary Nebula DdDm-1
- When Shape Matters: correcting the ICFs to derive the chemical abundances of bipolar and elliptical PNe
- Reduce, Reuse, Recycle: Planetary Nebulae as Green Galactic Citizens
Cited by in corpus (30)
- The Dawes Review 2: Nucleosynthesis and stellar yields of low and intermediate-mass single stars
- Ionization Correction Factors for Planetary Nebulae: I- Using optical spectra
- Planetary Nebulae: Sources of Enlightenment
- Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. II. Chemical abundances and the abundance discrepancy factor
- Planetary nebulae and HII regions in the spiral galaxy NGC 300. Clues on the evolution of abundance gradients and on AGB nucleosynthesis
- Chemical abundances in Galactic planetary nebulae with Spitzer spectra
- The Abundances of Light Neutron-Capture Elements in Planetary Nebulae III. The Impact of New Atomic Data on Nebular Selenium and Krypton Abundance Determinations
- The Herschel Planetary Nebula Survey (HerPlaNS) - a comprehensive dusty photoionization model of NGC6781
- Is the Sulphur Anomaly in Planetary Nebulae Caused by the s-Process?
- C/O ratios in planetary nebulae with dual-dust chemistry from faint optical recombination lines
- Chemical Abundances of Planetary Nebulae in the Substructures of M31
- The chemistry of planetary nebulae in the outer regions of M31
- Planetary Nebulae in the Small Magellanic Cloud
- Bootstrapping dielectronic recombination from second-row elements and the Orion Nebula
- Dielectronic recombination data for dynamic finite-density plasmas XV. The silicon isoelectronic sequence
- Chemical Abundances of Planetary Nebulae in the Substructures of M31 -- II. The Extended Sample and A Comparison Study with the Outer-disk Group
- Co-spatial Long-slit UV/Optical Spectra of Ten Galactic Planetary Nebulae with HST/STIS II. Nebular Models, Central Star Properties and He+CNO Synthesis
- Integral field spectroscopy of M1-67. A Wolf-Rayet nebula with LBVN appearance
- On the most luminous planetary nebulae of M31
- Neon, sulphur and argon abundances of planetary nebulae in the sub-solar metallicity Galactic anti-centre
- The population of planetary nebulae near the Galactic centre: chemical abundances
- Chemical Abundances in the PN Wray16-423 in the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy: Constraining the Dust Composition
- Charting Circumstellar Chemistry of Carbon-rich AGB Stars: I. ALMA 3 mm spectral surveys
- Physical and chemical properties of Wolf-Rayet planetary nebulae
- Bi-abundance ionization structure of the Wolf-Rayet planetary nebula PB 8
- Radio Planetary Nebulae in the Small Magellanic Cloud
- Recombination of hot ionized nebulae: The old planetary nebula around V4334 Sgr (Sakurai's star)
- Physical Conditions and Chemical Abundances of the Variable Planetary Nebula IC 4997
- Gaseous abundances in planetary nebulae: What have we learned in the past five years?
- Chemical Abundances of Eight Highly Extincted Milky Way Planetary Nebulae