Inferring the magnetic field vector in the quiet Sun. I. Photon noise and Selection Criteria
arXiv:1011.4380 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201015634
Abstract
In the past, spectropolarimetric data from Hinode/SP has been employed to infer the distribution of the magnetic field vector in the quiet Sun. While some authors have found predominantly horizontal magnetic fields, others favor an isotropic distribution. In this paper, we investigate whether it is actually possible to accurately retrieve the magnetic field vector in regions with very low polarization signals (e.g: internetwork), employing the \ion{Fe}{I} line pair at 6300 Å. We first perform inversions of the Stokes vector observed with Hinode/SP in the quiet Sun at disk center in order to confirm the distributions retrieved by other authors. We then carry out several Monte-Carlo simulations with synthetic data where we show that the observed distribution of the magnetic field vector can be explained in terms of purely vertical () and weak fields ( G), that are misinterpreted by the analysis technique (Stokes inversion code) as being horizontal () and stronger ( G), due to the effect of the photon noise. This casts doubts as to whether previous results, presenting the distributions for the magnetic field vector peaking at and G, are actually correct. We propose that an accurate determination of the magnetic field vector can be achieved by decreasing the photon noise to a point where most of the observed profiles posses Stokes or profiles that are above the noise level. Unfortunately, for noise levels as low as only 30% of the observed region with Hinode/SP have strong enough or signals, implying that the magnetic field vector remains unknown in the rest of the internetwork.
arXiv comment10 pages, 11 figures (5 color), accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics
References in corpus (20)
- The Solar Optical Telescope for the Hinode Mission: An Overview
- A Substantial Amount of Hidden Magnetic Energy in the Quiet Sun
- Emergence of Small-Scale Magnetic Loops in the Quiet Sun Internetwork
- Quiet Sun internetwork magnetic fields from the inversion of Hinode measurements
- Emergence of small-scale magnetic loops through the quiet solar atmosphere
- The intensity contrast of solar granulation: comparing Hinode SP results with MHD simulations
- Origin of the torsional oscillation pattern of solar rotation
- Transverse component of the magnetic field in the solar photosphere observed by Sunrise
- Evidence for Quasi-isotropic Magnetic Fields from Hinode Quiet Sun Observations
- Strategy for the inversion of Hinode spectropolarimetric measurements in the quiet Sun
- Quiet Sun magnetic fields from simultaneous inversions of visible and infrared spectropolarimetric observations
- Near-IR internetwork spectro-polarimetry at different heliocentric angles
- Statistics of convective collapse events in the photosphere and chromosphere observed with the Hinode SOT
- Concerning the existence of a 'turbulent' magnetic field in the quiet Sun
- Supersonic Magnetic Upflows in Granular Cells Observed with Sunrise/IMaX
- Shocks in the Quiet Solar Photosphere: A Rather Common Occurrence
- Detection of supersonic horizontal flows in the solar granulation
- On the Sr I 4607 A Hanle depolarization signals in the quiet Sun
- Milne-Eddington inversion of the Fe I line pair at 630~nm
- Statistical analysis of the very quiet Sun magnetism
Cited by in corpus (47)
- The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: SHARPs -- Space-weather HMI Active Region Patches
- The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: Overview and Performance
- Inversion of the radiative transfer equation for polarized light
- Quiet Sun magnetic fields observed by Hinode: Support for a local dynamo
- The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: Optimization of the Spectral Line Inversion Code
- Waves in the lower solar atmosphere: the dawn of next-generation solar telescopes
- Analysis of Quiet-Sun Internetwork Magnetic Fields Based on Linear Polarization Signals
- The formation of sunspot penumbra. I. Magnetic field properties
- Solar magnetoconvection and small-scale dynamo: Recent developments in observation and simulation
- The continuum intensity as a function of magnetic field I. Active region and quiet Sun magnetic elements
- Internetwork magnetic field as revealed by 2D inversions
- Magnetic field strength distribution of magnetic bright points inferred from filtergrams and spectro-polarimetric data
- Inferring the magnetic field vector in the quiet Sun. II. Interpreting results from the inversion of Stokes profiles
- The Role of Partial Ionization Effects in the Chromosphere
- Small-scale dynamos: From idealized models to solar and stellar applications
- The formation and disintegration of magnetic bright points observed by Sunrise/IMaX
- Inclinations of small quiet-Sun magnetic features based on a new geometric approach
- Probing deep photospheric layers of the quiet Sun with high magnetic sensitivity
- Pervasive Linear Polarization Signals in the Quiet Sun
- Solar surface and atmospheric dynamics: The Photosphere
- Magneto-static modelling from SUNRISE/IMaX: Application to an active region observed with SUNRISE II
- Magneto-static modelling of the mixed plasma Beta solar atmosphere based on SUNRISE/IMaX data
- Modelling and Interpreting The Effects of Spatial Resolution on Solar Magnetic Field Maps
- A Statistical Comparison between Photospheric Vector Magnetograms Obtained by SDO/HMI and Hinode/SP
- Is magnetic reconnection the cause of supersonic upflows in granular cells ?
- Inferring the magnetic field vector in the quiet Sun. III. Disk variation of the Stokes profiles and isotropism of the magnetic field
- Prospects of solar magnetometry - from ground and in space
- Hierarchical analysis of the quiet Sun magnetism
- Magnetic fields inferred by Solar Orbiter: A comparison between SO/PHI-HRT and SDO/HMI
- Accuracy analysis of the on-board data reduction pipeline for the Polarimetric and Helioseismic Imager on the Solar Orbiter mission
- High speed magnetized flows in the quiet Sun
- Temporal evolution of small-scale internetwork magnetic fields in the solar photosphere
- IBIS-A: The IBIS data Archive. High resolution observations of the solar photosphere and chromosphere with contextual data
- On the Magnetic Nature of an Exploding Granule as Revealed by Sunrise/IMaX
- Linear Polarization Features in the Quiet-Sun Photosphere: Structure and Dynamics
- Limitations and biases in the retrieval of the polar magnetic field I: the role of the magnetic filling factor in Milne-Eddington inversions of simulated Hinode/SP data
- Constraining the magnetic vector in the quiet solar photosphere and the impact of instrumental degradation
- Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profiles inversions. III. Uncertainty in the inference of electric currents
- Magnetized supersonic downflows in the chromosphere. A statistical study using the He I 10830 Å lines
- Markov properties of the magnetic field in the quiet solar photosphere
- A study of the capabilities for inferring atmospheric information from high-spatial-resolution simulations
- The polarization signature of photospheric magnetic fields in 3D MHD simulations and observations at disk center
- On the asymmetry of velocity oscillation amplitude in bipolar active regions
- Exploring magnetic loops and serpentine fields in the quiet Sun with the GRIS-IFU
- An iterative OLA method for inversion of solar spectropolarimetric data: I. Single and multiple variable inversions of thermodynamic quantities
- A stray light analysis for SO/PHI-HRT and an updated comparison of the inferred magnetic field with SDO/HMI
- Spectropolarimetric diagnostics of the lower solar atmosphere: a review of inversion techniques