A possible signature of terrestrial planet formation in the chemical composition of solar analogs

Abstract

Recent studies have shown that the elemental abundances in the Sun are anomalous when compared to most (about 85%) nearby solar twin stars. Compared to its twins, the Sun exhibits a deficiency of refractory elements (those with condensation temperatures Tc>900K) relative to volatiles (Tc<900K). This finding is speculated to be a signature of the planet formation that occurred more efficiently around the Sun compared with the majority of solar twins. Furthermore, within this scenario, it seems more likely that the abundance patterns found are specifically related to the formation of terrestrial planets. In this work we analyze abundance results from six large independent stellar abundance surveys to determine whether they confirm or reject this observational finding. We show that the elemental abundances derived for solar analogs in these six studies are consistent with the Tc trend suggested as a planet formation signature. The same conclusion is reached when those results are averaged heterogeneously. We also investigate the dependency of the abundances with first ionization potential (FIP), which correlates well with Tc. A trend with FIP would suggest a different origin for the abundance patterns found, but we show that the correlation with Tc is statistically more significant. We encourage similar investigations of metal-rich solar analogs and late F-type dwarf stars, for which the hypothesis of a planet formation signature in the elemental abundances makes very specific predictions. Finally, we examine a recent paper that claims that the abundance patterns of two stars hosting super-Earth like planets contradict the planet formation signature hypothesis. Instead, we find that the chemical compositions of these two stars are fully compatible with our hypothesis.

To appear in Astronomy and Astrophysics

References in corpus (11)

• alpha-, r-, and s-process element trends in the Galactic thin and thick disks
• Spectroscopic parameters for 451 stars in the HARPS GTO planet search program. Stellar [Fe/H] and the frequency of exo-Neptunes
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars. III. Spectroscopic stellar parameters
• Oxygen Abundances in Nearby Stars. Clues to the formation and evolution of the Galactic disk
• Chemical abundances of 451 stars from the HARPS GTO planet search program: Thin disc, thick disc, and planets
• Evolved stars hint to an external origin of enhanced metallicity in planet-hosting stars
• Lithium depletion in solar-like stars: no planet connection
• Searching for the signatures of terrestial planets in solar analogs
• Disentangling the Hercules stream
• Parent Stars of Extrasolar Planets. IX. Lithium Abundances
• The Galactic Stellar Disc

Cited by in corpus (72)

• Exploring the Milky Way stellar disk. A detailed elemental abundance study of 714 F and G dwarf stars in the Solar neighbourhood
• The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision
• SWEET-Cat: A catalogue of parameters for Stars With ExoplanETs I. New atmospheric parameters and masses for 48 stars with planets
• Oxygen Abundances in Nearby FGK Stars and the Galactic Chemical Evolution of the Local Disk and Halo
• The Solar Twin Planet Search. I. Fundamental parameters of the stellar sample
• The remarkable solar twin HIP 56948: a prime target in the quest for other Earths
• The Chemical Homogeneity of Sun-like Stars in the Solar Neighborhood
• Elemental abundance differences in the 16 Cygni binary system: a signature of gas giant planet formation?
• Searching for the signatures of terrestrial planets in F-, G-type main-sequence stars
• 18 Sco: a solar twin rich in refractory and neutron-capture elements. Implications for chemical tagging
• Accurate and homogeneous abundance patterns in solar-type stars of the solar neighbourhood: a chemo-chronological analysis
• The dissimilar chemical composition of the planet-hosting stars of the XO-2 binary system
• High Precision Abundances of the Old Solar Twin HIP 102152: Insights on Li Depletion from the Oldest Sun
• Abundances of Stars with Planets: Trends with Condensation Temperature
• Detailed Abundances of the Solar Twins 16 Cygni A and B: Constraining Planet Formation Models
• Silicon and Oxygen Abundances in Planet-Host Stars
• The Hyades open cluster is chemically inhomogeneous
• High Precision Differential Abundance Measurements in Globular Clusters: Chemical Inhomogeneities in NGC 6752
• The metallicity signature of evolved stars with planets
• A high precision chemical abundance analysis of the HAT-P-1 stellar binary: constraints on planet formation
• Homogeneous abundance analysis of dwarf, subgiant and giant FGK stars with and without giant planets
• Two Extrasolar Asteroids with Low Volatile-Element Mass Fractions
• Chemical signatures of planets: beyond solar-twins
• The Curious Case of Elemental Abundance Differences in the Dual Hot Jupiter Hosts WASP-94AB
• Planet signatures and effect of the chemical evolution of the Galactic thin-disk stars
• Abundance Differences Between Exoplanet Binary Host Stars XO-2N and XO-2S -- Dependence on Stellar Parameters
• Chemical (in)homogeneity and atomic diffusion in the open cluster M67
• Searching for signatures of planet formation in stars with circumstellar debris discs
• What are little worlds made of? Stellar abundances and the building blocks of planets
• The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG. X. Differential abundances in the XO-2 planet hosting binary
• Evolved stars and the origin of abundance trends in planet hosts
• The Galactic evolution of phosphorus
• A giant planet in the triple system HD132563
• Detailed Abundances of Stars with Small Planets Discovered by Kepler I: The First Sample
• The Volatility Trend of Protosolar and Terrestrial Elemental Abundances
• The chemical composition of HIP34407/HIP34426 and other twin-star comoving pairs
• Search for giant planets in M67 IV: survey results
• Elemental Abundances of Kepler Objects of Interest in APOGEE. I. Two Distinct Orbital Period Regimes Inferred from Host Star Iron Abundances
• The GAPS programme with HARPS-N@TNG IV: A planetary system around XO-2S
• Towards precise ages for single stars in the field. Gyrochronology constraints at several Gyr using wide binaries. I. Ages for initial sample
• Detailed chemical compositions of planet hosting stars: I. Exploration of possible planet signatures
• Revisiting the 16 Cygni planet host at unprecedented precision and exploring automated tools for precise abundances
• Distant Relatives: The Chemical Homogeneity of Comoving Pairs Identified in Gaia
• A temperature condensation trend in the debris-disk binary system Zet2 Ret
• Detailed chemical compositions of the wide binary HD 80606/80607: revised stellar properties and constraints on planet formation
• uvby-$\beta$ photometry of solar twins: the solar colors, model atmospheres, and the Teff and metallicity scales
• HD 80606: Searching the chemical signature of planet formation
• Exploring the link between star and planet formation with Ariel
• Detailed elemental abundances of binary stars: Searching for signatures of planet formation and atomic diffusion
• Parent Stars of Extrasolar Planets. XII. Additional evidence for trends with vsini, condensation temperature, and chromospheric activity
• The chemical composition of $\alpha$ Cen AB revisited
• High-precision analysis of binary stars with planets. I. Searching for condensation temperature trends in the HD 106515 system
• Carbon, isotopic ratio ${}^{12}$C/${}^{13}$C and nitrogen in solar twins: constraints for the chemical evolution of the local disc
• The detailed chemical composition of the terrestrial planet host Kepler-10
• Modelling the solar twin 18 Sco
• CHEMOUT: CHEMical complexity in star-forming regions of the OUTer Galaxy. I. Organic molecules and tracers of star-formation activity
• Statistics of the Chemical Composition of Solar Analog Stars and Links to Planet Formation
• Solar System Moons as Analogs for Compact Exoplanetary Systems
• HD 38858: a solar type star with a $\sim$10.8 yr activity cycle. Searching for Balmer and metallic line variations
• HIP 10725: The First Solar Twin/Analogue Field Blue Straggler
• The AMBRE Project: searching for the closest solar siblings
• Using non-solar-scaled opacities to derive stellar parameters. Toward high-precision parameters and abundances
• Searching for Solar Siblings in APOGEE and $Gaia$ DR2 with N-body Simulations
• CHEMOUT: CHEMical complexity in star-forming regions of the OUTer Galaxy. II. Methanol formation at low metallicity
• Implications of the spectroscopic abundances in α Centauri A and B
• Sun-like stars unlike the Sun: Clues for chemical anomalies of cool stars
• Assessing the processes behind planet engulfment and its imprints
• Characterization of Exoplanet-Host Stars
• Gemini-GRACES high-quality spectra of Kepler evolved stars with transiting planets I. Detailed characterization of multi-planet systems Kepler-278 and Kepler-391
• The Origin of the Metal-Poor Common Proper Motion Pair HD 134439/134440: Insights from New Elemental Abundances
• CHEMOUT: CHEMical complexity in star-forming regions of the OUTer Galaxy. V. Chemical composition gradients as a function of the galactocentric radius
• Survey for Distant Solar Twins (SDST) -- II. Design, observations and data