On the use of structure functions to study blazar variability: caveats and problems

Abstract

The extensive use of the structure function (SF) in the field of blazar variability suggests that characteristics time-scales are embedded in the light curves of these objects. We argue that for blazar variability studies, the SF results are sometimes erroneously interpreted leading to misconceptions about the actual source properties. Based on extensive simulations we caution that spurious breaks will appear in the SFs of almost all light curves, even though these light curves may contain no intrinsic characteristic time-scales. i.e. having a featureless underlying power-spectral-density (PSD). We show that the time-scales of the spurious SF-breaks depend mainly on the length of the artificial data set and also on the character of the variability i.e. the shape of the PSD. The SF is often invoked in the framework of shot-noise models to determine the temporal properties of individual shots. We caution that although the SF may be fitted to infer the shot parameters, the resultant shot-noise model is usually inconsistent with the observed PSD. As any model should fit the data in both the time and the frequency domain the shot-noise model, in these particular cases, can not be valid. Moreover, we show that the lack of statistical independence between adjacent SF points, in the standard SF formulation, means that it is not possible to perform robust statistical model fitting following the commonly used least-squares fitting methodology. The latter yields uncertainties in the fitting parameters (i.e. slopes, breaks) that are far too small with respect to their true statistical scatter. Finally, it is also commonly thought that SFs are immune to the sampling problems, such as data gaps, which affects the estimators of the PSDs. However we show that SFs are also troubled by gaps which can induce artefacts.

Accepted for publication in MNRAS, 18 pages, 14 figures

References in corpus (3)

• Discovery of multiple Lorentzian components in the X-ray timing properties of the Narrow Line Seyfert 1 Ark 564
• Testing the inverse-Compton catastrophe scenario in the intra-day variable blazar S5 0716+71, III. Rapid and correlated flux density variability from radio to sub-mm bands
• Testing the inverse-Compton catastrophe scenario in the intra-day variable blazar S5 0716+71: II. A search for intra-day variability at millimetre wavelengths with the IRAM 30 m telescope

Cited by in corpus (113)

• Modeling the Time Variability of SDSS Stripe 82 Quasars as a Damped Random Walk
• X-ray reverberation around accreting black holes
• Gamma-ray Light Curves and Variability of Bright Fermi-Detected Blazars
• Generating artificial light curves: Revisited and updated
• Flexible and Scalable Methods for Quantifying Stochastic Variability in the Era of Massive Time-Domain Astronomical Data Sets
• A method for the estimation of the significance of cross-correlations in unevenly sampled red-noise time series
• A Stochastic Model for the Luminosity Fluctuations of Accreting Black Holes
• Are the Variability Properties of the Kepler AGN Light Curves Consistent with a Damped Random Walk?
• Revisiting Stochastic Variability of AGNs with Structure Functions
• An Optical View of BL Lacertae Objects
• Long-term optical monitoring of TeV emitting Blazars
• Stochastic modelling of star-formation histories II: star-formation variability from molecular clouds and gas inflow
• The broad emission-line region: the confluence of the outer accretion disc with the inner edge of the dusty torus
• Optical variability of AGN in the PTF/iPTF survey
• Variability Timescale and Spectral Index of Sgr A* in the Near Infrared: Approximate Bayesian Computation Analysis of the Variability of the Closest Supermassive Black Hole
• Source-intrinsic near-infrared properties of Sgr A*: Total intensity measurements
• Millimeter light curves of Sagittarius A* observed during the 2017 Event Horizon Telescope campaign
• Stochastic modeling of star-formation histories I: the scatter of the star-forming main sequence
• Quasi-Periodic Oscillations of ~ 15 minutes in the Optical Light Curve of the BL Lac S5 0716+714
• Observational signatures of disk and jet misalignment in images of accreting black holes
• An 8 hour characteristic time-scale in submillimetre light curves of Sagittarius A*
• ALMA Polarimetry of Sgr A*: Probing the Accretion Flow from the Event Horizon to the Bondi Radius
• Optical Flux and Spectral Variability of Blazars
• A novel variability-based method for quasar selection: evidence for a rest frame ~54 day characteristic timescale
• Mrk 421 as a case study for TeV and X-ray variability in leptohadronic models
• The Unanticipated Phenomenology of the Blazar PKS~2131$-$021: A Unique Super-Massive Black Hole Binary Candidate
• A Mexican Hat with holes: calculating low resolution power spectra from data with gaps
• Corona-Heated Accretion-disk Reprocessing (CHAR): A Physical Model to Decipher the Melody of AGN UV/optical Twinkling
• AGN Variability Analysis Handbook
• Active Galactic Nuclei under the scrutiny of CTA
• Long-term X-ray variability of Swift J1644+57
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Reverberation Mapping Project: Ensemble Spectroscopic Variability of Quasar Broad Emission Lines
• Extracting Information from AGN Variability
• Multiwavelength Variability of the Blazars Mrk 421 and 3C 454.3 in the High-State
• Ensemble X-ray variability of Active Galactic Nuclei from serendipitous source catalogues
• The dual nature of blazar fast variability. Space and ground observations of S5 0716+714
• Characterizing the gamma-ray long-term variability of PKS 2155-304 with H.E.S.S. and Fermi-LAT
• Near Infrared Variability of obscured and unobscured X-ray selected AGN in the COSMOS field
• How far is quasar UV/optical variability from damped random walk at low frequency?
• Characteristic Variability Timescales in the Gamma-ray Power Spectra of Blazars
• Multi-band optical variability of the Blazar S5 0716+714 in outburst state during 2014-2015
• Optical Intraday Variability Studies of Ten Low Energy Peaked Blazars
• Long-term variability of T Tauri stars using WASP
• MAXI investigation into the longterm X-ray variability from the very-high-energy gamma-ray blazar Mrk 421
• Long-term optical variability of PKS 2155-304
• Spitzer/IRAC Observations of the Variability of Sgr A* and the Object G2 at 4.5 microns
• Statistics of X-ray flares of Sagittarius A*: evidence for solar-like self-organized criticality phenomenon
• Exploratory X-ray Monitoring of Luminous Radio-Quiet Quasars at High Redshift: Initial Results
• Random time series in Astronomy
• Exploring the nature of broadband variability in the FSRQ 3C 273
• Testing microvariability in quasar differential light curves using several field stars
• Variability of gamma-ray emission from blazars on the black hole timescales
• A structure function analysis of VST-COSMOS AGN
• Multi-band optical-NIR variability of blazars on diverse timescales
• Rapid Intrinsic Variability of Sgr A* at Radio Wavelengths
• Properties of AGN Multiband Optical Variability in the HSC SSP Transient Survey
• Time Variations in the Flux Density of Sgr A* at 230 GHz Detected with ALMA
• Spitzer Observations of Long Term Infrared Variability Among Young Stellar Objects in Chamaeleon I
• Evolution of quasar stochastic variability along its main sequence
• A forward modelling approach to AGN variability -- Method description and early applications
• Characterising the i-band variability of YSOs over six orders of magnitude in timescale
• Second Scale Submillimeter Variability of Sagittarius A* during flaring activity of 2019: On the Origin of Bright Near Infrared Flares
• Simulated Performance of Timescale Metrics for Aperiodic Light Curves
• Intraday Optical Variability of BL Lacertae
• Modeling Quasar UV/Optical Variability with the Corona-heated Accretion-disk Reprocessing (CHAR) Model
• A Method to Measure the Unbiased Decorrelation Timescale of the AGN Variable Signal from Structure Functions
• CHILES VERDES: Radio variability at an unprecedented depth and cadence in the COSMOS field
• The long-term centimeter variability of active galactic nuclei: A new relation between variability timescale and accretion rate
• The Variability and Period Analysis for the BL Lac AO 0235+164
• MOMO IV: The complete Swift X-ray and UV/optical light curve and characteristic variability of the blazar OJ 287 during the last two decades
• The First Hard X-Ray Power Spectral Density Functions of AGN
• ASGARD: A Large Survey for Slow Galactic Radio Transients. I. Overview and First Results
• Characterization of Variability in Blazar Light curves
• A Black Hole Mass-Variability Time Scale Correlation at Submillimeter Wavelengths
• LSST Cadence Strategy Evaluations for AGN Time-series Data in Wide-Fast-Deep Field
• Analyses on the Variability Asymmetry of Kepler AGNs
• Do the Kepler AGN Light Curves Need Re-processing?
• Ensemble power spectral density of SDSS quasars in UV/optical bands
• Constraining AGN Torus Sizes with Optical and Mid-Infrared Ensemble Structure Functions
• Spatial variations of turbulent properties of neutral hydrogen gas in the Small Magellanic Cloud using structure function analysis
• The variability of blazars throughout the electromagnetic spectrum
• Mid-infrared Variability of gamma-ray emitting blazars
• Continuum optical-UV and X-ray variability of AGN: current results and future challenges
• More than softer-when-brighter: the X-Ray powerlaw spectral variability in NGC 4051
• A new timescale-mass scaling for the optical variation of active galactic nuclei across the intermediate-mass to supermassive scales
• An Unobscured type II quasar candidate: SDSS J012032.19-005501.9
• Exploratory X-ray Monitoring of Luminous Radio-Quiet Quasars at High Redshift: No Evidence for Evolution in X-ray Variability
• New Clues to Jet Launching: The inner disks in radio loud quasars may be more stable
• Multiwavelength variability of the blazar AO 0235+164
• Analysis of the intra-night variability of BL Lacertae during its August 2020 flare
• Strong Lensed QSOs with Variability Detectable by LSST: How many are there?
• The mid-infrared variability of the SDSS optical quasars
• Possible evidence from the flaring activity of Sgr A* for a star at a distance of ~3.3 Schwarzscild radii from the blackhole
• Ensemble Variability Properties of Active Galactic Nuclei in the SDSS DR17
• Temperature Profiles of Accretion Disks in Luminous Active Galactic Nuclei derived from Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Variability
• Dust Reverberation Mapping and Light-Curve Modelling of Zw229-015
• Suborbital Fermi/LAT Analysis of the Brightest Gamma-Ray Flare of Blazar 3C 454.3
• Polarization Studies in Different Blazar Types. Part I: Correlation between Optical Brightness and Polarization Degree
• A new method for studying the blazar variability on the shortest time scales and its application to S5 1803+784
• Follow-up Observations for IceCube-170922A: Detection of Rapid Near-Infrared Variability and Intensive Monitoring of TXS 0506+056
• Time domain methods for X-ray and gamma-ray astronomy
• Not so Swift: 20 years of multiwavelength observations of Mrk 421 and Mrk 501
• Radio and Optical Properties of the blazar PKS 1614+051 at z=3.21
• Multiwavelength Variability Analysis of the Blazar PKS 0727-11: A $\sim$168 Days Quasi-periodic Oscillation in Gamma-ray
• Optical variability of eight FRII-type quasars with 13-yr photometric light curves
• The ensemble broad-frequency power spectrum of Stripe-82 quasars from multiple surveys
• Multi-wavelength variability analysis of the blazar S5 0716+714 during a long-lasting period of low activity
• De-Biasing Structure Function Estimates From Sparse Time Series of the Solar Wind: A Data-Driven Approach
• Flickers, Bursts, and Dips: Detecting Rapid Variability with the g(2) Autocorrelation Function
• Granulation on a quiet K dwarf: HD 166620 I. Spectral signatures as a function of line-formation temperature
• Direct power spectral density estimation from structure functions without Fourier transforms
• Optical Variability Structure Function of Low-Luminosity AGN using ATLAS Lightcurves
• Multi-wavelength Optical and NIR Variability Analysis of the Blazar PKS 0027-426