Systematic uncertainties on the cosmic-ray transport parameters: Is it possible to reconcile B/C data with delta = 1/3 or delta = 1/2?

Abstract

The B/C ratio is used in cosmic-ray physics to constrain the transport parameters. However, from the same set of data, the various published values show a puzzling large scatter of these parameters. We investigate the impact of using different inputs (gas density and hydrogen fraction in the Galactic disc, source spectral shape, low-energy dependence of the diffusion coefficient, and nuclear fragmentation cross-sections) on the best-fit values of the transport parameters. We quantify the systematics produced when varying these inputs, and compare them to statistical uncertainties. We discuss the consequences for the slope of the diffusion coefficient delta. The analysis relies on the propagation code USINE interfaced with the Minuit minimisation routines. We find the typical systematic uncertainties to be larger than the statistical ones. The several published values of delta (from 0.3 to 0.8) can be recovered when varying the low-energy shape of the diffusion coefficient and the convective wind strength. Models including a convective wind are characterised by delta > 0.6, which cannot be reconcile with the expected theoretical values (1/3 and 1/2). However, from a statistical point of view (chi^2 analysis), models with both reacceleration and convection-hence large delta-are favoured. The next favoured models in line yield delta that can be accommodated with 1/3 and 1/2, but require a strong upturn of the diffusion coefficient at low energy (and no convection). To date, using the best statistical tools, the transport parameter determination is still plagued by many unknowns at low energy (~ GeV/n). To disentangle between all these configurations, measurements of the B/C ratio at TeV/n energies and/or combination with other secondary-to-primary ratios is necessary.

12 pages, 7 figures, minor language corrections to match the A&A accepted version

References in corpus (6)

• Constraints on WIMP Dark Matter from the High Energy PAMELA $\bar{p}/p$ data
• Measurements of cosmic-ray secondary nuclei at high energies with the first flight of the CREAM balloon-borne experiment
• A Markov Chain Monte Carlo technique to sample transport and source parameters of Galactic cosmic rays: II. Results for the diffusion model combining B/C and radioactive nuclei
• Composition of Primary Cosmic-Ray Nuclei at High Energies
• A Markov Chain Monte Carlo for Galactic Cosmic Ray physics: I. Method and results for the Leaky Box Model
• Observations of the Li, Be, and B isotopes and constraints on cosmic-ray propagation

Cited by in corpus (64)

• Constraints on cosmic-ray propagation models from a global Bayesian analysis
• Cosmic-ray propagation with DRAGON2: I. numerical solver and astrophysical ingredients
• The origin of Galactic cosmic rays: challenges to the standard paradigm
• Diffusive propagation of cosmic rays from supernova remnants in the Galaxy. II: anisotropy
• Measurement of boron and carbon fluxes in cosmic rays with the PAMELA experiment
• Bayesian analysis of cosmic-ray propagation: evidence against homogeneous diffusion
• A Markov Chain Monte Carlo technique to sample transport and source parameters of Galactic cosmic rays: II. Results for the diffusion model combining B/C and radioactive nuclei
• Unified interpretation of cosmic-ray nuclei and antiproton recent measurements
• Antiprotons from dark matter annihilation in the Galaxy: astrophysical uncertainties
• Current status and desired accuracy of the isotopic production cross sections relevant to astrophysics of cosmic rays I. Li, Be, B, C, N
• AMS-02 data confronts acceleration of cosmic ray secondaries in nearby sources
• Indications for a high-rigidity break in the cosmic-ray diffusion coefficient
• Testing Physical Models for Cosmic Ray Transport Coefficients on Galactic Scales: Self-Confinement and Extrinsic Turbulence at GeV Energies
• Bayesian analysis of spatial-dependent cosmic-ray propagation: astrophysical background of antiprotons and positrons
• Imprints of Cosmic Rays in Multifrequency Observations of the Interstellar Emission
• Cosmic-ray transport from AMS-02 B/C data: benchmark models and interpretation
• Multimessenger constraints on the dark matter interpretation of the Fermi-LAT Galactic center excess
• A common solution to the cosmic ray anisotropy and gradient problems
• What Does The PAMELA Antiproton Spectrum Tell Us About Dark Matter?
• Cosmic-ray propagation with DRAGON2: II. Nuclear interactions with the interstellar gas
• AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded
• Constraining Galactic cosmic-ray parameters with Z<=2 nuclei
• Low energy cosmic ray positron fraction explained by charge-sign dependent solar modulation
• Galactic halo size in the light of recent AMS-02 data
• Combined analysis of AMS-02 (Li,Be,B)/C, N/O, 3He, and 4He data
• Theoretical uncertainties in extracting cosmic-ray diffusion parameters: the boron-to-carbon ratio
• Cosmic-ray Antinuclei as Messengers of New Physics: Status and Outlook for the New Decade
• Dark matter or correlated errors: Systematics of the AMS-02 antiproton excess
• First Predicted Cosmic Ray Spectra, Primary-to-Secondary Ratios, and Ionization Rates from MHD Galaxy Formation Simulations
• Fitting B/C cosmic-ray data in the AMS-02 era: A cookbook
• TeV cosmic-ray proton and helium spectra in the myriad model
• Implications of the Cosmic Ray Electron Spectrum and Anisotropy measured with Fermi-LAT
• Solar and nuclear physics uncertainties in cosmic-ray propagation
• Particle acceleration by supernova shocks and spallogenic nucleosynthesis of light elements
• CosRayMC: a global fitting method in studying the properties of the new sources of cosmic e${}^{\pm }$ excesses
• p, He, and C to Fe cosmic-ray primary fluxes in diffusion models: Source and transport signatures on fluxes and ratios
• Markov chain Monte Carlo analyses of the flux ratios of B, Be and Li with the DRAGON2 code
• Direct constraints on diffusion models from cosmic-ray positron data: Excluding the Minimal model for dark matter searches
• Secondary Cosmic Ray Nuclei from Supernova Remnants and Constraints to the Propagation Parameters
• Investigating the dark matter signal in the cosmic ray antiproton flux with the machine learning method
• Loops and spurs: The angular power spectrum of the Galactic synchrotron background
• A systematic study on the cosmic ray antiproton flux
• The impact of astrophysical dust grains on the confinement of cosmic rays
• A Genetic Algorithm for Astroparticle Physics Studies
• A simple determination of the halo size $L$ from ${}^{10}$Be/${}^9$Be data
• Antiproton Limits on Decaying Gravitino Dark Matter
• Diffuse Galactic Gamma Rays at intermediate and high latitudes. I. Constraints on the ISM properties
• The impact of propagation uncertainties on the potential Dark Matter contribution to the Fermi LAT mid-latitude gamma-ray data
• Recent results in nuclear astrophysics
• Cosmic-ray antiprotons in the AMS-02 era: A sensitive probe of dark matter
• Can the morphology of gamma-ray emission distinguish annihilating from decaying dark matter?
• The importance of Fe fragmentation for LiBeB analyses: Is a Li primary source needed to explain AMS-02 data?
• Cosmic Ray Anomalies from the MSSM?
• AMS-02 in space: physics results, overview, and challenges
• Recent extensions to GALPROP
• Extracting the size of the cosmic electron-positron anomaly
• Galactic Magnetic Turbulence from Radio data
• A tale of cosmic rays narrated in gamma rays by Fermi
• AMS-02 antiprotons and dark matter: Trimmed hints and robust bounds
• Transport parameters from AMS-02 F/Si data and fluorine source abundance
• Reanalysis of the Systematic Uncertainties in Cosmic-Ray Antiproton Flux
• Inelastic Scattering of Dark Matter with Heavy Cosmic Rays
• Origin of the high energy neutrino flux at IceCube
• AMS-02 in Space: Physics Results