Theoretical uncertainties in extracting cosmic-ray diffusion parameters: the boron-to-carbon ratio

Abstract

PAMELA and, more recently, AMS-02, are ushering us into a new era of greatly reduced statistical uncertainties in experimental measurements of cosmic-ray fluxes. In particular, new determinations of traditional diagnostic tools such as the boron-to-carbon ratio (B/C) are expected to significantly reduce errors on cosmic-ray diffusion parameters, with important implications for astroparticle physics, ranging from inferring primary source spectra to indirect dark matter searches. It is timely to stress, however, that the conclusions obtained crucially depend on the framework in which the data are interpreted as well as from some nuclear input parameters. We aim at assessing the theoretical uncertainties affecting the outcome, with models as simple as possible while still retaining the key dependencies. We compare different semi-analytical, two-zone model descriptions of cosmic-ray transport in the Galaxy. We test for the effect of a primary source contamination in the boron flux by parametrically altering its flux, as well as for nuclear cross section uncertainties. Our study on preliminary results from AMS-02 suggests that, differently for instance from the leptonic case, realistic modelling of the geometry of the Galaxy and of the source distribution are of minor importance to correctly reproduce B/C data at high energies and thus, to a large extent, for the extraction of diffusion parameters. The Ansatz on the lack of primary injection of boron represents the most serious bias, and requires multi-messenger studies to be addressed. If this uncertainty could be lifted, nuclear uncertainties would still represent a serious concern, which degrade the systematic error on the inferred parameters to the 20% level, or three times the estimated experimental sensitivity. In order to reduce this, a new nuclear cross section measurement campaign is probably required.

14 pages, 11 figures, 4 tables, published in A&A

References in corpus (5)

• The origin of the positron excess in cosmic rays
• High-energy antiprotons from old supernova remnants
• Testing astrophysical models for the PAMELA positron excess with cosmic ray nuclei
• AMS-02 data confronts acceleration of cosmic ray secondaries in nearby sources
• Galactic Cosmic Ray Nuclei as a Tool for Astroparticle Physics

Cited by in corpus (43)

• AMS-02 beryllium data and its implication for cosmic ray transport
• Scrutinizing the evidence for dark matter in cosmic-ray antiprotons
• Current status and desired accuracy of the isotopic production cross sections relevant to astrophysics of cosmic rays I. Li, Be, B, C, N
• Detection of a $\gamma$-ray halo around Geminga with the Fermi-LAT and implications for the positron flux
• Indications for a high-rigidity break in the cosmic-ray diffusion coefficient
• Imprints of Cosmic Rays in Multifrequency Observations of the Interstellar Emission
• Cosmic-ray transport from AMS-02 B/C data: benchmark models and interpretation
• Prospects to verify a possible dark matter hint in cosmic antiprotons with antideuterons and antihelium
• Cosmic-ray propagation with DRAGON2: II. Nuclear interactions with the interstellar gas
• AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded
• Combined analysis of AMS-02 (Li,Be,B)/C, N/O, 3He, and 4He data
• Contribution of pulsars to cosmic-ray positrons in light of recent observation of inverse-Compton halos
• Evidences of low-diffusion bubbles around Galactic pulsars
• Cosmic-ray Antinuclei as Messengers of New Physics: Status and Outlook for the New Decade
• Can we explain AMS-02 antiproton and positron excesses simultaneously by nearby supernovae without pulsars nor dark matter?
• Fitting B/C cosmic-ray data in the AMS-02 era: A cookbook
• Secondary antiprotons as a Galactic Dark Matter probe
• Solar and nuclear physics uncertainties in cosmic-ray propagation
• Dipole anisotropy in cosmic electrons and positrons: inspection on local sources
• Cosmic-ray positrons from millisecond pulsars
• The pinching method for Galactic cosmic ray positrons: implications in the light of precision measurements
• Updated Constraints on Primordial Black Hole Evaporation
• GW150914-like Black Holes as Galactic High-Energy Sources
• Turbulent diffusion of streaming cosmic rays in compressible, partially ionised plasma
• Multi-messenger constraints to the local emission of cosmic-ray electrons
• Late decaying 2-component dark matter scenario as an explanation of the AMS-02 positron excess
• Theoretical interpretation of Pass 8 Fermi-LAT $e^{+}+e^{-}$ data
• Novel interpretation of the latest AMS-02 cosmic-ray electron spectrum
• Cosmic Rays in a Galactic Breeze
• Cosmic-ray antiprotons in the AMS-02 era: A sensitive probe of dark matter
• Connecting the new H.E.S.S. diffuse emission at the Galactic center with the Fermi GeV excess: a combination of millisecond pulsars and heavy dark matter?
• Origin of the spectral upturn in the cosmic-ray C/Fe and O/Fe ratios
• The importance of Fe fragmentation for LiBeB analyses: Is a Li primary source needed to explain AMS-02 data?
• Status of Indirect (and Direct) Dark Matter searches
• Interaction between Molecular Clouds and MeV-TeV Cosmic-ray Protons Escaped from Supernova Remnants
• Contribution of the Galactic center to the local cosmic-ray flux
• Monte Carlo Study of Electron and Positron Cosmic-Ray Propagation with the CALET Spectrum
• Measuring the Mass of Missing Baryons in the Halo of Andromeda Galaxy with Gamma-Ray Observations
• Disclosing the catalog pulsars dominating the Galactic positron flux
• Galactic Centre as an efficient source of cosmic rays
• Transport parameters from AMS-02 F/Si data and fluorine source abundance
• Galactic Cosmic-Rays in a Breeze
• The Gamma-Ray Emission from the Supernova Remnant RX J1713.7-3946 Interacting with Two-phase Medium