Cosmological Measures without Volume Weighting
arXiv:0808.0351 · doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2008/10/025
Abstract
Many cosmologists (myself included) have advocated volume weighting for the cosmological measure problem, weighting spatial hypersurfaces by their volume. However, this often leads to the Boltzmann brain problem, that almost all observations would be by momentary Boltzmann brains that arise very briefly as quantum fluctuations in the late universe when it has expanded to a huge size, so that our observations (too ordered for Boltzmann brains) would be highly atypical and unlikely. Here it is suggested that volume weighting may be a mistake. Volume averaging is advocated as an alternative. One consequence may be a loss of the argument that eternal inflation gives a nonzero probability that our universe now has infinite volume.
15 pages, LaTeX, added references for constant-H hypersurfaces and also an idea for minimal-flux hypersurfaces
References in corpus (92)
- From the Big Bang Theory to the Theory of a Stationary Universe
- Inflationary Cosmology
- Predictions from Quantum Cosmology
- Eternal inflation and its implications
- Disturbing Implications of a Cosmological Constant
- Inflation and Eternal Inflation
- Pair Creation of Black Holes During Inflation
- Approaches to Quantum Cosmology
- What does inflation really predict?
- The Measure Problem in Cosmology
- Probabilities in the inflationary multiverse
- Can the universe afford inflation?
- Sinks in the Landscape, Boltzmann Brains, and the Cosmological Constant Problem
- Holographic probabilities in eternal inflation
- The Classical Universes of the No-Boundary Quantum State
- TASI Lectures on the Cosmological Constant
- A Measure of de Sitter Entropy and Eternal Inflation
- Fluctuations of the Gravitational Constant in the Inflationary Brans-Dicke Cosmology
- The No-Boundary Measure of the Universe
- Boltzmann brains and the scale-factor cutoff measure of the multiverse
- Predicting the Cosmological Constant from the Causal Entropic Principle
- Stationarity of Inflation and Predictions of Quantum Cosmology
- Eternal Inflation: The Inside Story
- Predicting the cosmological constant with the scale-factor cutoff measure
- Properties of the scale factor measure
- Is Our Universe Likely to Decay within 20 Billion Years?
- Do We Live in the Center of the World?
- A paradox in the global description of the multiverse
- Domain walls, near-BPS bubbles, and probabilities in the landscape
- Are We Typical?
- Open Inflation, the Four Form and the Cosmological Constant
- Making Predictions in Eternally Inflating Universe
- Predictability crisis in inflationary cosmology and its resolution
- Anthropic prediction for Lambda and the Q catastrophe
- Towards a gauge invariant volume-weighted probability measure for eternal inflation
- Multiverses and physical cosmology
- Unambiguous probabilities in an eternally inflating universe
- The Phase Transition to Eternal Inflation
- Hurdles for Recent Measures in Eternal Inflation
- A prescription for probabilities in eternal inflation
- Density Perturbations and the Cosmological Constant from Inflationary Landscapes
- Boltzmann babies in the proper time measure
- Prediction and explanation in the multiverse
- The wave function discord
- A global picture of quantum de Sitter space
- Counting Pockets with World Lines in Eternal Inflation
- Return of the Boltzmann Brains
- Multiple universes, cosmic coincidences, and other dark matters
- Freak observers and the measure of the multiverse
- A measure of the multiverse
- On Regularization Scheme Dependence of Predictions in Inflationary Cosmology
- Predictions in eternal inflation
- Probabilities in the landscape: The decay of nearly flat space
- (No) Eternal Inflation and Precision Higgs Physics
- Uncertainties of predictions in models of eternal inflation
- Landscape Predictions from Cosmological Vacuum Selection
- Geodesic measures of the landscape
- Is Our Universe Decaying at an Astronomical Rate?
- Sensible Quantum Mechanics: Are Probabilities only in the Mind?
- Susskind's Challenge to the Hartle-Hawking No-Boundary Proposal and Possible Resolutions
- Transient Observers and Variable Constants, or Repelling the Invasion of the Boltzmann's Brains
- Boltzmann Brains--I'd Rather See Than Be One
- Space for Both No-Boundary and Tunneling Quantum States of the Universe
- A volume-weighted measure for eternal inflation
- Multiverses and Cosmology: Philosophical Issues
- Volume Weighted Measures of Eternal Inflation in the Bousso-Polchinski Landscape
- Sensible Quantum Mechanics: Are Only Perceptions Probabilistic?
- A Stochastic Measure for Eternal Inflation
- In defence of the `Tunneling' wave function of the Universe
- Measures on transitions for cosmology from eternal inflation
- The scale of gravity and the cosmological constant within a landscape
- Entropy and initial conditions in cosmology
- Observational Selection Effects in Quantum Cosmology
- Global Prescribed Mean Curvature foliations in cosmological spacetimes with matter, Part I
- Local Prescribed Mean Curvature foliations in cosmological spacetimes
- Cosmological spacetimes not covered by a constant mean curvature slicing
- Black holes, information, and locality
- Insufficiency of the Quantum State for Deducing Observational Probabilities
- Volume Weighting in the No Boundary Proposal
- Reheating-volume measure for random-walk inflation
- Comment on `Quantum Creation of an Open Universe', by Andrei Linde
- Eternal inflation and the present universe
- Typicality Derived
- Global Prescribed Mean Curvature foliations in cosmological spacetimes with matter, Part II
- Typicality Defended
- Eternal inflation and chaotic terminology
- The Measure for the Multiverse and the Probability for Inflation
- No-Bang Quantum State of the Cosmos
- The quantum cosmology debate
- Typicality, Freak Observers and the Anthropic Principle of Existence
- On the foliation of space-time by constant mean curvature hypersurfaces
- One more observational consequence of many-worlds quantum theory
Cited by in corpus (29)
- Generation of fluctuations during inflation: comparison of stochastic and field-theoretic approaches
- Properties of the scale factor measure
- Law without law: from observer states to physics via algorithmic information theory
- The Born Rule Dies
- How unitary cosmology generalizes thermodynamics and solves the inflationary entropy problem
- Science in a Very Large Universe
- Global-Local Duality in Eternal Inflation
- Geometric origin of coincidences and hierarchies in the landscape
- Boundary definition of a multiverse measure
- Galaxy Formation Efficiency and the Multiverse Explanation of the Cosmological Constant with EAGLE Simulations
- A Finite Measure for the Initial Conditions of Inflation
- Consciousness and the Quantum
- Symmetric-Bounce Quantum State of the Universe
- Born's Rule Is Insufficient in a Large Universe
- Agnesi Weighting for the Measure Problem of Cosmology
- Testing typicality in multiverse cosmology
- Possibilities for Probabilities
- Spacetime Average Density (SAD) Cosmological Measures
- Possible Anthropic Support for a Decaying Universe: A Cosmic Doomsday Argument
- The Xerographic Distribution: Scientific Reasoning in a Large Universe
- Horizon Complementarity and Casimir Violations of the Null Energy Condition
- Rescuing the Born Rule for Quantum Cosmology
- Preliminary Inconclusive Hint of Evidence Against Optimal Fine Tuning of the Cosmological Constant for Maximizing the Fraction of Baryons Becoming Life
- Historical Parallels between, and Modal Realism underlying Einstein and Everett Relativities
- Do Our Observations Depend upon the Quantum State of the Universe?
- Many Worlds Model resolving the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox via a Direct Realism to Modal Realism Transition that preserves Einstein Locality
- Anthropic Estimates for Many Parameters of Physics and Astronomy
- Against Absolute Actualization: Three "Non-Localities" and Failure of Model-External Randomness made easy with Many-Worlds Models including Stronger Bell-Violation and Correct QM Probability
- Observers in an accelerated universe