Fundamental Limits to Position Determination by Concentration Gradients

Abstract

Position determination in biological systems is often achieved through protein concentration gradients. Measuring the local concentration of such a protein with a spatially-varying distribution allows the measurement of position within the system. In order for these systems to work effectively, position determination must be robust to noise. Here, we calculate fundamental limits to the precision of position determination by concentration gradients due to unavoidable biochemical noise perturbing the gradients. We focus on gradient proteins with first order reaction kinetics. Systems of this type have been experimentally characterised in both developmental and cell biology settings. For a single gradient we show that, through time-averaging, great precision can potentially be achieved even with very low protein copy numbers. As a second example, we investigate the ability of a system with oppositely directed gradients to find its centre. With this mechanism, positional precision close to the centre improves more slowly with increasing averaging time, and so longer averaging times or higher copy numbers are required for high precision. For both single and double gradients, we demonstrate the existence of optimal length scales for the gradients, where precision is maximized, as well as analyzing how precision depends on the size of the concentration measuring apparatus. Our results provide fundamental constraints on the positional precision supplied by concentration gradients in various contexts, including both in developmental biology and also within a single cell.

24 pages, 2 figures

References in corpus (9)

• Applications of Field-Theoretic Renormalization Group Methods to Reaction-Diffusion Problems
• Dynamic compartmentalization of bacteria: accurate division in E. coli
• Signal detection, modularity and the correlation between extrinsic and intrinsic noise in biochemical networks
• Cellular organization by self-organization : mechanisms and models for Min protein dynamics
• Embryonic Pattern Scaling Achieved by Oppositely Directed Morphogen Gradients
• Finding the center reliably: robust patterns of developmental gene expression
• A stochastic model of Min oscillations in Escherichia coli and Min protein segregation during cell division
• Morphogen Gradient from a Noisy Source
• Physical limits to biochemical signaling

Cited by in corpus (20)

• Information transmission in genetic regulatory networks: a review
• microRNAs may sharpen spatial expression patterns
• The role of spatial averaging in the precision of gene expression patterns
• Mutual Repression enhances the Steepness and Precision of Gene Expression Boundaries
• Morphogen Profiles Can Be Optimised to Buffer Against Noise
• Adaptive two-regime method: application to front propagation
• When it Pays to Rush: Interpreting Morphogen Gradients Prior to Steady-State
• Noise expands the response range of the Bacillus subtilis competence circuit
• Stability of localized wave fronts in bistable systems
• A Survey on Estimation Schemes in Molecular Communications
• Self-similar dynamics of morphogen gradients
• Aggregation-fragmentation model of robust concentration gradient formation
• Large number of receptors may reduce cellular response time variation
• Positional information readout in $C{a}^{2+}$ signaling
• Eventual self-similarity of solutions for the diffusion equation with nonlinear absorption and a point source
• Positional information trade-offs in boundary-driven reaction-diffusion systems
• Accuracy in readout of glutamate concentrations by neuronal cells
• Analysis of Brownian Dynamics Simulations of Reversible Bimolecular Reactions
• Physical limits on chemical sensing in bounded domains
• The pseudo-compartment method for coupling PDE and compartment-based models of diffusion