A case of mistaken identity? GRB 060912A and the nature of the long -- short GRB divide

Abstract

We investigate the origin of the GRB 060912A, which has observational properties that make its classification as either a long or short burst ambiguous. Short duration GRBs (SGRBs) are thought to have typically lower energies than long duration bursts, can be found in galaxies with populations of all ages and are likely to originate from different progenitors to the long duration bursts. However, it has become clear that duration alone is insufficient to make a distinction between the two populations in many cases, leading to a desire to find additional discriminators of burst type. GRB 060912A had a duration of 6 s and occurred only ~10 arcsec from a bright, low redshift ($z=0.0936$) elliptical galaxy, suggesting that this may have been the host, which would favour it being a short-burst. However, our deep optical imaging and spectroscopy of the location of GRB 060912A using the VLT shows that GRB 060912A more likely originates in a distant star forming galaxy at z=0.937, and is most likely a long burst. This demonstrates the risk in identifying bright, nearby galaxies as the hosts of given GRBs without further supporting evidence. Further, it implies that, in the absence of secure identifications, "host" type, or more broadly discriminators which rely on galaxy redshifts, may not be good indicators of the true nature of any given GRB.

9 pages, 5 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (10)

• Long gamma-ray bursts and core-collapse supernovae have different environments
• No supernovae associated with two long-duration gamma ray bursts
• An enigmatic long-lasting gamma-ray burst not accompanied by a bright supernova
• UV star-formation rates of GRB host galaxies
• Making a Short Gamma-Ray Burst from a Long one: Implications for the Nature of GRB 060614
• A Putative Early-Type Host Galaxy for GRB 060502B: Implications for the Progenitors of Short-Duration Hard-Spectrum Bursts
• Gamma-Ray Burst Selected High Redshift Galaxies: Comparison to Field Galaxy Populations to z~3
• Explosive Nucleosynthesis from GRB and Hypernova Progenitors: Direct Collapse versus Fallback
• The faint afterglow and host galaxy of the short-hard GRB 060121
• Refined Astrometry and Positions for 179 Swift X-ray Afterglows

Cited by in corpus (28)

• The optically unbiased GRB host (TOUGH) survey. I. Survey design and catalogs
• The Konus-Wind catalog of gamma-ray bursts with known redshifts. I. Bursts detected in the triggered mode
• Low-Luminosity Gamma-Ray Bursts as a Distinct GRB Population:A Firmer Case from Multiple Criteria Constraints
• Gamma-ray burst progenitors
• The X-ray fundamental plane of the Platinum Sample, the Kilonovae and the SNe Ib/c associated with GRBs
• Discovery of the afterglow and host galaxy of the low redshift short GRB 080905A
• Optical and X-ray GRB Fundamental Planes as Cosmological Distance Indicators
• The Optical Luminosity-Time Correlation for More Than 100 Gamma-Ray Burst Afterglows
• On the investigation of the closure relations for Gamma-Ray Bursts observed by Swift in the post-plateau phase and the GRB fundamental plane
• The Spectral Lag of GRB060505: A Likely Member of the Long Duration Class
• Cosmological Evolution of the Formation Rate of Short Gamma-ray Bursts With and Without Extended Emission
• The Optical Two and Three-Dimensional Fundamental Plane Correlations for Nearly 180 Gamma-Ray Burst Afterglows with Swift/UVOT, RATIR, and the SUBARU Telescope
• Constraints on the circumburst environments of short gamma-ray bursts
• The short GRB070707 afterglow and its very faint host galaxy
• On the nature of the short duration GRB 050906
• Closure relations during the plateau emission of Swift GRBs and the fundamental plane
• Exploring compact binary merger host galaxies and environments with $\mathrm{zELDA}$
• Spectroscopy and multiband photometry of the afterglow of intermediate duration gamma-ray burst 040924 and its host galaxy
• A quiescent galaxy at the position of the long GRB 050219A
• Testing the E_p,i - L_p,iso - T_0.45 correlation on a BeppoSAX and Swift sample of gamma-ray bursts
• Short gamma-ray bursts from SGR giant flares and neutron star mergers: two populations are better than one
• A Stochastic Approach To Reconstruct Gamma Ray Burst Lightcurves
• GRB 180418A: A possibly-short GRB with a wide-angle outflow in a faint host galaxy
• GRB Redshift Estimation using Machine Learning and the Associated Web-App
• Chandra and Hubble Space Telescope observations of dark gamma-ray bursts and their host galaxies
• GRB Optical and X-ray Plateau Properties Classifier Using Unsupervised Machine Learning
• Probability for chance coincidence of a gamma-ray burst with a galaxy on the sky
• Binary neutron star merger offsets from their host galaxies II. Short-duration gamma-ray bursts