Does the Transverse Electric Zero Mode Contribute to the Casimir Effect for a Metal?
arXiv:quant-ph/0212125 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.67.056116
Abstract
The finite temperature Casimir free energy, entropy, and internal energy are considered anew for a conventional parallel-plate configuration, in the light of current discussions in the literature. In the case of an "ideal" metal, characterized by a refractive index equal to infinity for all frequencies, we recover, via a somewhat unconventional method, conventional results for the temperature dependence, meaning that the zero-frequency transverse electric mode contributes the same as the transverse magnetic mode. For a real metal, however, approximately obeying the Drude dispersive model at low frequencies, we find that the zero-frequency transverse electric mode does not contribute at all. This would appear to lead to an observable temperature dependence and a violation of the third law of thermodynamics. It had been suggested that the source of the difficulty was the behaviour of the reflection coefficient for perpendicular polarization but we show that this is not the case. By introducing a simplified model for the Casimir interaction, consisting of two harmonic oscillators interacting via a third one, we illustrate the behavior of the transverse electric field. Numerical results are presented based on the refractive index for gold. A linear temperature correction to the Casimir force between parallel plates is indeed found which should be observable in room-temperature experiments, but this does not entail any thermodynamic inconsistency.
31 pages, REVTeX 4, 6 eps figures,to be published in Phys. Rev. E. This revision contains a number of small corrections and improvements, and two new references
References in corpus (23)
- New Developments in the Casimir Effect
- Precision Measurement of the Casimir Force from 0.1 to 0.9 microns
- Measurement of the Casimir force between parallel metallic surfaces
- Nonlinear Micromechanical Casimir Oscillator
- Improved Precision Measurement of the Casimir Force Using Gold Surfaces
- Template-stripped gold surfaces with 0.4 nm rms roughness suitable for force measurements. Application to the Casimir force in the 20-100 nm range
- Casimir force between metallic mirrors
- Demonstration of the Lateral Casimir Force
- Improved Precision Measurement of the Casimir Force
- Casimir force at both non-zero temperature and finite conductivity
- New constraints on ultrashort-ranged Yukawa interactions from atomic force microscopy
- Correlation of energy and free energy for the thermal Casimir force between real metals
- Thermodynamical aspects of the Casimir force between real metals at nonzero temperature
- Casimir Effect: The Classical Limit
- Temperature dependence of the Casimir force between real metals: problems and approach to their resolution
- New features of the thermal Casimir force at small separations
- Comment on "Demonstration of the Casimir Force in the 0.6 to 6 micrometer Range"
- The Casimir Problem of Spherical Dielectrics: Numerical Evaluation for General Permittivities
- Linear in temperature correction to the Casimir force
- The Casimir Problem of Spherical Dielectrics: Quantum Statistical and Field Theoretical Approaches
- Precise calculation of the Casimir force between gold surfaces
- Correlation between plasma and temperature corrections to the Casimir force
- What is the Temperature Dependence of the Casimir Force between Real Metals?
Cited by in corpus (94)
- The Casimir force between real materials: experiment and theory
- Tests of new physics from precise measurements of the Casimir pressure between two gold-coated plates
- Precise comparison of theory and new experiment for the Casimir force leads to stronger constraints on thermal quantum effects and long-range interactions
- Measurement of the Casimir force between dissimilar metals
- Improved tests of extra-dimensional physics and thermal quantum field theory from new Casimir force measurements
- The Casimir effect within scattering theory
- Finite temperature Casimir effect for graphene
- Violation of the Nernst heat theorem in the theory of thermal Casimir force between Drude metals
- On the Temperature Dependence of the Casimir Effect
- Detecting Chameleons through Casimir Force Measurements
- Theory confronts experiment in the Casimir force measurements: quantification of errors and precision
- Thermal Casimir vs Casimir-Polder forces: Equilibrium and non-equilibrium forces
- Thermal corrections to the Casimir effect
- Thermal quantum field theory and the Casimir interaction between dielectrics
- Influence of slab thickness on the Casimir force
- Experimental test for the conductivity properties from the Casimir force between metal and semiconductor
- Casimir-Polder interaction between an atom and a cavity wall under the influence of real conditions
- Correction to the Casimir force due to the anomalous skin effect
- Towards a precision measurement of the Casimir force in a cylinder-plane geometry
- Specific heat anomalies of open quantum systems
- Experiment and theory in the Casimir effect
- Nonlocal impedances and the Casimir entropy at low temperatures
- Casimir forces and non-Newtonian gravitation
- Analytical and Numerical Verification of the Nernst Theorem for Metals
- Comment on "On the temperature dependence of the Casimir effect"
- Present status of controversies regarding the thermal Casimir force
- Variations of Casimir energy from a superconducting transition
- What is the Temperature Dependence of the Casimir Effect?
- Thermal noise limitations to force measurements with torsion pendulums: Applications to the measurement of the Casimir force and its thermal correction
- Analytic approach to the thermal Casimir force between metal and dielectric
- Thermal correction to the Casimir force, radiative heat transfer, and an experiment
- Universal behavior of dispersion forces between two dielectric plates in the low-temperature limit
- Recent Developments in the Casimir Effect
- Thermal corrections in Casimir interaction between metal and dielectric
- Casimir Forces and Boundary Conditions in One Dimension: Attraction, Repulsion, Planck Spectrum, and Entropy
- A theory of electromagnetic fluctuations for metallic surfaces and van der Waals interactions between metallic bodies
- Anomalous temperature dependence of the Casimir force for thin metal films
- Quantum dissipative Brownian motion and the Casimir effect
- Comment on "Effects of spatial dispersion on electromagnetic surface modes and on modes associated with a gap between two half spaces"
- Casimir force between eccentric cylinders
- Casimir force between two ideal-conductor walls revisited
- Results from electrostatic calibrations for measuring the Casimir force in the cylinder-plane geometry
- New approach to the thermal Casimir force between real metals
- Hide it to see it better: a robust setup to probe the thermal Casimir effect
- Thermodynamic anomalies in open quantum systems: Strong coupling effects in the isotropic XY model
- Reply to "Comment on 'Analytic and Numerical Verification of the Nernst Theorem for Metals'"
- Viscous Brane Cosmology with a Brane-Bulk Energy Interchange Term
- Comment on ''Surface-impedance approach solves problems with the thermal Casimir force between real metals''
- Temperature Dependence of the Casimir Force
- Temperature Dependence of the Casimir Effect
- Finite Temperature Casimir Effect in Randall-Sundrum Models
- Casimir Force on Real Materials - the Slab and Cavity Geometry
- Analytical and Numerical Demonstration of How the Drude Dispersive Model Satisfies Nernst's Theorem for the Casimir Entropy
- Repulsive Casimir Force
- On the Feigel Effect: Extraction of Momentum from Vacuum?
- Observing the Casimir-Lifshitz Force Out of Thermal Equilibrium
- Geometrically confined thermal field theory: Finite size corrections and phase transitions
- Thermal and dissipative effects in Casimir physics
- Temperature Correction to Casimir-Lifshitz Free Energy at Low Temperatures: Semiconductors
- Geometric origin of negative Casimir entropies: A scattering-channel analysis
- Casimir Energies: Temperature Dependence, Dispersion, and Anomalies
- Lifshitz interaction can promote ice growth at water-silica interfaces
- Casimir forces in a Plasma: Possible Connections to Yukawa Potentials
- Evanescent character of the repulsive thermal Casimir force
- Casimir entropy and nonlocal response functions to the off-shell quantum fluctuations
- Remarks on the Casimir force for magnetodielectric media
- Concerning verification of the Nernst theorem for Casimir-Lifshitz free energy
- Finite Temperature Casimir Effect for a Massless Fractional Klein-Gordon field with Fractional Neumann Conditions
- Energetics of quantum vacuum friction. II: Dipole fluctuations and field fluctuations
- The Casimir force between a microfabricated elliptic cylinder and a plate
- Casimir energy and the superconducting phase transition
- Calculation of the Casimir Force between Similar and Dissimilar Metal Plates at Finite Temperature
- Casimir Self-Entropy of an Electromagnetic Thin Sheet
- Casimir Force on a Micrometer Sphere in a Dip: Proposal of an Experiment
- Something Can Come of Nothing: Surface Approaches to Quantum Fluctuations and the Casimir Force
- Thermal Issues in Casimir Forces Between Conductors and Semiconductors
- Evaluation of the Casimir Force for a Dielectric-diamagnetic Cylinder with Light Velocity Conservation Condition and the Analogue of Sellmeir's Dispersion Law
- The Aladin2 experiment: status and perspectives
- The influence of Lifshitz forces and gas on premelting of ice within porous materials
- Low temperature Casimir-Lifshitz free energy and entropy: the case of poor conductors
- On the Casimir entropy between 'perfect crystals'
- Theory of the Casimir effect for graphene at finite temperature
- Presence of negative entropies in Casimir interactions
- On the Temperature Dependence of the Casimir Force for Bulk Lossy Media
- Casimir Force between a Half-Space and a Plate of Finite Thickness
- Effects of phase transitions in devices actuated by the electromagnetic vacuum force
- A robust superconducting setup to probe the thermal Casimir effect
- Observation of the Thermal Casimir Force is Open to Question
- Van der Waals interactions: Evaluations by use of a statistical mechanical method
- Uniform quantized electron gas
- Casmir-Lifshitz Forces and Entropy
- Development of a high-sensitivity torsion balance to investigate the thermal Casimir force
- Entropy Bound for the TM Electromagnetic Field in the Half Einstein Universe
- Temperature-Distance Relations in Casimir Physics