Response to Eisenstein and Bunn's Null Hypothesis Comment on Cosmological Birefringence

Abstract

Eisenstein and Bunn have widely circulated a Comment (astro-ph/9704247) suggesting a non-standard null hypothesis in a test for cosmological birefringence. The Comment misrepresents the procedure used by Nodland and Ralston (B. Nodland and J. P. Ralston, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3043 (1997); astro-ph/9704196) and lacks statistical basis; no calculations were reported, but sweeping conclusions were drawn from eyeballing a single scatter plot. The results of the suggested procedure range from an underestimate of the statistical significance of well-correlated data, to a failure of detecting a perfect correlation in the limit of strong cuts. We verified these faults by performing the actual calculation which EB suggested, but neglected to carry out themselves. Furthermore, the calculation showed that the original correlation remains statistically significant, with the lego-plot of 1/P versus s showing a persistent bump, and the anisotropy direction s remaining in the same direction as previously reported.

2 pages, ReVTeX. Submitted to Physical Review Letters. More information is available at http://www.cc.rochester.edu/college/rtc/Borge/aniso.html

References in corpus (2)

• Indication of Anisotropy in Electromagnetic Propagation over Cosmological Distances
• Comment on the Appropriate Null Hypothesis for Cosmological Birefringence

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Lorentz-Violating Extension of the Standard Model
• Exact calculation of the radiatively-induced Lorentz and CPT violation in QED
• The Virgo Alignment Puzzle in Propagation of Radiation on Cosmological Scales
• Dynamical Lorentz simmetry breaking from 3+1 Axion-Wess-Zumino model
• Global and Local Effects of Rotation: Observational Aspects
• Spherically Symmetric Solutions of Gravitational Field Equations in Kalb-Ramond Background
• Rotation of the Universe and the angular momenta of celestial bodies
• Chern-Simons like term generation in an extended model of QED under external conditions
• The Corkscrew Effect
• Cosmic Optical Activity in a Randall-Sundrum Braneworld with Bulk Kalb-Ramond field
• Neutrino number asymmetry and cosmological birefringence
• Lorentz-breaking effects in scalar-tensor theories of gravity
• Primordial torsion fields as an explanation of the anisotropy in cosmological electromagnetic propagation
• One-loop structure of the photon propagator in the Standard Model Extension
• Cosmic optical activity in the spacetime of a scalar-tensor screwed cosmic string
• Rotation of the polarization vector from distant radio galaxies in the perturbed FRW metric
• Solar system constraints on planetary Coriolis-type effects induced by rotation of distant masses
• Spherically symmetric solution in a space-time with torsion
• The CMB Dipole and Circular Galaxy Distribution