Comment on the Appropriate Null Hypothesis for Cosmological Birefringence

Abstract

A recent paper (Nodland and Ralston, PRL 78, 3043, astro-ph/9704196) claims to have detected evidence for birefringence in the propagation of radio waves across cosmological distances. In order to assess the statistical significance of their results, the authors analyze simulated data sets, finding a stronger correlation in the real data than in the simulations. Unfortunately, the procedure used for generating the simulated data sets is based on an incorrect null hypothesis. Furthermore, the correct null hypothesis would lead to a stronger correlation in the simulated data sets, weakening the case for birefringence. We conclude that the paper's analysis does not provide statistically significant evidence of birefringence.

3 page, LaTeX, 1 ps fig included. Submitted as a Comment to PRL. We leave our initial Comment unchanged and append two pages detailing why the criticisms in astro-ph/9705190 are incorrect

References in corpus (1)

• Indication of Anisotropy in Electromagnetic Propagation over Cosmological Distances

Cited by in corpus (34)

• Lorentz-Violating Extension of the Standard Model
• Quintessence and the Rest of the World
• Exact calculation of the radiatively-induced Lorentz and CPT violation in QED
• Axion Dark Matter Detection with CMB Polarization
• Testing Parity-Violating Mechanisms with Cosmic Microwave Background Experiments
• Gravitational Leptogenesis and Its Signatures in CMB
• The Virgo Alignment Puzzle in Propagation of Radiation on Cosmological Scales
• Searches for the role of spin and polarization in gravity
• Dynamical Lorentz simmetry breaking from 3+1 Axion-Wess-Zumino model
• Anisotropy in the Distribution of Galactic Radio Polarizations
• Constraints on CPT violation from WMAP three year polarization data: a wavelet analysis
• First CMB Constraints on Direction-Dependent Cosmological Birefringence from WMAP-7
• Observational Evidence Against Birefringence Over Cosmological Distances
• Cross-Correlation of Cosmological Birefringence with CMB Temperature
• Empirical Foundations of Relativistic Gravity
• Global and Local Effects of Rotation: Observational Aspects
• The polarization in the JVAS/CLASS flat-spectrum radio sources: II. A search for aligned radio polarizations
• Limits on Cosmological Birefringence from the Ultraviolet Polarization of Distant Radio Galaxies
• WMAP 7 year constraints on CPT violation from large angle CMB anisotropies
• Rotation of the Universe and the angular momenta of celestial bodies
• Bayesian Analysis of the Polarization of Distant Radio Sources: Limits on Cosmological Birefringence
• The Corkscrew Effect
• Optical Activity of a Neutrino Gas
• Response to Eisenstein and Bunn's Null Hypothesis Comment on Cosmological Birefringence
• Neutrino number asymmetry and cosmological birefringence
• Non-Uniform Cosmological Birefringence and Active Galactic Nuclei
• Cosmic Polarization Rotation: an Astrophysical Test of Fundamental Physics
• Probing the Microscopic Origin of Gravity via Precision Polarization and Spin Experiments
• Primordial torsion fields as an explanation of the anisotropy in cosmological electromagnetic propagation
• Weak-Lensing by Large-Scale Structure and the Polarization Properties of Distant Radio-Sources
• The Parity Odd Universe, Dark Energy and QCD
• Cosmological Birefringence: an Astrophysical test of Fundamental Physics
• Cosmic optical activity in the spacetime of a scalar-tensor screwed cosmic string
• Cosmological birefringence induced by neutrino current