Revision of VLT/UVES constraints on a varying fine-structure constant

Abstract

We critically review the current null results on a varying fine-structure constant, alpha, derived from VLT/UVES quasar absorption spectra, focusing primarily on the many-multiplet analysis of 23 absorbers from which Chand et al. (2004) reported a weighted mean relative variation of da/a=(-0.06+/-0.06) x 10^{-5}. Our analysis of the same reduced data, using the same fits to the absorption profiles, yields very different individual da/a values with uncertainties typically larger by a factor of ~3. We attribute the discrepancies to flawed parameter estimation techniques in the original analysis and demonstrate that the original da/a values were strongly biased towards zero. Were those flaws not present, the input data and spectra should have given a weighted mean of da/a=(-0.44+/-0.16) x 10^{-5}. Although this new value does reflect the input spectra and fits (unchanged from the original work -- only our analysis is different), we do not claim that it supports previous Keck/HIRES evidence for a varying alpha: there remains significant scatter in the individual da/a values which may stem from the overly simplistic profile fits in the original work. Allowing for such additional, unknown random errors by increasing the uncertainties on da/a to match the scatter provides a more conservative weighted mean, da/a=(-0.64+/-0.36) x 10^{-5}. We highlight similar problems in other current UVES constraints on varying alpha and argue that comparison with previous Keck/HIRES results is premature.

arXiv comment11 pages, 7 figures (10 EPS files). Accepted by MNRAS. v3: Added figure summarizing all current UVES constraints; added references and corrected typos

References in corpus (18)

• Further Evidence for Cosmological Evolution of the Fine Structure Constant
• A Search for Time Variation of the Fine Structure Constant
• Further evidence for a variable fine-structure constant from Keck/HIRES QSO absorption spectra
• Possible evidence for a variable fine structure constant from QSO absorption lines: motivations, analysis and results
• Limits on the time variation of the electromagnetic fine-structure constant in the low energy limit from absorption lines in the spectra of distant quasars
• Space-Time Variation of Physical Constants and Relativistic Corrections in Atoms
• Probing the cosmological variation of the fine-structure constant: Results based on VLT-UVES sample
• Probing the variability of the fine-structure constant with the VLT/UVES
• Possible evidence for a variable fine structure constant from QSO absorption lines: systematic errors
• Further constraints on variation of the fine structure constant from alkali doublet QSO absorption lines
• On the variation of the fine-structure constant: Very high resolution spectrum of QSO HE 0515-4414
• Selection of ThAr lines for wavelength calibration of echelle spectra and implications for variations in the fine-structure constant
• Limits on variations in fundamental constants from 21-cm and ultraviolet quasar absorption lines
• A new measure of Delta alpha/alpha at redshift z = 1.84 from very high resolution spectra of Q1101-264
• Most precise single redshift bound to Delta alpha/alpha
• VLT/UVES constraints on the cosmological variability of the fine-structure constant
• Probing the time-variation of the fine-structure constant: Results based on Si IV doublets from a UVES sample
• Probing variations in fundamental constants with radio and optical quasar absorption-line observations

Cited by in corpus (86)

• Search for New Physics with Atoms and Molecules
• Varying constants, Gravitation and Cosmology
• The Physics of the Intergalactic Medium
• Spatial variation in the fine-structure constant -- new results from VLT/UVES
• Accurate Stellar Kinematics at Faint Magnitudes: application to the Bootes~I dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• Enhanced laboratory sensitivity to variation of the fine-structure constant using highly-charged ions
• Strong Limit on a Variable Proton-to-Electron Mass Ratio from Molecules in the Distant Universe
• Search for variation of the fundamental constants in atomic, molecular and nuclear spectra
• $f(T)$ Theories and Varying Fine Structure Constant
• Stringent null constraint on cosmological evolution of the proton-to-electron mass ratio
• The UVES Large Program for Testing Fundamental Physics: I Bounds on a change in alpha towards quasar HE 2217-2818
• Keck telescope constraint on cosmological variation of the proton-to-electron mass ratio
• Constraining changes in the proton-electron mass ratio with inversion and rotational lines
• The density, the cosmic microwave background, and the proton-to-electron mass ratio in a cloud at redshift 0.9
• Wavelength Accuracy of the Keck HIRES Spectrograph and Measuring Changes in the Fine Structure Constant
• First measurement of Mg isotope abundances at high redshifts and accurate estimate of Delta alpha/alpha
• UVES radial velocity accuracy from asteroid observations. Implications for the fine structure constant variability
• High-precision limit on variation in the fine-structure constant from a single quasar absorption system
• Breaking of the equivalence principle in the electromagnetic sector and its cosmological signatures
• Wavelength Calibration of the VLT-UVES Spectrograph
• New constraint on cosmological variation of the proton-to-electron mass ratio from Q0528-250
• A Frequency Comb calibrated Solar Atlas
• An Observational Determination of the Proton to Electron Mass Ratio in the Early Universe
• Searching for chameleon-like scalar fields with the ammonia method
• Precision spectroscopy of the 3s-3p fine structure doublet in Mg+
• Search for a Variation of the Fine Structure around the Supermassive Black Hole in Our Galactic Center
• Subaru Telescope limits on cosmological variations in the fine-structure constant
• On the (im)possibility of testing new physics in exoplanets using transit timing variations: deviation from inverse-square law of gravity
• General Dynamics of Varying-Alpha Universes
• Fundamental physics with ESPRESSO: Precise limit on variations in the fine-structure constant towards the bright quasar HE 0515$-$4414
• Manifestations of a spatial variation of fundamental constants on atomic clocks, Oklo, meteorites, and cosmological phenomena
• Is there further evidence for spatial variation of fundamental constants?
• Analysis of Molecular Hydrogen Absorption toward QSO B0642-5038 for a Varying Proton-to-Electron Mass Ratio
• Cosmologies in Horndeski's second-order vector-tensor theory
• Constraining the Variation of the Fine Structure Constant with Observations of Narrow Quasar Absorption Lines
• Constraining chameleon field theories using the GammeV afterglow experiments
• QSO 0347-383 and the invariance of m_p/m_e in the course of cosmic time
• A constraint on a varying proton--electron mass ratio 1.5 billion years after the Big Bang
• Precise limits on cosmological variability of the fine-structure constant with zinc and chromium quasar absorption lines
• Isotope shift calculations in Ti II
• On the Variations of Fundamental Constants and AGN feedback in the QSO host galaxy RXJ0911.4+0551 at z=2.79
• Varying-Alpha Cosmologies with Potentials
• Probing fundamental constant evolution with neutral atomic gas lines
• Constraining the time variation of the coupling constants from cosmic microwave background: effect of Λ_{QCD}
• Varying Alpha: New Constraints from Seasonal Variations
• Probing fundamental constant evolution with redshifted conjugate-satellite OH lines
• Eotvos bounds on couplings of fundamental parameters to gravity
• A new analysis of fine-structure constant measurements and modelling errors from quasar absorption lines
• Unifying cosmological and recent time variations of fundamental couplings
• Testing the Stability of the Fine Structure Constant in the Laboratory
• Stringent bounds to spatial variations of the electron-to-proton mass ratio in the Milky Way
• Atomic calculations and search for variation of the fine structure constant in quasar absorption spectra
• Probing dark energy beyond $z=2$ with CODEX
• Varying electric charge in multiscale spacetimes
• Invisible Active Galactic Nuclei. II Radio Morphologies & Five New HI 21 cm Absorption Line Detections
• On the cosmological evolution of alpha and mu and the dynamics of dark energy
• Enhanced sensitivity to the fine-structure constant variation in Th IV atomic clock transition
• Constraint on a variation of the proton-to-electron mass ratio from H2 absorption towards quasar Q2348-011
• Probing the constancy of the speed of light with future galaxy survey: the case of SKA and Euclid
• Varying Alpha Driven by the Dirac-Born-Infeld Scalar Field
• Atomic transition frequencies, isotope shifts, and sensitivity to variation of the fine structure constant for studies of quasar absorption spectra
• Implementation and Application of the Relativistic Equation of Motion Coupled-cluster Method for the Excited States of Closed-shell Atomic Systems
• Recovering a redshift-extended VSL signal from galaxy surveys
• Runaway Domain Wall and Space-time Varying alpha
• Do the fundamental constants change with time ?
• The value of the fine structure constant over cosmological times
• Probing the time variation of fine structure constant using galaxy clusters and quintessence model
• A new method for detecting velocity shifts and distortions between optical spectra
• Varying-Alpha and K-Essence
• Fundamental Physics with ESPRESSO, Constraining a simple parametrisation for varying $\alpha$
• Let's talk about varying G
• Redshifting of cosmological black bodies in BSBM varying-alpha theories
• Robust limit on a varying proton-to-electron mass ratio from a single H2 system
• Impact of the matter density uncertainty on the dark energy reconstruction
• The variation of the electromagnetic coupling and quintessence
• Revised fits to $\Delta \alpha /\alpha$ in consistency with the accelerating universe
• Bloch-Siegert shift in application to the astrophysical determination of the fundamental constants variation
• Estimations of the cosmological parameters from the observational variation of the fine structure constant
• Hitchhiker's Guide to the Swampland: The Cosmologist's Handbook to the string-theoretical Swampland Programme
• Sensitivity of the energy levels of singly ionized cobalt to the variation of the fine structure constant
• The time variation of the fine structure constant: A statistical analysis of astronomical data
• Variation of the Fine-Structure Constant from the de Sitter Invariant Special Relativity
• Assessing the viability of successful reconstruction of the dynamics of dark energy using varying fundamental couplings
• Constraints on variations of m${}_{\mathrm{p}}$/m${}_{\mathrm{e}}$ based on UVES observations of H${}_2$
• New constraints on the values of the fundamental constants at a look-back time of 7.3 Gyr
• On Non-triviality of Units Transformations