The Axis of Evil revisited

Abstract

In light of the three-year data release from WMAP we re-examine the evidence for the ``Axis of Evil'' (AOE). We discover that previous statistics are not robust with respect to the data-sets available and different treatments of the galactic plane. We identify the cause of the instability and implement an alternative ``model selection'' approach. A comparison to Gaussian isotropic simulations find the features significant at the 94-98% level, depending on the particular AOE model. The Bayesian evidence finds lower significance, ranging from ``substantial'' at $\Delta (\ln E)\sim 1.4$, to no evidence for the most general AOE model.

7 pages, accepted to MNRAS

References in corpus (24)

• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Preliminary Maps and Basic Results
• Information criteria for astrophysical model selection
• Asymmetries in the CMB anisotropy field
• A high resolution foreground cleaned CMB map from WMAP
• The significance of the largest scale CMB fluctuations in WMAP
• Detection of non-Gaussianity in the WMAP 1-year data using spherical wavelets
• The axis of evil
• Is the low-l microwave background cosmic?
• How many cosmological parameters?
• Testing the cosmological principle of isotropy: local power spectrum estimates of the WMAP data
• On the large-angle anomalies of the microwave sky
• On Foreground Removal from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe Data by an Internal Linear Combination Method: Limitations and Implications
• Non-Gaussian Signatures in the Temperature Fluctuation Observed by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe
• Testing for Non-Gaussianity in the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe Data: Minkowski Functionals and the Length of the Skeleton
• Asymmetries in the local curvature of the WMAP data
• Is the Universe odd?
• The Virgo Alignment Puzzle in Propagation of Radiation on Cosmological Scales
• Can the lack of symmetry in the COBE/DMR maps constrain the topology of the universe?
• On the CMB large-scales angular correlations
• Model selection as a science driver for dark energy surveys
• Isotropy of the early universe from CMB anisotropies
• Template fitting and the large-angle CMB anomalies
• Occam's razor meets WMAP

Cited by in corpus (106)

• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Data Processing, Sky Maps, and Basic Results
• Large-angle anomalies in the CMB
• Cosmic Microwave Background Statistics for a Direction-Dependent Primordial Power Spectrum
• Power Asymmetry in Cosmic Microwave Background Fluctuations from Full Sky to Sub-degree Scales: Is the Universe Isotropic?
• A Cosmic Microwave Background feature consistent with a cosmic texture
• Power asymmetry in WMAP and Planck temperature sky maps as measured by a local variance estimator
• Primordial statistical anisotropy generated at the end of inflation
• Anisotropic Cosmological Constant and the CMB Quadrupole Anomaly
• Elko as self-interacting fermionic dark matter with axis of locality
• Detection of a Dipole in the Handedness of Spiral Galaxies with Redshifts z ~ 0.04
• Anomalous parity asymmetry of the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe power spectrum data at low multipoles
• Cosmology of a Scalar Field Coupled to Matter and an Isotropy-Violating Maxwell Field
• The CMB cold spot: texture, cluster or void?
• The optimal phase of the generalised Poincare dodecahedral space hypothesis implied by the spatial cross-correlation function of the WMAP sky maps
• Anisotropic Inflation from Charged Scalar Fields
• Stability of Horndeski vector-tensor interactions
• Testable polarization predictions for models of CMB isotropy anomalies
• Fingerprints of Galactic Loop I on the Cosmic Microwave Background
• Anomalous parity asymmetry of WMAP power spectrum data at low multpoles: is it cosmological or systematics?
• Exploring Elko typical signature
• The Szekeres Swiss Cheese model and the CMB observations
• Particle Production of Vector Fields: Scale Invariance is Attractive
• Explaining Cosmological Anisotropy: Evidence for Causal Horizons from CMB data
• Non-isotropy in the CMB power spectrum in single field inflation
• Anisotropic dark energy and CMB anomalies
• Non-gaussianity at tree and one-loop levels from vector field perturbations
• Zero Energy of Plane-Waves for ELKOs
• Non-detection of a statistically anisotropic power spectrum in large-scale structure
• Testing Isotropy of Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation
• Null Signal for the Cosmic Anisotropy in the Pantheon Supernovae Data
• Alignment and signed-intensity anomalies in WMAP data
• Causal propagation for ELKO fields
• The axis of evil - a polarization perspective
• Anomalous CMB north-south asymmetry
• Translational Invariance and the Anisotropy of the Cosmic Microwave Background
• Is the CMB asymmetry due to the kinematic dipole?
• Planck CMB Anomalies: Astrophysical and Cosmological Secondary Effects and the Curse of Masking
• Accelerating dark energy models with anisotropic fluid in Bianchi type-$V{I}_0$ space-time
• Testing Isotropy in the Local Universe
• Directional dependence of CMB parity asymmetry
• 'Tilting' the Universe with the Landscape Multiverse: The 'Dark' Flow
• Can a primordial magnetic field originate large-scale anomalies in WMAP data?
• Signals of Statistical Anisotropy in WMAP Foreground-Cleaned Maps
• Issues on Generating Primordial Anisotropies at the End of Inflation
• Inflationary power asymmetry from primordial domain walls
• Statistical Anisotropy and the Vector Curvaton Paradigm
• Needlet Bispectrum Asymmetries in the WMAP 5-year Data
• Testing the Cosmic Anisotropy with Supernovae Data: Hemisphere Comparison and Dipole Fitting
• A Theory of a Spot
• The Topology and Size of the Universe from the Cosmic Microwave Background
• Causality for ELKOs
• Statistical Anisotropy from Vector Curvaton in D-brane Inflation
• Non-Gaussianity analysis on local morphological measures of WMAP data
• Analysis of non-Gaussian CMB maps based on the N-pdf. Application to WMAP data
• Cosmological Constant, Fine Structure Constant and Beyond
• Searching for non-Gaussianity in the WMAP data
• Observation number correlation in WMAP data
• Bipolar Harmonic encoding of CMB correlation patterns
• Non-gaussianity in the foreground-reduced CMB maps
• Can residuals of the Solar system foreground explain low multipole anomalies of the CMB ?
• Harmonic in-painting of CMB sky by constrained Gaussian realization
• North-South non-Gaussian asymmetry in PLANCK CMB maps
• Is the cold spot responsible for the CMB North-South asymmetry?
• Cosmic Anisotropy and Fast Radio Bursts
• Symmetry and anti-symmetry of the CMB anisotropy pattern
• On Preferred Axes in WMAP Cosmic Microwave Background Data after Subtraction of the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
• Preferred axis of CMB parity asymmetry in the masked maps
• MOND's acceleration scale as a fundamental quantity
• The Kullback-Leibler Divergence as an Estimator of the Statistical Properties of CMB Maps
• Large-scale anomalies of the CMB in the curvaton scenario
• Statistical Characterization of Temperature Patterns in Anisotropic Cosmologies
• WMAP anomalous signal in the ecliptic plane
• Large-scale cosmic flows and moving dark energy
• CMB Isotropy Anomalies and the Local Kinetic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• Harmonic Inpainting of the Cosmic Microwave Background Sky: Formulation and Error Estimate
• The Parity Odd Universe, Dark Energy and QCD
• Hemispherical power asymmetry: parameter estimation from CMB WMAP5 data
• Eliminating the eta-problem in SUGRA Hybrid Inflation with Vector Backreaction
• Probability Density of the Multipole Vectors for a Gaussian Cosmic Microwave Background
• Effect of Foregrounds on the CMBR Multipole Alignment
• Dark Energy Cosmology with the Alternative Cosmic Microwave Background Data
• Compact Stars in Vector-Tensor-Horndeski Theory of Gravity
• Large scale vector modes and the first CMB temperature multipoles
• SNe Ia Tests of Quintessence Tracker Cosmology in an Anisotropic Background
• Some doubts on the validity of the foreground Galactic contribution subtraction from microwave anisotropies
• Cosmic microwave background anomalies viewed via Gumbel Statistics
• On the Coherence of WMAP and Planck Temperature Maps
• Symmetry of the CMB sky as a new test of its statistical isotropy. Non Cosmological Octupole?
• Temperature and Polarization Patterns in Anisotropic Cosmologies
• How Sensitive is the CMB to a Single Lens?
• Electrodynamic effect of anisotropic expansions in the Universe
• Search for a direction in the forest of Lyman-$\alpha$
• The primordial "f_NL" non-Gaussianity, and perturbations beyond the present horizon
• Testing Short Distance Anisotropy in Space
• Statistics of the excursion sets in models with local primordial non-Gaussianity
• The Diffuse Light of the Universe - On the microwave background before and after its discovery: open questions
• Limits on Semiclassical Fluctuations in the Primordial Universe
• Cosmic microwave background constraints on cosmological models with large-scale isotropy breaking
• Phase statistics of the WMAP 7 year data
• Distance-Redshift Relations in an Anisotropic Cosmological Model
• The quantum origin of cosmic structure: theory and observations
• An overview of the current status of CMB observations
• CMB Anomalies from Imperfect Dark Energy: Confrontation with the Data
• Hidden in the background: a local approach to CMB anomalies
• Novel setup for detecting short-range anisotropic corrections to gravity