QPOs during magnetar flares are not driven by mechanical normal modes of the crust
arXiv:astro-ph/0601020 · doi:10.1111/j.1745-3933.2006.00155.x
Abstract
Quasi-Periodic Oscillations (QPOs) have been observed during three powerful magnetar flares, from SGR0526-66, SGR1806-20 and SGR1900+14. These QPOs have been commonly interpreted as being driven by the mechanical modes of the magnetar's solid crust which are excited during the flare. Here we show that this interpretation is in sharp contradiction with the conventional magnetar model. Firstly, we show that a magnetar crustal mode decays on the timescale of at most a second due to the emission of Alfven waves into the neutron-star interior. A possible modification is then to assume that the QPOs are associated with the magnetars' global modes. However, we argue that at the frequencies of the observed QPOs, the neutron-star core is likely to support a continuum of Magneto-Hydrodynamic (MHD) normal modes. We demonstrate this on a completely solvable toy model which captures the essential physics of the system. We then show that the frequency of the global mode of the whole star is likely to have a significant imaginary component, and its amplitude is likely to decay on a short timescale. This is not observed. Thus we conclude that either (i) the origin of the QPO is in the magnetar's magnetosphere, or (ii) the magnetic field has a special configuration: either it is expelled from the magnetar's core prior to the flares, or its poloidal component has very small coherence length.
arXiv comment4 pages, accepted to MNRAS letters. Important references on oscillations of magnetic stars are added, comment on the 625Hz QPO is added, the conclusions are strengthened
References in corpus (12)
- An exceptionally bright flare from SGR1806-20 and the origins of short-duration gamma-ray bursts
- Gamma-Ray Observations of a Giant Flare from The Magnetar SGR 1806-20
- A giant, periodic flare from the soft gamma repeater SGR1900+14
- Discovery of Rapid X-ray Oscillations in the Tail of the SGR 1806-20 Hyperflare
- Discovery of Fast X-ray Oscillations During the 1998 Giant Flare from SGR 1900+14
- Explosive reconnection in magnetars
- Global Seismic Oscillations in Soft Gamma Repeaters
- Detection with RHESSI of high frequency X-ray oscillations in the tail of the 2004 hyperflare from SGR 1806-20
- Shear Waves and Giant Flare Oscillations from Soft Gamma-Ray Repeaters
- A Giant Outburst from SGR 1900+14 Observed with the BeppoSAX Gamma Ray Burst Monitor
- Hydromagnetic and gravitomagnetic crust-core coupling in a precessing neutron star
- Oscillations of magnetic stars: II. Axisymmetric toroidal and non-axisymmetric shear Alfven modes in a spherical shell
Cited by in corpus (99)
- Magnetars: the physics behind observations
- Neutron Star Asteroseismology. Axial Crust Oscillations in the Cowling Approximation
- Gravitational waves from neutron stars: Promises and challenges
- The 2004 Hyperflare from SGR 1806-20: Further Evidence for Global Torsional Vibrations
- Asteroseismology Can Reveal Strong Internal Magnetic Fields in Red Giant Stars
- Gravitational Waves from Neutron Stars: A Review
- Repeating Fast Radio Bursts from Magnetars with Low Magnetospheric Twist
- How Gravitational-wave Observations Can Shape the Gamma-ray Burst Paradigm
- Magneto-elastic oscillations of neutron stars with dipolar magnetic fields
- Probing the Equation of State of Nuclear Matter via Neutron Star Asteroseismology
- Elastic or magnetic? A toy model for global magnetar oscillations with implications for QPOs during flares
- Alfvén QPOs in Magnetars
- Neutron star oscillations and QPOs during magnetar flares
- Long gravitational-wave transients and associated detection strategies for a network of terrestrial interferometers
- Magnetars oscillations in the presence of a crust
- Effect of superfluidity on neutron star crustal oscillations
- Hydromagnetic Instabilities in Neutron Stars
- Magneto-elastic oscillations and the damping of crustal shear modes in magnetars
- Coupled polar-axial magnetar oscillations
- Search for gravitational wave radiation associated with the pulsating tail of the SGR 1806-20 hyperflare of 27 December 2004 using LIGO
- Plasmoid ejection by Alfvén waves and the fast radio bursts from SGR 1935+2154
- The Fast Radio Burst Luminosity Function and Death Line in the Low-Twist Magnetar Model
- Alfven QPOs in magnetars in the anelastic approximation
- Constraints on the Magnetic Field Geometry of Magnetars
- Possible Constraints on the Density Dependence of the Nuclear Symmetry Energy from Quasiperiodic Oscillations in Soft Gamma Repeaters
- On the Quasi-Periodic Oscillations of Magnetars
- Magnetars: a short review and some sparse considerations
- Magnetar Oscillations I: strongly coupled dynamics of the crust and the core
- Quasi-Periodic Oscillations in Short Recurring Bursts of the Soft-Gamma Repeater J1550-5418
- Superfluid signatures in magnetar seismology
- Global Crustal Dynamics of Magnetars in Relation to their Bright X-ray Outbursts
- Quasi-periodic oscillations in superfluid magnetars
- Evidence for an abundant old population of Galactic ultra long period magnetars and implications for fast radio bursts
- Spectrum of shear modes in the neutron-star crust: Estimating the nuclear-physics uncertainties
- Alfvén Polar Oscillations of Relativistic Stars
- Stratification, superfluidity and magnetar QPOs
- Axisymmetric oscillations of magnetic neutron stars
- Possible identifications of newly observed magnetar quasi-periodic oscillations as crustal shear modes
- Constraints on the symmetry energy from observational probes of the neutron star crust
- A Quake Quenching the Vela Pulsar
- Magnetar Oscillations II: spectral method
- Axisymmetric toroidal modes of magnetized neutron stars
- On the trigger mechanisms for SGR giant flares
- Shear modulus of neutron star crust
- Crustal Oscillations of Slowly Rotating Relativistic Stars
- Hydromagnetic waves in a superfluid neutron star with strong vortex pinning
- Constraining properties of high-density matter in neutron stars with magneto-elastic oscillations
- Axial quasi-normal modes of neutron stars: Accounting for the superfluid in the crust
- Constraining the Origin of Magnetar Flares
- On the Persistence of QPOs During the SGR 1806-20 Giant Flare
- SGR1806-20: evidence for a superstrong Magnetic Field from Quasi Periodic Oscillations
- Coherent magneto-elastic oscillations in superfluid magnetars
- Elastic stars in general relativity: IV. Axial perturbations
- High frequency oscillations during magnetar flares
- Intermittency and Lifetime of the 625 Hz QPO in the 2004 Hyperflare from the Magnetar SGR 1806-20 as evidence for magnetic coupling between the crust and the core
- Gravity waves in strong magnetic fields
- Tidally-induced Magnetar Super Flare at the Eve of Coalescence with Its Compact Companion
- Shear oscillations in the hadron-quark mixed phase
- Magnetar giant flare oscillations and the nuclear symmetry energy
- Torsional Oscillations of a Magnetar with a Tangled Magnetic Field
- Deformed crystals and torsional oscillations of neutron star crust
- Searching for quasi-periodic oscillations in astrophysical transients using Gaussian processes
- Quasi-periodic oscillations in superfluid, relativistic magnetars with nuclear pasta phases
- Search for quasi-periodic signals in magnetar giant flares
- Magnetar QPOs and neutron star crust elasticity
- Electromagnetic fields in the exterior of an oscillating relativistic star -- II. Electromagnetic damping
- Identification of noise artifacts in searches for long-duration gravitational-wave transients
- Empirical formula of crustal torsional oscillations
- Three evolutionary paths for magnetar oscillations
- Electron screening effects on crustal torsional oscillations
- Non-radial oscillations of the magnetized rotating stars with purely toroidal magnetic fields
- Observable QPOs produced by steep pulse profiles in Magnetar Flares
- Discovery of Quasi-Periodic Oscillations in the Recurrent Burst Emission from SGR 1806-20
- Short-period pulsar oscillations following a glitch
- Role of nuclear physics in oscillations of magnetars
- Quasi-periodic oscillations during magnetar giant flares in the strangeon star model
- Non-axisymmetric magnetic modes of neutron stars with purely poloidal magnetic fields
- A Comptonized Fireball Bubble Fits the Second Extragalactic Magnetar Giant Flare GRB 231115A
- Torsional oscillations of magnetized neutron stars with mixed poloidal-toroidal fields
- Tangled magnetic field model of QPOs
- Gravitational waves from nonradial oscillations of stochastically accreting neutron stars
- What Magnetar Seismology can Teach us about the Magnetic Fields
- Continuous frequency spectrum of the global hydromagnetic oscillations of a magnetically confined mountain on an accreting neutron star
- Magneto-elastic torsional oscillations of magnetars
- Selfsimilarity relations for torsional oscillations of neutron stars
- The Giant Flare from SGR 1806-20 and its Radio Afterglow
- Zeeman splitting of torsional oscillation frequencies of magnetars
- A Magnetic Flux Tube Oscillation Model for QPOs in SGR Giant Flares
- Powerful flares and magneto-elastic oscillations of magnetars
- Axisymmetric magnetic modes of neutron stars having mixed poloidal and toroidal magnetic fields
- Axisymmetric spheroidal modes of neutron stars magnetized with poloidal magnetic fields
- Magneto-elastic oscillations modulating the emission of magnetars
- Turbulence in Magnetised Neutron Stars
- Non-axisymmetric low frequency oscillations of rotating and magnetized neutron stars
- Torsional oscillations of magnetized neutron stars: Impacts of Landau-Rabi quantization of electron motion
- Zeeman effect in oscillations of magnetars with toroidal magnetic fields
- Prompt and Afterglow Constraints on the Central Engine of GRB 240825A
- The Broad-band Noise Characteristics of Selected Anomalous X-Ray Pulsars and Soft Gamma-ray Repeaters
- Quasi-Periodic Oscillations in magnetars: linking variability and emission