Neon Lights Up a Controversy: the Solar Ne/O Abundance

Abstract

The standard solar model was so reliable that it could predict the existence of the massive neutrino. Helioseismology measurements were so precise that they could determine the depth of the convection zone. This agreement between theory and observation was the envy of all astrophysics -- until recently when sophisticated three-dimensional hydrodynamic calculations of the solar atmosphere reduced the metal content by a factor of almost two. Antia & Basu (2005) suggested that a higher value of the solar neon abundance, Ne/O = 0.52, would resolve this controversy. Drake & Testa (2005) presented strong evidence in favor of this idea from a sample of 21 Chandra stars with enhanced values of the neon abundance, Ne/O = 0.41. In this paper, we have analyzed solar active region spectra from the archive of the Flat Crystal Spectrometer on Solar Maximum Mission, a NASA mission from the 1980s, as well as full-Sun spectra from the pioneering days of X-ray astronomy in the 1960s. These data seem consistent with the standard neon-to-oxygen abundance value, Ne/O = 0.15 (Grevesse & Sauval 1998). If these results prove to be correct, than the enhanced-neon hypothesis will not resolve the current controversy.

arXiv commentsubmitted to ApJ Letters

References in corpus (8)

• The 'Forbidden' Abundance of Oxygen in the Sun
• Ionization balance for optically thin plasmas: rate coefficients for all atoms and ions of the elements H to Ni
• Line formation in solar granulation: IV. [O I], OI and OH lines and the photospheric O abundance
• CHIANTI - an Atomic Database for Emission Lines. Paper VI: Proton Rates and Other Improvements
• The "Solar Model Problem" Solved by the Abundance of Neon in Stars of the Local Cosmos
• What Is The Neon Abundance Of The Sun?
• The discrepancy between solar abundances and helioseismology
• How Accurately Can We Calculate the Depth of the Solar Convective Zone?

Cited by in corpus (43)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• Spitzer Quasar and ULIRG Evolution Study (QUEST). IV. Comparison of 1-Jy Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxies with Palomar-Green Quasars
• Helioseismology and Solar Abundances
• Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas
• X-Ray Spectroscopy of Stars
• Resolving the Xi Boo Binary with Chandra, and Revealing the Spectral Type Dependence of the Coronal "FIP Effect"
• Solar UV and X-Ray Spectral Diagnostics
• The Sun in Time: Activity and Environment
• The Solar Heavy Element Abundances: I. Constraints from Stellar Interiors
• Non-WKB Models of the FIP Effect: Implications for Solar Coronal Heating and the Coronal Helium and Neon Abundances
• Neon Fine-Structure Line Emission By X-ray Irradiated Protoplanetary Disks
• Properties of Energetic Ions in the Solar Atmosphere from γ -Ray and Neutron Observations
• Solar structure and evolution
• High-Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy of the Interstellar Medium II: Neon and Iron Absorption Edges
• Determining solar abundances using helioseismology
• Solar abundances and helioseismology: fine structure spacings and separation ratios of low-degree p modes
• Elemental abundances of Galactic bulge planetary nebulae from optical recombination lines
• Low abundances of heavy elements in the solar outer layers: comparisons of solar models with helioseismic inversions
• Extinction Columns and Intrinsic X-ray Spectra of the Anomalous X-ray Pulsars
• The neon content of nearby B-type stars and its implications for the solar model problem
• Element abundance ratios in the quiet Sun transition region
• A Chandra/LETGS Survey of Main Sequence Stars
• X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy of the Multi-phase Interstellar Medium: Oxygen and Neon Abundances
• Investigating the reliability of coronal emission measure distribution diagnostics using 3D radiative MHD simulations
• Solar Models with Revised Abundances and Opacities
• A Method to Derive the Absolute Composition of the Sun, the Solar System and the Stars
• A Solar cycle correlation of coronal element abundances in Sun-as-a-star observations
• Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium Associated with the Coma Cluster
• Coronal Emission Measures and Abundances for Moderately Active K Dwarfs Observed by Chandra
• X-Ray Flaring on the dMe Star, Ross 154
• Perspectives in Global Helioseismology, and the Road Ahead
• Neon and oxygen in low activity stars: towards a coronal unification with the Sun
• New light on the old problem of lithium pre--MS depletion: models with 2D RHD convection
• The Coronal Abundances of Mid-F Dwarfs
• A diagnostic of coronal elemental behavior during the inverse FIP effect in solar flares
• Solar models with new low-metal abundances
• The Solar Heavy Element Abundances: II. Constraints from Stellar Atmospheres
• The coronal Ne/O abundance of alpha Centauri
• Neon Insights from Old Solar X-rays: a Plasma Temperature Dependence of the Coronal Neon Content
• Astrophysics in 2005
• The Sun's Interior Metallicity Constrained by Neutrinos
• Solar cycle observations of the Neon abundance in the Sun-as-a-star
• Structure and variability in the corona of the ultrafast rotator LO Peg