Investigating the reliability of coronal emission measure distribution diagnostics using 3D radiative MHD simulations

Abstract

Determining the temperature distribution of coronal plasmas can provide stringent constraints on coronal heating. Current observations with the Extreme ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph onboard Hinode and the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly onboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory provide diagnostics of the emission measure distribution (EMD) of the coronal plasma. Here we test the reliability of temperature diagnostics using 3D radiative MHD simulations. We produce synthetic observables from the models, and apply the Monte Carlo Markov chain EMD diagnostic. By comparing the derived EMDs with the "true" distributions from the model we assess the limitations of the diagnostics, as a function of the plasma parameters and of the signal-to-noise of the data. We find that EMDs derived from EIS synthetic data reproduce some general characteristics of the true distributions, but usually show differences from the true EMDs that are much larger than the estimated uncertainties suggest, especially when structures with significantly different density overlap along the line-of-sight. When using AIA synthetic data the derived EMDs reproduce the true EMDs much less accurately, especially for broad EMDs. The differences between the two instruments are due to the: (1) smaller number of constraints provided by AIA data, (2) broad temperature response function of the AIA channels which provide looser constraints to the temperature distribution. Our results suggest that EMDs derived from current observatories may often show significant discrepancies from the true EMDs, rendering their interpretation fraught with uncertainty. These inherent limitations to the method should be carefully considered when using these distributions to constrain coronal heating.

Accepted for publication on The Astrophysical Journal. 25 pages, 29 figures. Paper version with full resolution images and appendixes can be found at: http://folk.uio.no/bdp/papers/3dEMD_ptesta.pdf

References in corpus (7)

• Differential Emission Measures from the Regularized Inversion of Hinode and SDO data
• High precision density measurements in the solar corona: I. Analysis methods and results for Fe XII and Fe XIII
• Observations of Active Region Loops with the EUV Imaging Spectrometer on Hinode
• Hinode X-Ray Telescope Detection of Hot Emission from Quiescent Active Regions: A Nanoflare Signature?
• Hinode/EIS spectroscopic validation of very hot plasma imaged with Solar Dynamics Observatory in non-flaring active region cores
• The Temperature and Density Structure of the Solar Corona. I. Observations of the Quiet Sun with the EUV Imaging Spectrometer (EIS) on Hinode
• Hinode/Extreme-Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrometer Observations of the Temperature Structure of the Quiet Corona

Cited by in corpus (32)

• Thermal Diagnostics with the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly onboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory: A Validated Method for Differential Emission Measure Inversions
• Evidence of Non-Thermal Particles in Coronal Loops Heated Impulsively by Nanoflares
• Multi-thermal dynamics and energetics of a coronal mass ejection in the low solar atmosphere
• The Multi-slit Approach to Coronal Spectroscopy with the Multi-slit Solar Explorer (MUSE)
• Observations of Subarcsecond Bright Dots in the Transition Region above Sunspots with the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: II. Thermal Energies
• On the Accuracy of the Differential Emission Measure Diagnostics of Solar Plasmas. Application to AIA/SDO. Part I: Isothermal plasmas
• Observational Signatures of Coronal Loop Heating and Cooling Driven by Footpoint Shuffling
• Can the Differential Emission Measure constrain the timescale of energy deposition
• 3D MHD modeling of twisted coronal loops
• IRIS observations of short-term variability in moss associated with transient hot coronal loops
• Diagnosing the time-dependence of active region core heating from the emission measure: II. Nanoflare trains
• Observations of Thermal Flare Plasma with the EUV Variability Experiment
• Benchmark Test of Differential Emission Measure Codes and Multi-Thermal Energies in Solar Active Regions
• Multi-component Decomposition of Astronomical Spectra by Compressed Sensing
• Constraining Hot Plasma in a Non-flaring Solar Active Region with FOXSI Hard X-ray Observations
• The Evolution of the EM Distribution in the Core of an Active Region
• Multi-Wavelength Observations of the Spatio-Temporal Evolution of Solar Flares with AIA/SDO: II. Hydrodynamic Scaling Laws and Thermal Energies
• Coronal Mini-jets in an Activated Solar Tornado-like Prominence
• The Slowly Varying Corona: I --- Daily Differential Emission Measure Distributions Derived from EVE Spectra
• Multimodal Differential Emission Measure in the Solar Corona
• Thermal structure of hot non-flaring corona from Hinode/EIS
• Modeling Coronal Response in Decaying Active Regions with Magnetic Flux Transport and Steady Heating
• Broadening of the DEM by multi-shelled and turbulent loops
• Solar Active Region Heating Diagnostics from High Temperature Emission using the Marshall Grazing Incidence X-ray Spectrometer (MaGIXS)
• Heating Mechanisms for Intermittent Loops in Active Region Cores from AIA/SDO EUV Observations
• Relative Abundance Measurements in Plumes and Interplumes
• Energy Input Flux in the Global Quiet-Sun Corona
• The Slowly Varying Corona. II. The Components of F ${}_{10.7}$ and Their Use in EUV Proxies
• Small-scale Bright Blobs Ejected from a Sunspot Light Bridge
• FIP Bias Evolution in an Emerging Active Region as observed in SPICE Synoptic Observations
• Measuring relative abundances in the solar corona with optimised linear combinations of spectral lines