Concerning the White Dwarf Cooling Age of M4: A Response to the Paper by De Marchi et al. on "A Different Interpretation of Recent HST Observations"
arXiv:astro-ph/0401446 · doi:10.1086/383294
Abstract
We respond to the paper by De Marchi, Paresce, Straniero and Moroni (2003) on the white dwarf cooling age of M4. The authors question the data analysis and interpretation that led to the conclusions in Hansen et al. (2002). In their paper, De Marchi et al. are unable to obtain photometry as deep as ours from the same data set and therefore assert that only a lower limit to the white dwarf cooling age for this cluster of approximately 9 Gyr can be obtained. In this short contribution we show that shortcomings in the data analysis and reduction techniques of De Marchi et al. are responsible for their inability to reach the photometry limits that our study reports. In a forthcoming paper in which the complete techniques for age determination with white dwarfs are laid out, we demonstrate that their method of fitting the luminosity function gives a spuriously low white dwarf cooling age.
arXiv comment14 pages, 5 figures, AJ in press
References in corpus (7)
- First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
- The White Dwarf Cooling Sequence of the Globular Cluster Messier 4
- White Dwarfs in Globular Clusters: HST Observations of M4
- The Lower Main Sequence and Mass Function of the Globular Cluster Messier 4
- Hubble Space Telescope Observations of White Dwarfs in the Globular Cluster M4
- The Galactic Inner Halo: Searching for White Dwarfs and Measuring the Fundamental Galactic Constant, Vo/Ro
- On the age and mass function of the globular cluster M4: a different interpretation of recent deep HST observations
Cited by in corpus (12)
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
- The White Dwarf Cooling Sequence of NGC6397
- The white dwarf cooling sequence in NGC 6791
- Stellar Proper Motions in the Galactic Bulge from deep HST ACS/WFC Photometry
- HST Observations of the White Dwarf Cooling Sequence of M4
- The End of the White Dwarf Cooling Sequence in M4: an efficient approach
- On the distance of the globular cluster M4 (NGC 6121) using RR Lyrae stars: I. optical and near-infrared Period-Luminosity and Period-Wesenheit relations
- A Deep HST Study of the Globular Cluster NGC 6397: Reduction Methods
- Spectral Types and Masses of White Dwarfs in Globular Clusters
- From Young and Hot to Old and Cold: Comparing White Dwarf Cooling Theory to Main Sequence Stellar Evolution in Open Clusters
- Cataclysmic and Close Binaries in Star Clusters. V. Erupting Dwarf Novae, Faint Blue Stars, X-ray sources, and the Classical Nova in the Core of M80
- White dwarf atmosphere models with Ly- opacity in the analysis of the white dwarf cooling sequence of NGC 6397