Testing the circumstellar disk hypothesis: A search for H2 outflow signatures from massive YSOs with linearly distributed methanol masers

Abstract

The results of a survey searching for outflows using near-infrared imaging is presented. Targets were chosen from a compiled list of massive young stellar objects (YSOs) associated with methanol masers in linear distributions. Presently, it is a widely held belief that these methanol masers are found in (and delineate) circumstellar accretion disks around massive stars. If this scenario is correct, one way to test the disk hypothesis is to search for outflows perpendicular to the methanol maser distributions. The main objective of the survey was to obtain wide-field near-infrared images of the sites of linearly distributed methanol masers using a narrow-band 2.12 micron filter. This filter is centered on the H2 v=1-0 S(1) line; a shock diagnostic that has been shown to successfully trace CO outflows from young stellar objects. Twenty-eight sources in total were imaged of which eighteen sources display H2 emission. Of these, only TWO sources showed emission found to be dominantly perpendicular to the methanol maser distribution. Surprisingly, the H2 emission in these fields is not distributed randomly, but instead the majority of sources are found to have H2 emission dominantly PARALLEL to their distribution of methanol masers. These results seriously question the hypothesis that methanol masers exist in circumstellar disks. The possibility that linearly distributed methanol masers are instead directly associated with outflows is discussed.

26 pages, 26 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Pre-prints with higher quality figures can be found at http://www.ctio.noao.edu/~debuizer/

References in corpus (4)

• Massive star formation in 100,000 years from turbulent and pressurized molecular clouds
• Mid-Infrared Detection of a Hot Molecular Core in G29.96-0.02
• Mid-Infrared Imaging of NGC 6334 I
• High-Resolution Mid-Infrared Imaging of G339.88-1.26

Cited by in corpus (62)

• Toward Understanding Massive Star Formation
• A Catalog of Extended Green Objects (EGOs) in the GLIMPSE Survey: A new sample of massive young stellar object outflow candidates
• Hierarchical fragmentation and differential star formation in the Galactic "Snake": infrared dark cloud G11.11-0.12
• A Class I and Class II Methanol Maser Survey of Extended Green Objects (EGOs) from the GLIMPSE Survey
• Accretion disks in luminous young stellar objects
• Southern class I methanol masers at 36 and 44 GHz
• A near IR imaging survey of intermediate and high-mass young stellar outflow candidates
• A search for ionized jets towards massive young stellar objects
• A 95 GHz Class I Methanol Maser Survey Toward GLIMPSE Extended Green Objects (EGOs)
• Full-Polarization Observations of OH Masers in Massive Star-Forming Regions: II. Maser Properties and the Interpretation of Polarization
• The Extraordinary Outburst in the Massive Protostellar System NGC6334I-MM1: Emergence of Strong 6.7 GHz Methanol Masers
• VLBI study of maser kinematics in high-mass SFRs. I. G16.59-0.05
• A near-IR spectroscopic survey of massive jets towards EGOs
• VLBI study of maser kinematics in high-mass SFRs. II. G23.01-0.41
• Observations of Massive Star Forming Regions with Water Masers: Mid-Infrared Imaging
• The Remarkable Mid-Infrared Jet of Massive Young Stellar Object G35.20-0.74
• Evolutionary study of complex organic molecules in high-mass star-forming regions
• New 9.9-GHz methanol masers
• The VLTI/MIDI survey of massive young stellar objects - Sounding the inner regions around intermediate- and high-mass young stars using mid-infrared interferometry
• The SOFIA Massive (SOMA) Star Formation Survey. I. Overview and First Results
• High resolution observations of 6.7-GHz methanol masers with the LBA
• Accretion Signatures from Massive Young Stellar Objects
• Investigating the Nature of the Dust Emission around Massive Protostar NGC 7538 IRS 1: Circumstellar Disk and Outflow?
• In Search of Circumstellar Disks Around Young Massive Stars
• The Arecibo Methanol Maser Galactic Plane Survey-IV: Accurate Astrometry and Source Morphologies
• Observations of 6.7 GHz Methanol Masers with EAVN I: VLBI Images of the first Epoch of Observations
• A multiple system of high-mass YSOs surrounded by disks in NGC7538 IRS1
• Associations of water and methanol masers at milli-arcsec angular resolution in two high-mass young stellar objects
• Hot high-mass accretion disk candidates
• Rotating and infalling motion around the high-mass young stellar object Cepheus A-HW2 observed with the methanol maser at 6.7 GHz
• SiO Outflow Signatures Toward Massive Young Stellar Objects with Linearly Distributed Methanol Masers
• Periodic Flare of the 6.7 GHz Methanol Maser in IRAS22198+6336
• The Complex Mid-Infrared Structure at the Heart of IRAS 20126+4104
• Parallaxes of 6.7-GHz Methanol Masers towards the G305.2 High-Mass Star Formation Region
• Structure of W3(OH) from Very High Spectral Resolution Observations of 5 Centimeter OH Masers
• The First Very Long Baseline Interferometry Image of 44 GHz Methanol Maser with the KVN and VERA Array (KaVA)
• A Double-Jet System in the G31.41+0.31 Hot Molecular Core
• A Synchronized Variation of the 6.7 GHz Methanol Maser in Cepheus A
• The SOFIA Massive (SOMA) Star Formation Survey. II. High Luminosity Protostars
• A general catalogue of 6.7GHz methanol masers II: statistical analysis
• Outflows and Massive Stars in the protocluster IRAS 05358+3543
• The polarization of mm methanol masers
• ALMA observations of the Extended Green Object G19.01$-$0.03: I. A Keplerian disc in a massive protostellar system
• Mopra Observations of G305.2+0.2: Massive Star Formation at Different Evolutionary Stages?
• EVN observations of 6.7-GHz methanol maser polarization in massive star-forming regions II. First statistical results
• Embedded Stellar Populations towards Young Massive Star Formation Regions I. G305.2+0.2
• Testing the Evolutionary Sequence of High Mass Protostars with CARMA
• Testing the Hypothesis that Methanol Maser Rings Trace Circumstellar Disks: High Resolution Near-IR and Mid-IR Imaging
• Revising the kinematics of 12GHz CH3OH masers in W3(OH)
• A differentially rotating disc in a high-mass protostellar system
• NGC7538 IRS1 -- an O star driving an ionized jet and giant N-S outflow
• Probing the magnetic fields of massive star forming regions with methanol maser polarisation
• On the massive young stellar object AFGL4176: High-spatial-resolution multi-wavelength observations and modeling
• High Resolution Mid-Infrared Imaging of Radio Ultra-Compact HII Regions
• Masers and star formation
• Internal Motion of 6.7-GHz Methanol Masers in H II Region S269
• A misaligned protostellar disk fed by gas streamers in a barred spiral-like massive dense core
• Non-thermal Radio Emission from Massive Protostars in the SARAO MeerKAT Galactic Plane Survey
• Milliarcsecond structure of water maser emission in two young high-mass stellar objects associated with methanol masers
• Molecular complexity on disk-scales uncovered by ALMA: The chemical composition of the high-mass protostar AFGL 4176
• Recent Developments in Maser Theory
• The infrared environments of masers associated with star formation