The last stand before MAP: cosmological parameters from lensing, CMB and galaxy clustering

Abstract

Cosmic shear measurements have now improved to the point where they deserve to be treated on par with CMB and galaxy clustering data for cosmological parameter analysis, using the full measured aperture mass variance curve rather than a mere phenomenological parametrization thereof. We perform a detailed 9-parameter analysis of recent lensing (RCS), CMB (up to Archeops) and galaxy clustering (2dF) data, both separately and jointly. CMB and 2dF data are consistent with a simple flat adiabatic scale-invariant model with Omega_Lambda=0.72+/-0.09, omega_cdm=0.115+/- 0.013, omega_b=0.024+/-0.003, and a hint of reionization around z~8. Lensing helps further tighten these constraints, but reveals tension regarding the power spectrum normalization: including the RCS survey results raises sigma8 significantly and forces other parameters to uncomfortable values. Indeed, sigma8 is emerging as the currently most controversial cosmological parameter, and we discuss possible resolutions of this sigma8 problem. We also comment on the disturbing fact that many recent analyses (including this one) obtain error bars smaller than the Fisher matrix bound. We produce a CMB power spectrum combining all existing experiments, and using it for a "MAP versus world" comparison next month will provide a powerful test of how realistic the error estimates have been in the cosmology community.

Added references and Fisher error discussion. Combined CMB data, window and covariance matrix for January "MAP vs World" contest at http://www.hep.upenn.edu/~max/cmblsslens.html or from [email protected]

References in corpus (87)

• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Technical Summary
• Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Spectra and redshifts
• The Cosmic Triangle: Revealing the State of the Universe
• Karhunen-Loeve eigenvalue problems in cosmology: how should we tackle large data sets?
• Evidence for Reionization at z ~ 6: Detection of a Gunn-Peterson Trough in a z=6.28 Quasar
• Power Spectra for Cold Dark Matter and its Variants
• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Angular Power Spectrum
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: The power spectrum and the matter content of the universe
• Nonlinear evolution of cosmological power spectra
• Reconstructing the linear power spectrum of cosmological mass fluctuations
• Mass Reconstruction with CMB Polarization
• Detection of weak gravitational lensing distortions of distant galaxies by cosmic dark matter at large scales
• Detection of Weak Gravitational Lensing by Large-scale Structure
• Cosmology from Maxima-1, Boomerang and COBE/DMR CMB Observations
• The PSCz Catalogue
• Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis Predictions for Precision Cosmology
• COBE, Gravitational Waves, Inflation and Extended Inflation
• Cosmic Confusion: Degeneracies among Cosmological Parameters Derived from Measurements of Microwave Background Anisotropies
• A new measure for cosmic shear
• First Estimations of Cosmological Parameters From BOOMERANG
• The Anisotropy of the Microwave Background to l = 3500: Deep Field Observations with the Cosmic Background Imager
• Cosmic Complementarity: Joint Parameter Estimation from CMB Experiments and Redshift Surveys
• Cosmological Model Predictions for Weak Lensing: Linear and Nonlinear Regimes
• Cosmological Parameter Extraction from the First Season of Observations with DASI
• Measuring ${\Omega }_m$ with the ROSAT Deep Cluster Survey
• The Anisotropy of the Microwave Background to l = 3500: Mosaic Observations with the Cosmic Background Imager
• Evidence for a non-zero Lambda and a low matter density from a combined analysis of the 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey and Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies
• Constraining the equation of state of the Universe from Distant Type Ia Supernovae and Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies
• Cosmological implications of the MAXIMA-I high resolution Cosmic Microwave Background anisotropy measurement
• Reionization of Hydrogen and Helium by Early Stars and Quasars
• CMB Observables and Their Cosmological Implications
• Constraints on Omega_m, Omega_L, and Sigma_8, from Galaxy Cluster Redshift Distributions
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: The amplitudes of fluctuations in the 2dFGRS and the CMB, and implications for galaxy biasing
• Cosmological Parameters from Cosmic Background Imager Observations and Comparisons with BOOMERANG, DASI, and MAXIMA
• Cosmic Shear Statistics and Cosmology
• The Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy Power Spectrum measured by Archeops
• Constraints on reionization from the thermal history of the intergalactic medium
• Constraints on Omega_m and sigma_8 from weak lensing in RCS fields
• Power spectrum normalization from the local abundance of rich clusters of galaxies
• The shear power spectrum from the COMBO-17 survey
• The power spectrum of galaxies in the 2dF 100k redshift survey
• The REFLEX Galaxy Cluster Survey VII: Omega_m and sigma_8 from cluster abundance and large-scale clustering
• Cosmological constraints from the local X-ray luminosity function of the most X-ray luminous galaxy clusters
• Efficient Cosmological Parameter Estimation from Microwave Background Anisotropies
• Is cosmology consistent?
• Weak Lensing: Prospects for Measuring Cosmological Parameters
• Non-Linear Cluster Lens Reconstruction
• Likelihood Analysis of Cosmic Shear on Simulated and VIRMOS-DESCART Data
• Probing the Reionization History of the Universe using the Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization
• Separating the Early Universe from the Late Universe: cosmological parameter estimation beyond the black box
• On determining the cluster abundance normalization
• Towards a refined cosmic concordance model: joint 11-parameter constraints from CMB and large-scale structure
• Joint Cosmic Shear Measurements with the Keck and William Herschel Telescopes
• Detection of correlated galaxy ellipticities on CFHT data: first evidence for gravitational lensing by large-scale structures
• Current cosmological constraints from a 10 parameter CMB analysis
• Cluster abundance normalization from observed mass-temperature relation
• Cosmic Shear and Power Spectrum Normalization with the Hubble Space Telescope
• New CMB constraints on the cosmic matter budget: trouble for nucleosynthesis?
• Constraining the Matter Power Spectrum Normalization using the SDSS/RASS and REFLEX Cluster surveys
• Power Spectra Estimation for Weak Lensing
• First results from the Very Small Array -- III. The CMB power spectrum
• Current status of weak gravitational lensing
• The precision of slow-roll predictions for the CMBR anisotropies
• Formulae for Growth Factors In Expanding Universes Containing Matter and a Cosmological Constant
• Detection of He II reionization in the SDSS quasar sample
• The Amplitude of Mass Fluctuations
• Characterizing the Peak in the CMB Angular Power Spectrum
• Mapping the CMB III: combined analysis of QMAP flights
• The Case for Omega_M = 0.33 +/- 0.035
• Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy Window Functions Revisited
• New Constraints on inflation from the Cosmic Microwave Background
• First results from the Very Small Array -- IV. Cosmological parameter estimation
• Constraints on inflation from CMB and Lyman-alpha forest
• Cosmological Parameters from Velocities, CMB and Supernovae
• On the density of Cold Dark Matter
• New CMBR data and the cosmic neutrino background
• Constraints on Cosmological Parameters from the Lyman-alpha Forest Power Spectrum and COBE-DMR
• CMB Constraints on a Baryonic Dark Matter-Dominated Universe
• Cosmological Constraints from a Combined Analysis of the Cluster Mass Function and Microwave Background Anisotropies
• Nonlinear Stochastic Biasing of Peaks and Halos: Scale-Dependence, Time-Evolution, and Redshift-Space Distortion from Cosmological N-body Simulations
• Constraints on Omega_B, Omega_m and h from MAXIMA and BOOMERANG
• The Inflationary Gravity Waves in light of recent Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies data
• Mutual Constraints Between Reionization Models and Parameter Extraction From Cosmic Microwave Background Data
• Cosmological parameters from complementary observations of the Universe
• Cosmological parameters from large scale structure observations

Cited by in corpus (39)

• Cosmological parameters from SDSS and WMAP
• The 3D power spectrum of galaxies from the SDSS
• Planck 2018 results. I. Overview and the cosmological legacy of Planck
• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• Primordial Nucleosynthesis for the New Cosmology: Determining Uncertainties and Examining Concordance
• Large Scale Structure in Bekenstein's theory of relativistic Modified Newtonian Dynamics
• Cosmological viable f(R,T) dark energy model: dynamics and stability
• The Dark Universe
• Cosmological mass limits on neutrinos, axions, and other light particles
• WMAPping inflationary physics
• Reconstructing the primordial power spectrum - a new algorithm
• Upper limits on neutrino masses from the 2dFGRS and WMAP: the role of priors
• Constraints on the coupled quintessence from cosmic microwave background anisotropy and matter power spectrum
• Neutrino Masses from Cosmological Probes
• Constraints on isocurvature models from the WMAP first-year data
• The initial conditions of the universe: how much isocurvature is allowed?
• A STIS Survey for OVI Absorption Systems at 0.12 < z < 0.5 I.: The Statistical Properties of Ionized Gas
• Temperature and polarization angular power spectra of Galactic dust radiation at 353 GHz as measured by Archeops
• Weak Lensing and CMB: Parameter forecasts including a running spectral index
• Inflationary potentials yielding constant scalar perturbation spectral indices
• Probing decisive answers to dark energy questions from cosmic complementarity and lensing tomography
• The galaxy cluster X-ray luminosity--gravitational mass relation in the light of the WMAP 3rd year data
• Spectroscopic source redshifts and parameter constraints from weak lensing and CMB
• Undulant Universe
• BeyondPlanck I. Global Bayesian analysis of the Planck Low Frequency Instrument data
• Measuring the geometry of the Universe in the presence of isocurvature modes
• The statistics of voids as a tool to constrain cosmological parameters: sigma_8 and Omega_m h
• Exploring the Gamma Ray Horizon with the next generation of Gamma Ray Telescopes. Part 1: Theoretical predictions
• MAXIMA: A Balloon-Borne Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy Experiment
• Observational Constraints on Undulant Cosmologies
• Statistical characteristics of observed Ly-$\alpha$ forest and the shape of initial power spectrum
• Cosmology and neutrino masses - an update
• Statistical characteristics of observed Ly-$\alpha$ forest and the shape of linear power spectrum
• Degree-scale anomalies in the CMB: localizing the first peak dip to a small patch of the north ecliptic sky
• Exploring the Gamma Ray Horizon with the next generation of Gamma Ray Telescopes. Part 3: Optimizing the observation schedule of gamma-ray sources for the extraction of cosmological parameters
• Cosmological constraints from Microwave Background Anisotropy and Polarization
• Weighing Neutrinos with Large-Scale Structure
• Testing the CMB Data for Systematic Effects
• Neutrino physics from Cosmology