Not Earth-like Yet Temperate? More Generic Climate Feedback Configurations Still Allow Temperate Climates in Habitable Zone Exo-Earth Candidates

Abstract

Earth's climate is influenced by over a dozen feedbacks, but only three dominate its long-term climate behavior. Models of the exoplanet habitable zone (HZ) assume that this is similar for other Earth-like planets. We used dynamical simulations to study Earth-like planets with a fourth, (potentially strong) generalized climate feedback. Across over 20,000 climate simulations, we find that the addition of the fourth feedback produces novel behaviors, including runaway and chaotic climate trajectories, that are more diverse than one would expect based on Earth's climate configuration. Non-negligible fourth feedbacks -- if negative -- would not lessen the probability of planets with temperate climates. However, positive fourth feedbacks decrease the fraction of exo-Earth candidates that are long-term habitable. Therefore, strong fourth feedbacks will alter (and mostly shrink) the boundaries of the classical habitable zone. When combined with occurrence rates of Earth-sized planets around sun-like stars, our results imply that the fraction of stars hosting rocky planets with temperate climates may be substantially lower than classical estimates under Earth-like climate assumptions. Our results are subject to the validity of the model assumptions and not intended to represent conclusive predictions about exoplanet populations but rather to demonstrate the potential climate diversity that emerges from non-Earth-like model configurations. Our conclusions provide context on sample sizes and science questions for next-generation exoplanet surveys.

29 pages, 16 figures, accepted for publication in the Planetary Science Journal

References in corpus (38)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• Recurrence Plots for the Analysis of Complex Systems
• Habitable Zones Around Main-Sequence Stars: New Estimates
• Extreme Water Loss and Abiotic O${}_2$ Buildup On Planets Throughout the Habitable Zones of M Dwarfs
• The Compositional Diversity of Extrasolar Terrestrial Planets: I. In-Situ Simulations
• Gliese 581d is the first discovered terrestrial-mass exoplanet in the habitable zone
• The cosmic shoreline: the evidence that escape determines which planets have atmospheres, and what this may mean for Proxima Centauri b
• Large Interferometer For Exoplanets (LIFE): I. Improved exoplanet detection yield estimates for a large mid-infrared space-interferometer mission
• The Different Evolution of Gas and Dust in Disks around Sun-like and Cool Stars
• Photochemistry in Terrestrial Exoplanet Atmospheres III: Photochemistry and Thermochemistry in Thick Atmospheres on Super Earths and Mini Neptunes
• Disequilibrium biosignatures over Earth history and implications for detecting exoplanet life
• Whole planet coupling between climate, mantle, and core: Implications for the evolution of rocky planets
• Climate Stability of Habitable Earth-like Planets
• Climate of Earth-like planets with high obliquity and eccentric orbits: implications for habitability conditions
• A Probabilistic Approach to Kepler Completeness and Reliability for Exoplanet Occurrence Rates
• Transitions across Melancholia States in a Climate Model: Reconciling the Deterministic and Stochastic Points of View
• Limit cycles can reduce the width of the habitable zone
• The runaway greenhouse radius inflation effect - An observational diagnostic to probe water on Earth-size planets and test the Habitable Zone concept
• Thermodynamic Analysis of Snowball Earth Hysteresis Experiment: Efficiency, Entropy Production, and Irreversibility
• No snowball on habitable tidally locked planets
• A Statistical Comparative Planetology Approach to the Hunt for Habitable Exoplanets and Life Beyond the Solar System
• The Compositional Diversity of Low-Mass Exoplanets
• Rotational Variability of Earth's Polar Regions: Implications for Detecting Snowball Planets
• Gaian bottlenecks and planetary habitability maintained by evolving model biospheres: The ExoGaia model
• Bioverse: A Comprehensive Assessment of the Capabilities of Extremely Large Telescopes to Probe Earth-like O${}_2$ Levels in Nearby Transiting Habitable Zone Exoplanets
• Analytical investigation of the decrease in the size of the habitable zone due to limited CO${}_2$ outgassing rate
• A Thousand Earths: A Very Large Aperture, Ultralight Space Telescope Array for Atmospheric Biosignature Surveys
• Super-Earths and Earth-like Exoplanets
• Habitability and Multistability in Earth-like Planets
• The Demographics of Kepler's Earths and super-Earths into the Habitable Zone
• The impact of stripped cores on the frequency of Earth-size planets in the habitable zone
• GCM Simulations of Unstable Climates in the Habitable Zone
• Habitable Snowballs: Temperate Land Conditions, Liquid Water, and Implications for CO${}_2$ Weathering
• The direct imaging search for Earth 2.0: Quantifying biases and planetary false positives
• The Sparse Atmospheric MOdel Sampling Analysis (SAMOSA) intercomparison: Motivations and protocol version 1.0. A CUISINES model intercomparison project
• A Gaian Habitable Zone
• How likely are Snowball episodes near the inner edge of the habitable zone?
• Robustness of Gaian Feedbacks to Climate Perturbations

Cited by in corpus (1)

• When Stabilizing Feedbacks Wreak Havoc in Habitable Planets: Chaos at the Freezing Point in a Four-Feedback Climate Model