Cross Calibration of Galaxy Cluster Temperatures Measured with NuSTAR, XMM-Newton, and Chandra

Abstract

The use of galaxy clusters to constrain cosmology is limited in part due to uncertainties in derived cluster masses, which often depend on the gas temperature. Unfortunately, there exists a longstanding discrepancy in temperature measurements of the same galaxy clusters made by the two most sensitive X-ray observatories, Chandra and XMM-Newton. The NuSTAR X-ray Observatory's greater sensitivity to the exponential turnover in the bremsstrahlung continuum allows for more precise and potentially more accurate galaxy cluster temperature estimates, especially given its unique ability to independently calibrate its optics in orbit. We present new NuSTAR spectra of 10 relaxed clusters ($5\mathrm{keV}<kT<10\mathrm{keV}$), extracted from identical regions as previous spectra from Chandra and XMM-Newton. The 3--20~keV spectra are well fit by single temperature models, and fits done in narrower bandpasses provide no clear evidence in support of the existence of multi temperature gas. We find NuSTAR temperatures are typically $\sim 15\%$ higher than XMM-Newton temperatures. In contrast, good agreement is found between NuSTAR and Chandra temperatures for clusters with $kT\lesssim 7\mathrm{keV}$, with Chandra measurements exceeding NuSTAR's in hotter systems. When more clusters are included, the trend is reinforced and can be extended to higher temperatures. A generic increase to Chandra's $E>2\mathrm{keV}$ effective area ($\sim 5\%$ at 5~keV) is found to explain the trend reasonably well. These results demonstrate the potential for NuSTAR data to address the two-decade-old temperature discrepancy between Chandra and XMM-Newton.

17 pages, 9 figures

References in corpus (15)

• NuSTAR Observations of the Bullet Cluster: Constraints on Inverse Compton Emission
• XMM-Newton and Chandra Cross Calibration Using HIFLUGCS Galaxy Clusters: Systematic Temperature Differences and Cosmological Impact
• The SRG/eROSITA all-sky survey: Cosmology constraints from cluster abundances in the western Galactic hemisphere
• A NuSTAR observation of the center of the Coma Cluster
• Hydrostatic mass estimates of massive galaxy clusters: a study with varying hydrodynamics flavours and non-thermal pressure support
• The XXL survey: XLVI. Forward cosmological analysis of the C1 cluster sample
• Tracing the non-thermal pressure and hydrostatic bias in galaxy clusters
• The SRG/eROSITA All-Sky Survey: SRG/eROSITA cross-calibration with Chandra and XMM-Newton using galaxy cluster gas temperatures
• CHEX-MATE: Characterization of the intra-cluster medium temperature distribution
• Soft and hard X-ray excess emission in Abell 3112 observed with Chandra
• A Systematic Comparison of Galaxy Cluster Temperatures Measured with NuSTAR and Chandra
• Hydrostatic Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters in the eROSITA Survey
• The NuSTAR and Chandra view of CL 0217+70 and Its Tell-Tale Radio Halo
• Constraining Ultra-light Axions with Galaxy Cluster Number Counts
• The NuSTAR View of Perseus: the ICM and a Peculiar Hard Excess