Chemotaxing E. coli do not count single molecules
arXiv:2407.07264 · doi:10.1038/s41567-025-03111-4
Abstract
Organisms use specialized sensors to measure their environments, but the fundamental principles that determine their accuracy remain largely unknown. In Escherichia coli chemotaxis, we previously found that gradient-climbing speed is bounded by the amount of information that cells acquire from their environment, and that E. coli operate near this bound. However, it remains unclear what prevents them from acquiring more information. Past work argued that E. coli's chemosensing is limited by the physics of molecules stochastically arriving at cells' receptors, without direct evidence. Here, we show instead that E. coli are far from this physical limit. To show this, we develop a theoretical approach that uses information rates to quantify how accurately behaviorally-relevant signals can be estimated from available observations: molecule arrivals for the physical limit; chemotaxis signaling activity for E. coli. Measuring these information rates in single-cell experiments across multiple background concentrations, we find that E. coli encode two orders of magnitude less information than the physical limit. Thus, E. coli chemosensing is limited by internal noise in signal processing rather than the physics of molecule diffusion, motivating investigation of what specific physical and biological constraints shaped the evolution of this prototypical sensory system.
27 pages of main text, 4 figures, 43 pages of supplement + supplementary figures
References in corpus (18)
- Measuring Information Transfer
- Optimal decoding of information from a genetic network
- Maximum likelihood and the single receptor
- E. coli chemotaxis is information-limited
- Limits of sensing temporal concentration changes by single cells
- The Bacterial Chemotactic Response Reflects a Compromise Between Transient and Steady State Behavior
- Non-genetic diversity modulates population performance
- Bacteria push the limits of chemotactic precision to navigate dynamic chemical gradients
- Optimal Prediction by Cellular Signaling Networks
- The free energy cost of reducing noise while maintaining a high sensitivity
- Landauer in the age of synthetic biology: energy consumption and information processing in biochemical networks
- Physical limit to concentration sensing in a changing environment
- Feedback Between Motion and Sensation Provides Nonlinear Boost in Run-and-tumble Navigation
- Physical Limits on Bacterial Navigation in Dynamic Environments
- Physical constraints in intracellular signaling: the cost of sending a bit
- Know the single-receptor sensing limit? Think again
- Resolving the binding-kinase discrepancy in bacterial chemotaxis: A nonequilibrium allosteric model and the role of energy dissipation
- Time-reversal symmetry breaking in the chemosensory array reveals mechanisms for dissipation-enhanced cooperative sensing