The spectral evolution of white dwarfs: where do we stand?

Abstract

White dwarfs are the dense, burnt-out remnants of the vast majority of stars, condemned to cool over billions of years as they steadily radiate away their residual thermal energy. To first order, their atmosphere is expected to be made purely of hydrogen due to the efficient gravitational settling of heavier elements. However, observations reveal a much more complex situation, as the surface of a white dwarf (1) can be dominated by helium rather than hydrogen, (2) can be polluted by trace chemical species, and (3) can undergo significant composition changes with time. This indicates that various mechanisms of element transport effectively compete against gravitational settling in the stellar envelope. This phenomenon is known as the spectral evolution of white dwarfs and has important implications for Galactic, stellar, and planetary astrophysics. This invited review provides a comprehensive picture of our current understanding of white dwarf spectral evolution. We first describe the latest observational constraints on the variations in atmospheric composition along the cooling sequence, covering both the dominant and trace constituents. We then summarise the predictions of state-of-the-art models of element transport in white dwarfs and assess their ability to explain the observed spectral evolution. Finally, we highlight remaining open questions and suggest avenues for future work.

arXiv commentInvited review published in the '2023 Astronomy Prize Awardees Collection' of Astrophysics and Space Science; accepted version following peer review

References in corpus (210)

• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Technical Summary
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• The Gaia mission
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Gaia Data Release 3: Summary of the content and survey properties
• The Galaxy Evolution Explorer: A Space Ultraviolet Survey Mission
• The Formation Rate, Mass and Luminosity Functions of DA White Dwarfs from the Palomar Green Survey
• Are There Unstable Planetary Systems Around White Dwarfs?
• An Improved Spectroscopic Analysis of DA White Dwarfs from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 4
• The frequency of planetary debris around young white dwarfs
• A $Gaia$ Data Release 2 catalogue of white dwarfs and a comparison with SDSS
• Evolutionary and pulsational properties of white dwarf stars
• Photometric and Spectroscopic Analysis of Cool White Dwarfs with Trigonometric Parallax Measurements
• A Comprehensive Spectroscopic Analysis of DB White Dwarfs
• Ancient planetary systems are orbiting a large fraction of white dwarf stars
• A Spectroscopic Survey & Analysis of Bright, Hydrogen-Rich White Dwarfs
• The Chemical Composition of an Extrasolar Minor Planet
• A catalogue of white dwarfs in Gaia EDR3
• On the Spectral Evolution of Hot White Dwarf Stars. I. A Detailed Model-Atmosphere Analysis of Hot White Dwarfs from SDSS DR12
• The White Dwarf Initial-Final Mass Relation for Progenitor Stars From 0.85 to 7.5 M${}_{\odot }$
• The Element Abundances in Bare Planetary Nebula Central Stars and the Shell Burning in AGB Stars
• Accretion and diffusion in white dwarfs. New diffusion timescales and applications to GD362 and G29-38
• Circumstellar Debris and Pollution at White Dwarf Stars
• New cooling sequences for old white dwarfs
• J-PLUS: The Javalambre Photometric Local Universe Survey
• The formation and evolution of hydrogen-deficient post-AGB white dwarfs: the emerging chemical profile and the expectations for the PG1159-DB-DQ evolutionary connection
• A white dwarf cooling age of 8 Gyr for NGC 6791 from physical separation processes
• Know Your Neighborhood: A Detailed Model Atmosphere Analysis of Nearby White Dwarfs
• Chemical Abundances in the Externally Polluted White Dwarf GD 40: Evidence of a Rocky Extrasolar Minor Planet
• Evidence for Water in the Rocky Debris of a Disrupted Extrasolar Minor Planet
• The White Dwarf Cooling Sequence of NGC6397
• On the Spectral Evolution of Cool, Helium-Atmosphere White Dwarfs: Detailed Spectroscopic and Photometric Analysis of DZ Stars
• On the Measurement of Fundamental Parameters of White Dwarfs in the Gaia Era
• Elemental Compositions of Two Extrasolar Rocky Planetesimals
• Rare White dwarf stars with carbon atmospheres
• Cool DZ white dwarfs II: Compositions and evolution of old remnant planetary systems
• The Ages of the Thin Disk, Thick Disk, and the Halo from Nearby White Dwarfs
• Toward ensemble asteroseismology of ZZ Ceti stars with fully evolutionary models
• The Gaia 20 pc white dwarf sample
• The 100 pc White Dwarf Sample in the SDSS Footprint
• A White Dwarf catalogue from Gaia-DR2 and the Virtual Observatory
• Detailed Spectroscopic and Photometric Analysis of DQ White Dwarfs
• Evolution on the AGB and beyond: On the formation of H-deficient post-AGB stars
• A cooling anomaly of high-mass white dwarfs
• Current challenges in the physics of white dwarf stars
• An aluminum/calcium-rich, iron-poor, white dwarf star: evidence for an extrasolar planetary lithosphere?
• The Chemical Composition of an Extrasolar Kuiper-Belt-Object
• The accretion-diffusion scenario for metals in cool white dwarfs
• Detailed compositional analysis of the heavily polluted DBZ white dwarf SDSS J073842.56+183509.06: A window on planet formation?
• Analysis of Helium-Rich White Dwarfs Polluted by Heavy Elements in the Gaia Era
• White dwarf and subdwarf stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 14
• Full evolutionary models for PG1159 stars. Implications for the helium-rich O(He) stars
• An Empirical Measurement of the Initial-Final Mass Relation with Gaia White Dwarfs
• $Gaia$ white dwarfs within 40 pc II: the volume-limited northern hemisphere sample
• The Discovery of the Most Metal-Rich White Dwarf: Composition of a Tidally Disrupted Extrasolar Dwarf Planet
• Likely detection of water-rich asteroid debris in a metal-polluted white dwarf
• Polluted White Dwarfs: Constraints on the Origin and Geology of Exoplanetary Material
• Two Beyond-Primitive Extrasolar Planetesimals
• Hot DQ White Dwarfs: Something Different
• Rocky Extrasolar Planetary Compositions Derived from Externally-Polluted White Dwarfs
• Measurements of Physical Parameters of White Dwarfs: A Test of the Mass-Radius Relation
• DB white dwarfs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 10 and 12
• Fundamental parameter accuracy of DA and DB white dwarfs in Gaia Data Release 2
• Cool DZ white dwarfs I: Identification and spectral analysis
• The Age of the Milky Way Inner Halo
• The Ratio of Helium- to Hydrogen-Atmosphere White Dwarfs: Direct Evidence for Convective Mixing
• Gaia Data Release 3: The Galaxy in your preferred colours. Synthetic photometry from Gaia low-resolution spectra
• White Dwarf Cosmochronology in the Solar Neighborhood
• Hydrogen delivery onto white dwarfs from remnant exo-Oort cloud comets
• New evolutionary calculations for the Born Again scenario
• The 40 pc sample of white dwarfs from Gaia
• Possible Signs of Water and Differentiation in a Rocky Exoplanetary Body
• Hot DB White Dwarfs from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• A New Generation of Cool White Dwarf Atmosphere Models. IV. Revisiting the Spectral Evolution of Cool White Dwarfs
• Accretion of a Terrestrial-Like Minor Planet by a White Dwarf
• Compositions of Planetary Debris around Dusty White Dwarfs
• On the Spectral Evolution of Helium-Atmosphere White Dwarfs Showing Traces of Hydrogen
• New evolutionary sequences for hot H-deficient white dwarfs on the basis of a full account of progenitor evolution
• Two Extrasolar Asteroids with Low Volatile-Element Mass Fractions
• Interpretation and diversity of exoplanetary material orbiting white dwarfs
• ${}^{22}$Ne Phase Separation As A Solution To The Ultramassive White Dwarf Cooling Anomaly
• New white dwarf envelope models and diffusion. Application to DQ white dwarfs
• The Survival of Water within Extrasolar Minor Planets
• Thick to Thin: The Evolutionary Connection Between PG 1159 Stars and the Thin Helium-Enveloped Pulsating White Dwarf GD 358
• Rocky Planetesimals as the Origin of Metals in DZ Stars
• The Canada-France Imaging Survey: Reconstructing the Milky Way Star Formation History from its White Dwarf Population
• Trace hydrogen in helium atmosphere white dwarfs as a possible signature of water accretion
• Evidence for an external origin of heavy elements in hot DA white dwarfs
• Mass-loss and diffusion in subdwarf B stars and hot white dwarfs: do weak winds exist?
• The effect of ${}^{22}$Ne diffusion in the evolution and pulsational properties of white dwarfs with solar metallicity progenitors
• Calibration of the Mixing-Length Theory for Convective White Dwarf Envelopes
• Heavy element abundance patterns in hot DA white dwarfs
• Multiple channels for the onset of magnetism in isolated white dwarfs
• Convective Overshoot and Macroscopic Diffusion in Pure-Hydrogen Atmosphere White Dwarfs
• Fe emission and ionized excess absorption in the luminous quasar 3C109 with XMM-Newton
• Are exoplanetesimals differentiated?
• Spectral classification of the 100 pc white dwarf population from Gaia-DR3 and the Virtual Observatory
• The updated BaSTI stellar evolution models and isochrones. III. White Dwarfs
• A Photometric and Spectroscopic Investigation of the DB White Dwarf Population using SDSS and Gaia Data
• The Solar Neighborhood. XXXIX. Parallax Results from the CTIOPI and NOFS Programs: 50 New Members of the 25 Parsec White Dwarf Sample
• An ultra-massive white dwarf with a mixed hydrogen-carbon atmosphere as a likely merger remnant
• Cool DZ white dwarfs in the SDSS
• A Spectroscopic Analysis of White Dwarfs in the Kiso Survey
• The virtual observatory service TheoSSA: Establishing a database of synthetic stellar flux standards. I. NLTE spectral analysis of the DA-type white dwarf G 191-B2B
• On helium-dominated stellar evolution: the mysterious role of the O(He)-type stars
• Accretion from debris disks onto white dwarfs : Fingering (thermohaline) instability and derived accretion rates
• $\text{Gaia}$ white dwarfs within 40 pc III: spectroscopic observations of new candidates in the southern hemisphere
• Evolutionary sequences for hydrogen-deficient white dwarfs
• Polluted White Dwarfs: Mixing Regions and Diffusion Timescales
• New DQ white dwarfs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR4: confirmation of two sequences
• Planetary Systems Around White Dwarfs
• White dwarf pollution by hydrated planetary remnants: Hydrogen and Metals in WD J204713.76-125908.9
• Alkali metals in white dwarf atmospheres as tracers of ancient planetary crusts
• Solar Abundances of Rock Forming Elements, Extreme Oxygen and Hydrogen in a Young Polluted White Dwarf
• Pure-hydrogen 3D model atmospheres of cool white dwarfs
• From Hydrogen to Helium: The Spectral Evolution of White Dwarfs as Evidence for Convective Mixing
• A Spectro-photometric Analysis of Cool White Dwarfs in the Gaia and Pan-STARRS Footprint
• Discovery of Beryllium in White Dwarfs Polluted by Planetesimal Accretion
• Carbon-rich (DQ) white dwarfs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Spectral analyses of eighteen hot H-deficient (pre-) white dwarfs from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 4
• The star formation history in the solar neighborhood as told by massive white dwarfs
• 3D spectroscopic analysis of helium-line white dwarfs
• Discovery of photospheric argon in very hot central stars of planetary nebulae and white dwarfs
• Evolution of DA white dwarfs in the context of a new theory of convection
• Buoyant crystals halt the cooling of white dwarf stars
• Bayesian constraints on the origin and geology of exo-planetary material using a population of externally polluted white dwarfs
• Cold giant planets evaporated by hot white dwarfs
• Increases to Inferred Rates of Planetesimal Accretion Due to Thermohaline Mixing in Metal Accreting White Dwarfs
• Evolutionary calculations of carbon dredge-up in helium envelope white dwarfs
• The formation of DA white dwarfs with thin hydrogen envelopes
• On the Spectral Evolution of Hot White Dwarf Stars. III. The PG 1159$-$DO$-$DB$-$DQ Evolutionary Channel Revisited
• Mixing and Overshooting in Surface Convection Zones of DA White Dwarfs: First Results from ANTARES
• Lithium pollution of a white dwarf records the accretion of an extrasolar planetesimal
• Carbon-Oxygen Phase Separation in MESA White Dwarf Models
• Modeling of the Variable Circumstellar Absorption Features of WD 1145+017
• On the Spectral Evolution of Hot White Dwarf Stars. II. Time-dependent Simulations of Element Transport in Evolving White Dwarfs with STELUM
• White dwarf and subdwarf stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 16
• Pure-helium 3D model atmospheres of white dwarfs
• Gaia Reveals Evidence for Merged White Dwarfs
• Equilibrium abundances in hot DA white dwarfs as derived from self-consistent diffusion models I. Analysis of spectroscopic EUVE data
• Calibration of the mixing length theory for structures of helium-dominated atmosphere white dwarfs
• No evidence for a strong decrease of planetesimal accretion in old white dwarfs
• Spectral analysis of ultra-cool white dwarfs polluted by planetary debris
• Stellar laboratories IV. New Ga IV, Ga V, and Ga VI oscillator strengths and the gallium abundance in the hot white dwarfs G191-B2B and RE0503-289
• Stellar laboratories III. New Ba V, Ba VI, and Ba VII oscillator strengths and the barium abundance in the hot white dwarfs G191-B2B and RE0503-289
• Analysis of cool DO-type white dwarfs from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 10
• Variability in Hot Carbon-Dominated Atmosphere (hot DQ) White Dwarfs: Rapid Rotation?
• On the Nature of Ultracool White Dwarfs: Not so Cool Afterall
• Stellar laboratories. VI. New Mo IV - VII oscillator strengths and the molybdenum abundance in the hot white dwarfs G191-B2B and RE0503-289
• New chondritic bodies identified in eight oxygen-bearing white dwarfs
• Spectral analysis of the extremely hot DA white dwarf PG0948+534
• J-PLUS: Spectral evolution of white dwarfs by PDF analysis
• Stellar laboratories. IX. New Se V, Sr IV - VII, Te VI, and I VI oscillator strengths and the Se, Sr, Te, and I abundances in the hot white dwarfs G191-B2B and RE 0503-289
• White dwarf Random Forest classification through Gaia spectral coefficients
• The evolution of carbon-polluted white dwarfs at low effective temperatures
• Local stellar formation history from the 40 pc white dwarf sample
• A Study of Cool White Dwarfs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 12
• GD424 -- a helium-atmosphere white dwarf with a large amount of trace hydrogen in the process of digesting a rocky planetesimal
• Diffusion coefficients in the envelopes of white dwarfs
• Stellar laboratories. VIII. New Zr IV - VII, Xe IV - V, and Xe VII oscillator strengths and the Al, Zr, and Xe abundances in the hot white dwarfs G191-B2B and RE0503-289
• Metal abundances in hot white dwarfs with signatures of a superionized wind
• Carbon dredge-up required to explain the Gaia white dwarf colour-magnitude bifurcation
• A hidden population of white dwarfs with atmospheric carbon traces in the Gaia bifurcation
• Importance of fingering convection for accreting white dwarfs in the framework of full evolutionary calculations: the case of the hydrogen-rich white dwarfs GD133 and G29-38
• Stellar laboratories. VII. New Kr IV - VII oscillator strengths and an improved spectral analysis of the hot, hydrogen-deficient DO-type white dwarf RE0503-289
• A New Generation of Cool White Dwarf Atmosphere Models. III. WD J2356$-$209: Accretion of a Planetesimal with an Unusual Composition
• On the formation of hot DQ white dwarfs
• Cool white dwarfs as standards for infrared observations
• First detection of bromine and antimony in hot stars
• Unusual Abundances from Planetary System Material Polluting the White Dwarf G238-44
• Stellar laboratories II. New Zn IV and Zn V oscillator strengths and their validation in the hot white dwarfs G191-B2B and RE0503-289
• White dwarf spectral type-temperature distribution from Gaia-DR3 and the Virtual Observatory
• Slowly cooling white dwarfs in M13 from stable hydrogen burning
• The double-layered chemical structure in DB white dwarfs
• A Convective Dredge-Up Model as the Origin of Hydrogen in DBA White Dwarfs
• On the Spectral Evolution of Hot White Dwarf Stars. IV. The Diffusion and Mixing of Residual Hydrogen in Helium-rich White Dwarfs
• Photometric variability in a warm, strongly magnetic DQ white dwarf, SDSS J103655.39+652252.2
• On the existence of warm H-rich pulsating white dwarfs
• First discovery of trans-iron elements in a DAO-type white dwarf (BD$-22{}^{\circ }3467$)
• Atmospheric parameters and carbon abundance for hot DB white dwarfs
• Stellar laboratories. V. The Xe VI ultraviolet spectrum and the xenon abundance in the hot DO-type white dwarf RE0503-289
• Radiative Levitation of Silicon in the Atmospheres of Two Hyades DA White Dwarfs
• The non-explosive stellar merging origin of the ultra-massive carbon-rich white dwarfs
• The bright blue side of the night sky: Spectroscopic survey of bright and hot (pre-) white dwarfs
• Spectroscopic Analysis of the DAB White Dwarf PG 1115+166: An Unresolved DA + DB Degenerate Binary
• Heavy element abundances in DAO white dwarfs measured from FUSE data
• Discovery of Spectroscopic Variations in the DAB White Dwarf GD 323
• Search for trans-iron elements in hot, helium-rich white dwarfs with the HST Cosmic Origins Spectrograph
• A rotating white dwarf shows different compositions on its opposite faces
• A comprehensive near and far ultraviolet spectroscopic study of the hot DA white dwarf G191-B2B
• Iron in Hot DA White Dwarfs
• Spectral analysis of cool white dwarfs accreting from planetary systems: from the UV to the optical
• Stellar laboratories. X. New Cu IV - VII oscillator strengths and the first detection of copper and indium in hot white dwarfs
• The Spectral Evolution of Convective Mixing White Dwarfs, the non-DA Gap, and White Dwarf Cosmochronology
• The ubiquity of carbon dredge-up in hydrogen-deficient white dwarfs as revealed by GALEX
• Spectral analyses of DO white dwarfs and PG1159 stars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Evidence of Spectral Evolution on the white dwarf sample from the Gaia Mission
• Complete spectral energy distribution of the hot, helium-rich white dwarf RX J0503.9-2854
• A far-UV survey of three hot, metal-polluted white dwarf stars: WD0455-282, WD0621-376, and WD2211-495
• Missing metals in DQ stars: A simple explanation
• Spectroscopic Analysis of the White Dwarf KUV 02196+2816: A New Unresolved DA+DB Degenerate Binary
• Multiwavelength Observations of the Hot DB Star PG 0112+104
• New simulations of accreting DA white dwarfs: inferring accretion rates from the surface contamination
• A cool, magnetic white dwarf accreting planetary debris
• DQ white-dwarf stars with low C abundance: Possible progenitors
• Detection of cesium in the atmosphere of the hot He-rich white dwarf HD 149499B
• The OmegaWhite Survey for Short-Period Variable Stars IV: Discovery of the warm DQ white dwarf OW J175358.85-310728.9
• Reinterpreting the Polluted White Dwarf SDSS J122859.93+104032.9 in Light of Thermohaline Mixing Models: More Polluting Material from a Larger Orbiting Solid Body
• Missing Metals in DQ Stars; a Compelling Clue to their Origin
• White Dwarf Merger Remnants: The DAQ Subclass

Cited by in corpus (10)

• PEWDD: A database of white dwarfs enriched by exo-planetary material
• A Random Forest spectral classification of the Gaia 500-pc white dwarf population
• Younger age for the oldest magnetic white dwarfs
• A hot white dwarf merger remnant revealed by an ultraviolet detection of carbon
• A primer on the formation and evolution of hydrogen deficient Central Stars of Planetary Nebulæ and Related Objects
• Gaia white dwarfs with infrared excess I. The 100 pc catalogue
• White Dwarf Stars in the Big Data Era
• Double-faced white dwarfs and the magnetic inhibition of convection
• A new code for low-resolution spectral identification of white dwarf binary candidates
• J-PLUS: Understanding outlier white dwarfs in the third data release via dimensionality reduction