Misidentification of Short GRBs as Magnetars in Nearby Galaxies

Abstract

Context. Recent observations of GRB 200415A, a short and very bright pulse of $\gamma$-rays, have been claimed to be an extragalactic magnetar giant flare (MGF) whose proposed host galaxy is the nearby $\mathrm{NGC}253$. However, as the redshift of the transient object was not measured, it is possible that the measured location of the transient on the celestial sphere and the location of the local galaxy merely coincided. Thus, its real progenitor could have been arbitrarily far away, leading possibly to a much larger luminosity of the transient, and leaving the standard model of short gamma-ray bursts (sGRBs), the merger of two compact objects, as an explanation for the observations. Aims. In this study, our aim is to compute the false-alarm rate for the misinterpretation of sGRBs as magnetars in a given observation period. Methods. We simulate synthetic surveys of sGRB observations in a time period of 14 years corresponding to the operation period of the Gamma-ray Burst Monitor (GBM) detector. For all sGRBs that align on the sky with a nearby Local Volume galaxy, we generate realistic data which is folded through the response of the GBM. To identify candidates of sGRBs that may be misinterpreted as magnetars, six selections (spatial, star formation rate, GBM trigger, duration, isotropic energy release, and fluence) are applied to the simulated surveys. Results. In a non-negligible fraction, 15.7 %, of the simulated surveys, we identify at least one sGRB that has the same characteristics as a magnetar giant flare and could be thus misinterpreted as magnetar. Thus, we conclude that the selections that were proposed in previous work to unambiguously identify an extragalactic magnetar giant flare are not sufficient.

arXiv comment14 pages, 15 figures. Submitted to A&A

References in corpus (63)

• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• MultiNest: an efficient and robust Bayesian inference tool for cosmology and particle physics
• X-ray spectral modelling of the AGN obscuring region in the CDFS: Bayesian model selection and catalogue
• The Fermi Gamma-Ray Burst Monitor
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Near Infrared Galaxy Luminosity Functions
• Studies in Astronomical Time Series Analysis. VI. Bayesian Block Representations
• An exceptionally bright flare from SGR1806-20 and the origins of short-duration gamma-ray bursts
• Gamma-Ray Observations of a Giant Flare from The Magnetar SGR 1806-20
• The afterglow of GRB050709 and the nature of the short-hard gamma-ray bursts
• A giant, periodic flare from the soft gamma repeater SGR1900+14
• Discovery of Rapid X-ray Oscillations in the Tail of the SGR 1806-20 Hyperflare
• The rate, luminosity function and time delay of non-Collapsar short GRBs
• The optical afterglow of the short gamma-ray burst GRB 050709
• Discovery of Fast X-ray Oscillations During the 1998 Giant Flare from SGR 1900+14
• Detection with RHESSI of high frequency X-ray oscillations in the tail of the 2004 hyperflare from SGR 1806-20
• Afterglow Observations of Fermi-LAT Gamma-Ray Bursts and the Emerging Class of Hyper-Energetic Events
• The Local Rate and the Progenitor Lifetimes of Short-Hard Gamma-Ray Bursts: Synthesis and Predictions for LIGO
• A Short GRB "No-Host'' Problem? Investigating Large Progenitor Offsets for Short GRBs with Optical Afterglows
• The Fermi GBM Gamma-Ray Burst Catalog: The First Two Years
• A downward revision to the distance of the 1806-20 cluster and associated magnetar from Gemini near-Infrared spectroscopy
• The Fermi GBM Gamma-Ray Burst Spectral Catalog: 10 Years of Data
• The Konus-Wind catalog of gamma-ray bursts with known redshifts. I. Bursts detected in the triggered mode
• Localization of Gamma-Ray Bursts using the Fermi Gamma-Ray Burst Monitor
• A complete sample of bright Swift short Gamma-Ray Bursts
• The BATSE-Swift luminosity and redshift distributions of short-duration GRBs
• Short GRBs at the dawn of the gravitational wave era
• Optical and near-infrared follow-up observations of four Fermi/LAT GRBs : Redshifts, afterglows, energetics and host galaxies
• The redshift and afterglow of the extremely energetic gamma-ray burst GRB 080916C
• An origin in the local Universe for some short gamma-ray bursts
• The Luminosity and Redshift Distributions of Short-Duration GRB
• The first giant flare from SGR 1806-20: observations with the INTEGRAL SPI Anti-Coincidence Shield
• The Fermi GBM gamma-ray burst time-resolved spectral catalog: brightest bursts in the first four years
• A bright gamma-ray flare interpreted as a giant magnetar flare in NGC 253
• On the GBM event seen 0.4 sec after GW 150914
• A Giant Flare from a Soft Gamma Repeater in the Andromeda Galaxy, M31
• On the nature of the 'hostless' short GRBs
• The Multi-Mission Maximum Likelihood framework (3ML)
• On the Possibility of Identification of a Short/Hard Burst GRB 051103 with the Giant Flare from a Soft Gamma Repeater in the M81 Group of Galaxies
• Are all short-hard gamma-ray bursts produced from mergers of compact stellar objects?
• Rapid Spectral Variability of a Giant Flare from a Magnetar in NGC 253
• Short GRBs in old populations: Magnetars from WD-WD mergers
• Identification of a Local Sample of Gamma-Ray Bursts Consistent with a Magnetar Giant Flare Origin
• Observational Prospects for Afterglows of Short Duration Gamma-ray Bursts
• Soft gamma repeaters outside the Local group
• The second Konus-Wind catalog of short gamma-ray bursts
• The Interplanetary Network Supplement to the Fermi GBM Catalog of Cosmic Gamma-Ray Bursts
• A new analysis of the short-duration, hard-spectrum GRB 051103, a possible extragalactic SGR giant flare
• Gemini Spectroscopy of the Short GRB 130603B Afterglow and Host
• Short gamma-ray bursts within 200 Mpc
• GRB 070201: A possible Soft Gamma Ray Repeater in M31
• The short-hard GRB 051103: Observations and implications for its nature
• Rest-frame properties of 32 gamma-ray bursts observed by the Fermi Gamma-Ray Burst Monitor
• A search for giant flares from soft gamma-repeaters in nearby galaxies in the Konus-Wind short burst sample
• On the nature of the short duration GRB 050906
• The ultraluminous GRB 110918A
• Improved Fermi-GBM GRB localizations using BALROG
• The Rate of Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts in the Local Universe
• Search for quasi-periodic signals in magnetar giant flares
• nazgul: A statistical approach to gamma-ray burst localization. Triangulation via non-stationary time-series models
• Popsynth: A generic astrophysical population synthesis framework
• A proposed network of Gamma-ray Burst detectors on the Global Navigation Satellite System Galileo G2
• A Magnetar Flare in the BATSE Catalog?
• Contamination of short GRBs by giant magnetar flares: Significance of downward revision in distance to SGR 1806-20