The Impending Opacity Challenge in Exoplanet Atmospheric Characterization

Abstract

With a new generation of observatories coming online this decade, the process of characterizing exoplanet atmospheres will need to be reinvented. Currently mostly on the instrumental side, characterization bottlenecks will soon stand by the models used to translate spectra into atmospheric properties. Limitations stemming from our stellar and atmospheric models have already been highlighted. Here, we show that the current limitations of the opacity models used to decode exoplanet spectra propagate into an accuracy wall at ~0.5-1.0 dex (i.e., 3 to 10x) on the atmospheric properties, which is an order of magnitude above the precision targeted by JWST Cycle 1 programs and needed for, e.g., meaningful C/O-ratio constraints and biosignatures identification. We perform a sensitivity analysis using nine different opacity models and find that most of the retrievals produce harmonious fits owing to compensations in the form of >5$\sigma$ biases on the derived atmospheric parameters translating in the aforementioned accuracy wall. We suggest a two-tier approach to alleviate this problem involving a new retrieval procedure and guided improvements in opacity data, their standardization and optimal dissemination.

arXiv comment16 Pages, 12 Figures

References in corpus (37)

• emcee: The MCMC Hammer
• ExoMol molecular line lists XXX: a complete high-accuracy line list for water
• petitRADTRANS: a Python radiative transfer package for exoplanet characterization and retrieval
• ExoMol line lists IV: The rotation-vibration spectrum of methane up to 1500 K
• The Transit Light Source Effect: False Spectral Features and Incorrect Densities for M-dwarf Transiting Planets
• PandExo: A Community Tool for Transiting Exoplanet Science with JWST & HST
• Photochemistry in Terrestrial Exoplanet Atmospheres I: Photochemistry Model and Benchmark Cases
• Phosphine Gas in the Cloud Decks of Venus
• Fingering convection and cloudless models for cool brown dwarf atmospheres
• The 2020 release of the ExoMol database: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other hot atmospheres
• An accurate, extensive, and practical line list of methane for the HITEMP database
• ExoMol line lists -- XXXIX. Ro-vibrational molecular line list for CO${}_2$
• ExoCross: a general program for generating spectra from molecular line lists
• Five carbon- and nitrogen-bearing species in a hot giant planet's atmosphere
• A hybrid line list for CH${}_4$ and hot methane continuum
• Evolved Climates and Observational Discriminants for the TRAPPIST-1 Planetary System
• Constraining Exoplanet Mass from Transmission Spectroscopy
• The theory of transmission spectra revisited: a semi-analytical method for interpreting WFC3 data and an unresolved challenge
• Phosphine as a Biosignature Gas in Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Forward modelling and retrievals with PLATON, a fast open source tool
• Effects of a fully 3D atmospheric structure on exoplanet transmission spectra: retrieval biases due to day-night temperature gradients
• Why is it so Cold in Here?: Explaining the Cold Temperatures Retrieved from Transmission Spectra of Exoplanet Atmospheres
• The full infrared spectrum of molecular hydrogen
• Interpreting the photometry and spectroscopy of directly imaged planets: a new atmospheric model applied to beta Pictoris b and SPHERE observations
• Highlights in the Study of Exoplanet Atmospheres
• On degeneracies in retrievals of exoplanetary transmission spectra
• JWST Noise Floor I: Random Error Sources in JWST NIRCam Time Series
• Toward the analysis of JWST exoplanet spectra: Identifying troublesome model parameters
• Photochemistry of Anoxic Abiotic Habitable Planet Atmospheres: Impact of New H${}_2$O Cross-Sections
• Unveiling cloudy exoplanets: the influence of cloud model choices on retrieval solutions
• Information Content Analysis for Selection of Optimal JWST Observing Modes for Transiting Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Effect of Pressure Broadening on Molecular Absorption Cross Sections in Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• An analytical formalism accounting for clouds and other "surfaces" for exoplanet transmission spectroscopy
• The Influence of H2O Pressure Broadening in High Metallicity Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Introduction of water-vapor broadening coefficients and their temperature dependence exponents into the HITRAN database, Part I: CO2, N2O, CO, CH4, O2, NH3, and H2S
• Molecular Simulations for the Spectroscopic Detection of Atmospheric Gases
• The Need for Laboratory Measurements and Ab Initio Studies to Aid Understanding of Exoplanetary Atmospheres

Cited by in corpus (20)

• Retrieving C and O Abundance of HR 8799 c by Combining High- and Low-Resolution Data
• A roadmap for the atmospheric characterization of terrestrial exoplanets with JWST
• Toward Robust Corrections for Stellar Contamination in JWST Exoplanet Transmission Spectra
• A Catalogue of Exoplanet Atmospheric Retrieval Codes
• A 1.55 R${}_{\oplus }$ habitable-zone planet hosted by TOI-715, an M4 star near the ecliptic South Pole
• Data availability and requirements relevant for the Ariel space mission and other exoplanet atmosphere applications
• Origin and extent of the opacity challenge for atmospheric retrievals of WASP-39 b
• Atmospheric carbon depletion as a tracer of water oceans and biomass on temperate terrestrial exoplanets
• High-throughput Quantum Chemistry: Empowering the Search for Molecular Candidates behind Unknown Spectral Signatures in Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• Cloud and Haze Parameterization in Atmospheric Retrievals: Insights from Titan's Cassini Data and JWST Observations of Hot Jupiters
• Ab initio quantum dynamics as a scalable solution to the exoplanet opacity challenge: A case study of CO${}_2$ in hydrogen atmosphere
• The impact of spectral line wing cut-off: Recommended standard method with application to MAESTRO opacity database
• An extended low-density atmosphere around the Jupiter-sized planet WASP-193 b
• Radiative Transfer and Inversion codes for characterizing planetary atmospheres: an overview
• The Detection-vs-Retrieval Challenge: Titan as an Exoplanet
• Knobs and dials of retrieving JWST transmission spectra. II. Impacts of pipeline-level differences on retrieval posteriors
• Measurements and predictions of H2 pressure-broadening coefficients of CO2 absorption lines for exoplanet atmosphere studies
• On the importance of laboratory experiments for interpreting exoplanet observations
• Helium Atmospheres May Hide in Current Exoplanet Analysis Frameworks
• A quadratic-scaling algorithm with guaranteed convergence for quantum coupled-channel calculations