The Streaming Instability Cannot Form Planetesimals from mm-size Grains in Pressure Bumps

Abstract

We present evidence that it is unlikely that the streaming instability (SI) can form planetesimals from mm grains inside axisymmetric pressure bumps. We conducted the largest simulation of the SI so far (7 million CPU hours), consisting of a large slice of the disk with mm grains, a solar-like dust-to-gas ratio ($Z=0.01$), and the largest pressure bump that does not cause gravitational instability (GI) in the particle layer. We used a high resolution of $1000/H$ to resolve as many SI unstable modes as possible. The simulation produced a long-lived particle over-density far exceeding the SI criteria (i.e., a critical solid abundance to headwind parameter ratio $Z/\Pi$) where strong clumping would occur if these conditions were present over an extended region of the disk; yet we observed none. The likely reason is that the time it takes particles to cross the high-$Z/\Pi$ region ($t_{\mathrm{cross}}$) is shorter than the growth timescale of the SI ($t_{\mathrm{grow}}$). We propose an added criterion for planetesimal formation by the SI -- that $t_{\mathrm{cross}}>t_{\mathrm{grow}}$. We show that any bump larger than the one in this run would form planetesimals by the GI instead of the SI. Our results significantly restrict the pathways to planet formation: Either protoplanetary disks regularly form grains larger than 1~mm, or planetesimals do not form by the SI in axisymmetric pressure bumps. Since bumps large enough to induce the GI are likely Rossby-wave unstable, we propose that mm grains may only form planetesimals in vortices.

arXiv comment13 pages, 8 figures, accepted to ApJL. Updated with minor changes to improve clarity with respect to prior works

References in corpus (44)

• Streaming Instabilities in Protoplanetary Disks
• First Results from High Angular Resolution ALMA Observations Toward the HL Tau Region
• Athena: A New Code for Astrophysical MHD
• A simple model for the evolution of the dust population in protoplanetary disks
• The outcome of protoplanetary dust growth: pebbles, boulders, or planetesimals? II. Introducing the bouncing barrier
• The outcome of protoplanetary dust growth: pebbles, boulders, or planetesimals? I. Mapping the zoo of laboratory collision experiments
• The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): II. Characteristics of Annular Substructures
• Protoplanetary Disk Turbulence Driven by the Streaming Instability: Non-Linear Saturation and Particle Concentration
• Closed-form expressions for particle relative velocities induced by turbulence
• Zonal Flows and Long-Lived Axisymmetric Pressure Bumps in Magnetorotational Turbulence
• The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP) VI: Dust trapping in thin-ringed protoplanetary disks
• Trapping dust particles in the outer regions of protoplanetary disks
• Size-selective concentration of chondrules and other small particles in protoplanetary nebula turbulence
• The Mass and Size Distribution of Planetesimals Formed by the Streaming Instability. I. The Role of Self-Gravity
• Concentrating small particles in protoplanetary disks through the streaming instability
• Planetesimal formation starts at the snow line
• How to form planetesimals from mm-sized chondrules and chondrule aggregates
• The Effect of the Radial Pressure Gradient in Protoplanetary Disks on Planetesimal Formation
• Planetesimal formation by the streaming instability in a photoevaporating disk
• Thresholds for Particle Clumping by the Streaming Instability
• Magnetic Flux Concentration and Zonal Flows in Magnetorotational Instability Turbulence
• Gravoturbulent Planetesimal Formation: The Positive Effect of long-lived Zonal Flows
• Can photo-evaporation trigger planetesimal formation?
• Resistivity-driven State Changes in Vertically Stratified Accretion Disks
• Diffusion and Concentration of Solids in the Dead Zone of a Protoplanetary Disk
• Protoplanetary Disk Rings as Sites for Planetesimal Formation
• The DSHARP Rings: Evidence of Ongoing Planetesimal Formation?
• Streaming Instability in Turbulent Protoplanetary Disks
• How efficient is the streaming instability in viscous protoplanetary disks?
• Formation of planetary cores at Type I migration traps
• Turbulence Regulates the Rate of Planetesimal Formation via Gravitational Collapse
• On the Numerical Robustness of the Streaming Instability: Particle Concentration and Gas Dynamics in Protoplanetary Disks
• Efficiency of Particle Trapping in the Outer Regions of Protoplanetary Disks
• Dust and gas density evolution at a radial pressure bump in protoplanetary disks
• Rossby wave instability does not require sharp resistivity gradients
• Linear growth of streaming instability in pressure bumps
• Pebble trapping in vortices: three-dimensional simulations
• Physical models of streaming instabilities in protoplanetary disks
• Dust Settling and Clumping in MRI Turbulent Outer Protoplanetary Disks
• Vortices as nurseries for planetesimal formation in protoplanetary discs
• Solving grain size inconsistency between ALMA polarization and VLA continuum in the Ophiuchus IRS 48 protoplanetary disk
• Two key parameters controlling particle clumping caused by streaming instability in the dead-zone dust layer of a protoplanetary disk
• Resilience of Planetesimal Formation in Weakly-Reinforced Pressure Bumps
• Self-Sustaining Vortices in Protoplanetary Disks: Setting the Stage for Planetary System Formation

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Rapid Formation of Massive Planetary Cores in a Pressure Bump
• Disc population synthesis: Decrease in the solid mass reservoir through pebble drift
• The coexistence of the streaming instability and the vertical shear instability in protoplanetary disks: Planetesimal formation thresholds explored in two-dimensional global models
• CO2-rich protoplanetary discs as a probe of dust radial drift & trapping
• The impact of dynamic pressure bumps on the observational properties of protoplanetary disks
• Turbulent Dust-trapping Rings as Efficient Sites for Planetesimal Formation
• Establishing Dust Rings and Forming Planets Within Them
• Dust dynamics in RAMSES -- I. Methods and turbulent acceleration
• Instabilities in dusty non-isothermal proto-planetary discs
• The growth of super-large pre-planetary pebbles to an impact erosion limit
• Planetesimal formation via the streaming instability with multiple grain sizes
• Dust-gas dynamics driven by the streaming instability with various pressure gradients
• Planetesimal and planet formation in transient dust traps
• Millimeter emission in photoevaporating disks is determined by early substructures
• Forbidden planetesimals
• Formation of the First Planetesimals via the Streaming Instability in Globally Turbulent Protoplanetary Disks?
• Primordial dust rings, hidden dust mass, and the first generation of planetesimals in gravitationally unstable protoplanetary disks
• Clusters of heavy particles in two-dimensional Keplerian turbulence
• Clusters of tribocharged dust aggregates as pebbles in protoplanetary disks
• Evading the dust fragmentation barrier with the streaming instability in protoplanetary disks
• Dust-driven vortex cascades originating at water snow regions: A pathway to planetesimal formation
• Planetesimal gravitational collapse in a gaseous environment: Thermal and dynamic evolution